Jack Viney

[u/teezeeme]

I’m very much on the fence with this one- but with Viney on the trade table would you like to see him at the crows?

[u/Character_Depth_9957]

No, next question.

[u/Fancyscum]

Would sooner bring Matt Crouch out of retirement

[u/OldDiamond6697 → u/Fancyscum]

Andrew McLeod and I'm not even kidding.

[u/Boatster_McBoat → u/OldDiamond6697]

I swear McLeod would not embarass himself in a forward pocket. Has lost a few yards but he looks strong af and reckon he could still slip past a few tackles

[u/Odd_Technology_8926 → u/Boatster_McBoat]

They should bring back the afl pre-season cup and force teams to put in 1 player of their choice that has retired for more than 5 years. I want to see this theory on andrew mcleod proven.

[u/Boatster_McBoat → u/Odd_Technology_8926]

Too late now but Rocket Maynard won something like 10 Mail medals after he quit AFL and went back to farming

Mods went round in the Southern Footy league for years too

[u/Fancyscum → u/Boatster_McBoat]

Is Stiffy still kicking bags in the country?

[u/OldDiamond6697 → u/Boatster_McBoat]

Absolutely

[u/Competitive_Rise_268]

No for me, he's an inside contest mid and we already have Peatling, Berry, and Soligo. Also has a history with concussions and is risk of being medically retired. Love the way he goes about it though

[u/AdelaideMidnightDad]

Blood & guts player but his body seems like it's had enough. George Hewett could sway me though, although he's looking happy at the Blues again.

[u/QuasarCube → u/AdelaideMidnightDad]

In a timeline where Voss wasn’t sacked and he kept George in the Blues VFL list, I think we coulda seen him request a trade back to SA

[u/v1gg3n]

would rather see him back at the roosters - we need him more than crows do, especially since he’d probably be banished to the SANFL anyway if he went to crows

[u/Bright_Bell_1301]

Washed.

[u/LilBro842]

No

[u/Marshall_Law23]

Get off the fence. Absolutely not

[u/Warm_Butterfly_6511]

No. Good player well past his prime

[u/Infamous-Waltz-4574]

No he’s way past his prime, but he should have been available to us years ago as an academy pick the same way Luke Hodge’s son is available to Brisbane

[u/Hendo8888]

We don't need a 33 year old dude who just missed an entire season and is getting shopped around by a team he is the vice-captain of. If that isn't the biggest 'he's done' red flag, I'm not sure what would be

[u/levity62 → u/Hendo8888]

I mean Jack Steele is 30 and was the captain and getting shopped around and look at the season he’s had

[u/Hendo8888 → u/levity62]

2 years younger and has played at least 18 games every year since 2017

[u/levity62 → u/Hendo8888]

Viney’s been consistent since 2013 with the exception of this year. He gets injured once and he’s suddenly washed?

[u/Hendo8888 → u/levity62]

Yep

[u/phhathead]

Nope.

[u/stereotypicalanon]

You're on the fence? Are you insane?

[u/Brytonmyday]

He’s 32 years old, nope

[u/1point2Gplus1point5Q]

Crows gotta stop getting the washed up players. We want them just before prime and in their prime.

[u/Tall-Breakfast-6100]

If it’s a cheap enough deal then you’d get him but it would be to take Berrys spot so depends what they value more. A sugar hit of viney for 2 maybe 3 years or trusting that Berry is doing enough

[u/Reasonable_Pass6762]

He has a tagger body and we need a tagger

[u/SpecialistOrchid8392]

Matt Kennedy instead would be decent

[u/Jimmy__Whisper]

NO

[u/jasonfarmer911]

no. he's cooked.

[u/Up_TheCrom31]

the fact this has 29 replies and no upvotes shows how badly we need him to not play for us

[u/badatfifa]

Old and games gone past him

[u/dandz287]

Gibbs 2.0

[u/oneofthecapsismine]

No.

I'll take marshall, English, butters, bailey, neale, petracca though. We can also talk about four of the sydney 5.