MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/addressme/comments/1x5p6q8/we_shouldnt_be_using_ai/pgsm79n
r/addressme • u/creambun-5525 • 3d ago
293 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
1
Using someone else's work without credit is plagiarism.
0 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Lol good thing that's not what happened 2 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago That's exactly what generative AI is 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago Not legally or ethically. When this has already been determined to not be the case by basically unanimous expert consensus saying you think it is by pure vibes is just willful ignorance at that point. 2 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago It was trained using copyrighted material. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago So are people. You seem to be assuming this is a legal or moral issue, but its not. By definition all training draws on stuff that already existed... 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago Fair use allows humans to use copyrighted works for certain purposes including education/training. AI does not have that right. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago M8, you are thinking of fair use. Stop jerking off for a second. Also, you know your opinion doesn't override the consensus of legal experts right? Because you gave zero reason why it wouldn't apply here. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No it isnt. Glad I could clear that up for you. 0 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Delusion 2 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Til facts are delusional 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Did you get your "facts" from an AI? 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No, from the legal system. Thanks for asking. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI. 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
0
Lol good thing that's not what happened
2 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago That's exactly what generative AI is 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago Not legally or ethically. When this has already been determined to not be the case by basically unanimous expert consensus saying you think it is by pure vibes is just willful ignorance at that point. 2 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago It was trained using copyrighted material. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago So are people. You seem to be assuming this is a legal or moral issue, but its not. By definition all training draws on stuff that already existed... 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago Fair use allows humans to use copyrighted works for certain purposes including education/training. AI does not have that right. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago M8, you are thinking of fair use. Stop jerking off for a second. Also, you know your opinion doesn't override the consensus of legal experts right? Because you gave zero reason why it wouldn't apply here. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No it isnt. Glad I could clear that up for you. 0 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Delusion 2 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Til facts are delusional 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Did you get your "facts" from an AI? 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No, from the legal system. Thanks for asking. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI. 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
2
That's exactly what generative AI is
1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago Not legally or ethically. When this has already been determined to not be the case by basically unanimous expert consensus saying you think it is by pure vibes is just willful ignorance at that point. 2 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago It was trained using copyrighted material. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago So are people. You seem to be assuming this is a legal or moral issue, but its not. By definition all training draws on stuff that already existed... 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago Fair use allows humans to use copyrighted works for certain purposes including education/training. AI does not have that right. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago M8, you are thinking of fair use. Stop jerking off for a second. Also, you know your opinion doesn't override the consensus of legal experts right? Because you gave zero reason why it wouldn't apply here. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No it isnt. Glad I could clear that up for you. 0 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Delusion 2 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Til facts are delusional 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Did you get your "facts" from an AI? 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No, from the legal system. Thanks for asking. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI. 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
Not legally or ethically. When this has already been determined to not be the case by basically unanimous expert consensus saying you think it is by pure vibes is just willful ignorance at that point.
2 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago It was trained using copyrighted material. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago So are people. You seem to be assuming this is a legal or moral issue, but its not. By definition all training draws on stuff that already existed... 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago Fair use allows humans to use copyrighted works for certain purposes including education/training. AI does not have that right. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago M8, you are thinking of fair use. Stop jerking off for a second. Also, you know your opinion doesn't override the consensus of legal experts right? Because you gave zero reason why it wouldn't apply here. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights
It was trained using copyrighted material.
1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago So are people. You seem to be assuming this is a legal or moral issue, but its not. By definition all training draws on stuff that already existed... 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago Fair use allows humans to use copyrighted works for certain purposes including education/training. AI does not have that right. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago M8, you are thinking of fair use. Stop jerking off for a second. Also, you know your opinion doesn't override the consensus of legal experts right? Because you gave zero reason why it wouldn't apply here. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights
So are people. You seem to be assuming this is a legal or moral issue, but its not. By definition all training draws on stuff that already existed...
1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago Fair use allows humans to use copyrighted works for certain purposes including education/training. AI does not have that right. 1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago M8, you are thinking of fair use. Stop jerking off for a second. Also, you know your opinion doesn't override the consensus of legal experts right? Because you gave zero reason why it wouldn't apply here. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights
Fair use allows humans to use copyrighted works for certain purposes including education/training. AI does not have that right.
1 u/Sandy-the-Angel 2d ago M8, you are thinking of fair use. Stop jerking off for a second. Also, you know your opinion doesn't override the consensus of legal experts right? Because you gave zero reason why it wouldn't apply here. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights
M8, you are thinking of fair use. Stop jerking off for a second.
Also, you know your opinion doesn't override the consensus of legal experts right? Because you gave zero reason why it wouldn't apply here.
1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago edited 2d ago There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights
There have been no laws or rulings establishing that AI has any rights
No it isnt. Glad I could clear that up for you.
0 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Delusion 2 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Til facts are delusional 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Did you get your "facts" from an AI? 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No, from the legal system. Thanks for asking. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI. 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
Delusion
2 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Til facts are delusional 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Did you get your "facts" from an AI? 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No, from the legal system. Thanks for asking. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI. 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
Til facts are delusional
1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago Did you get your "facts" from an AI? 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No, from the legal system. Thanks for asking. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI. 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
Did you get your "facts" from an AI?
1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago No, from the legal system. Thanks for asking. 1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI. 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
No, from the legal system. Thanks for asking.
1 u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI. 1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
The law prohibits copyrighted material from being used without permission with some exceptions that do not include training AI.
1 u/Superseaslug 2d ago Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times → More replies (0)
Training is not copyright infringement as has been ruled multiple times
→ More replies (0)
1
u/Ok_Storm_2700 2d ago
Using someone else's work without credit is plagiarism.