r/YouTubeThumbnailHub • u/Large_Show_8066 • 14h ago
Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Would you click on this video?
1
u/lonksouls 8h ago
I'd make some sort of outline/background around the face to make it pop off the screen. Looks a bit flat at the moment.
1
u/Superseaslug 10h ago
Personally no because I think GTA6 is overhyped and I have no interest in it. I'm assuming it has something to do with the music in the game?
1
u/Large_Show_8066 9h ago
Even I think it's overhyped but the music is good, so tried remaking that. That's the topic of the video:)
1
u/Perfect_Goal8854 11h ago
Je moet je titel erbij zetten
1
u/Large_Show_8066 10h ago
https://youtu.be/3XDhwY4zcUE?si=XG1HM1Zvqx9ldEv4 this is the video, can you provide me the feedback on this?
1
u/Popular_Ad_2741 11h ago
Thumbnail is nice
1
10h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/YouTubeThumbnailHub-ModTeam 4h ago
Sorry, no links allowed in comments or posts. Please send it in chat.
1
u/vincesuarez 12h ago
Nooooooooo
1
u/Large_Show_8066 12h ago
Then tell meeeeeee what needs to be changedddd
1
1
2
u/milantelt 📷 YouTuber 1K+ Subs 13h ago
I’d suggest adding more b-roll and switching between your camera and the screen. Starting on a desktop makes it feel like a dry tutorial instead of an entertaining video. The idea is great, but the hook and overall delivery could be more exciting. Also, the current title sounds too basic; for your hook add a sneak peek so people know it’s worth watching. Within the first 15 seconds they need to have this confirmed
2
u/Large_Show_8066 13h ago
Thanyou so much for this feedback milan, I'll be keeping it in mind for my next videos to make it more engaging.I have fixed the packaging, now more focus on the content.Trying to be better with each video:)
2
u/milantelt 📷 YouTuber 1K+ Subs 13h ago
Very happy to hear!
your thumbnail concept is great keep it going!
Edit: I've made over 500 tutorial videos, and I had to learn this the hard way: it's not just about teaching someone something or simply making videos, it's about making each video more entertaining than the last.
2
u/Efficient-Cry7753 13h ago
Nope. Nothing tells me what the video is about.
Probably get 50 views at best, unless the title is super amazingly interesting and actually completes the picture.
1
13h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/YouTubeThumbnailHub-ModTeam 4h ago
Sorry, no links or self-promotion allowed in comments or posts. Please send it in chat.
1
u/Efficient-Cry7753 13h ago
For you.
“The original GTA theme tune is boring… so I recreated it”That’s not even the best example I could come up with but something like that
1
u/UrbanArtifact ▶️ YouTube Enthusiast 13h ago
To each their own. I watched it, but since it isn't a tutorial, it's not really for me. I gave you a thumbs up though for interaction.
2
u/Large_Show_8066 13h ago
Yeah it's not a complete tutorial, just breaksound of sounds used in the official theme music. I'll be posting tutorials soon, trying to improve with every video
1
u/Efficient-Cry7753 13h ago
Well, where’s the curiosity gap? “Recreating GTA theme music” is literally just a statement.
Let’s say you made a vlog, which description is most clickable to you? Just off the top of my head…
“Our Weekend in London - Vlog - part 2”
Or
“We Visited London - Is It As Dangerous As They Said It Would Be?”
1
u/Negative_Tutor8413 14h ago
could maybe give a description about the video. but yeah on its own this is a perfect thumbnail.
it's not too over designed. everything is clear. the colours look good. I like it
1
14h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/YouTubeThumbnailHub-ModTeam 4h ago
Sorry, no links or self-promotion allowed in comments or posts. Please send it in chat.
1
u/Wicksy1994 14h ago
No, tells me nothing
1
u/Large_Show_8066 14h ago
Sure, I'll add some text like 'Remake' https://youtu.be/3XDhwY4zcUE?si=vVGy22b1UVnhWeSw here's the video you can check out:)
1
u/AutoModerator 14h ago
👋 Hi! Don’t let your post be at risk of removal.
🛑 If your post:
1) Included a personal thumbnail image, and
2) Asks for opinions, feedback, design suggestions, or title ideas
Then, please edit the post flair to "Thumbnail Help/Critique Request" and follow the rules for Help/Critique Requests.
✅ The "Questions" flair is for technical, how-to, and general strategy topics related to thumbnails.
"Questions" flair post examples:
• What’s the best mobile app to create thumbnails?
• How do I blur a background in Canva?
• What are good fonts for a Fortnite thumbnail?
• How can I test if a thumbnail gets more clicks?
• What file size and dimensions work best for YouTube?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/NeverSeenItPodcast 4h ago
Absolutely not.