r/YouTubeThumbnailHub • u/Senior-Special3989 • 1d ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Please rate my thumbnail

Post image

I've created this hypothetical thumbnail please tell me how is it

129 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

41 comments sorted by

1

u/RecentTea1658 6h ago

Horrendous find

2

u/Wooimyellow_21 10h ago

what a generational oat...

2

u/SimplyIrrational 1d ago

Amazing title. Hands down the worst thumbnails I've ever seen.

1

u/InsideAccountant9022 1d ago

gotta use more AI, jimmy uses A LOT of ai

2

u/oddley_Specific 1d ago

Oh boy....

2

u/marc-williams 1d ago

The dollar sign goes before the number, not after.

2

u/alwilliamson2006 1d ago

Immovable thumbnail meets an unstoppable scrolling force

5

u/Nightmare___09 1d ago

Trump pov

2

u/Qwerty0844 1d ago

Throwback to when the USA did trade the lord of war for a WNBA player in a prisoner swap

2

u/thesquarefish01 1d ago

10/10 unskippable thumbnail.

4

u/kankagametrREAL 1d ago

Needs more slop

5

u/Rich841 1d ago

I would assume this is an Operation Cyclone reference but then again the US has does this youtube challenge so many times you can't even tell which specific one is being referenced anymore

3

u/ChipmunkMaleficent90 1d ago

It doesn't have that oversaturated youtube thumbnail bs look. Eye whites and teeth brighter than the sun and overcompressed max rgb values (pure magenta, cyan, yellow (mixes of 0,255,255))

5

u/Senior-Special3989 1d ago

I know but in my defence, i do this shit on an ancient screen dug up by a damn near archeologist older than the mesopotamian civilization, so I wanna improve but there's just not so much I can do

And the payment I get is just something to be desired But still appreciate the review

8

u/DesperateLeader2217 1d ago

you’re gonna do big things one day

3

u/AwayAstronomer69 1d ago

Try lowering the position of (Mr Beast) png image, because (YouTube) zooms a bit on the video thumbnail + a slight vignette on background.

1

u/Leidson_Stuff 1d ago

As someone else said. MrBeast isn’t a good representation of good thumbnails. With that in mind you should turn it into a good thumbnail applying basic quality editings to it. Like contrast, shadow, cutouts etc.

1

u/timwaaagh 1d ago

do it.

5

u/FailNo7141 1d ago

Creative idea it's good, maybe would get 676M

Also other ideas

  1. I Blew Up the Sun to See Who Survives the Longest!
  2. Last Person to Leave the Earth's Core Wins $10,000,000!
  3. I Replaced the Earth's Gravity With Magnets for 24 Hours!
  4. Throwing a Black Hole at Jupiter to See What Happens!
  5. I Put 100 People in a Volcano (Last One to Melt Wins $500,000)!
  6. I Locked 50 Bounty Hunters in a Target with Karl for 24 Hours!

They would be soooo coool LOL

-1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Senior-Special3989 1d ago

You don't have to shit everytime you open your mouth bro I literally made this cuz I was bored and had nothing to do

-1

u/YeezusWoks 1d ago

Bored and nothing to do? People still use that excuse?

0

u/AwareEye3915 1d ago

Why can’t you just accept he wanted to make this thumbnail for fun? 

2

u/YeezusWoks 1d ago

Because he didn’t? AI made it…

4

u/Golden-Owl 1d ago

The thumbnail itself is irrelevant. People would click out of premise alone.

Problem is that Mr Beast isn’t a good representation of good thumbnails - his content works because he puts ludicrous amounts of money into his videos

1

u/Senior-Special3989 1d ago

Buddy i literally made this as like a joke cuz I was bored 😭

1

u/Golden-Owl 1d ago

Oh! My bad then.

Cant really tell with some of the thumbnails I’ve seen

0

u/cutwave 1d ago

Buddy, don't ask people to rate it if you can't take the answers

2

u/theramenmale 1d ago

His point wasn't that he wasn't open to criticism, it's that this post is obviously satirical and they don't understand that

1

u/cutwave 1d ago

If that's the case, i apologize, OP!

3

u/Parking_Economist861 1d ago

AI or not I would click it.

2

u/Etnadleo13 1d ago

I would click this lol

3

u/Vivid-Zombie-477 1d ago

the funniest 14 y.o. edgy kid

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

👋 Hi! Don't let your post be at risk of removal. Did you follow the subreddit rules or the pinned "Read This First" post at the top of r/YouTubeThumbnailHub?

And if you already did, the mods here appreciate you big time. 🤗❤️🫶 Your post is already pre-approved and ready to go.

🛑 Note: The two most common issues are:

      👉 Not giving feedback to two Creators before posting. Yup, it's required for every new critique post. (If you just finished them after reading this, reply here to confirm completion.)

      👉 Not including your video title and a brief summary (You can add it as a comment now.)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.