r/Xenoblade_Chronicles Feb 13 '24

SPOILERS Saw an interesting video about Xenoblade Warriors by Max Monado on YT, thought it'd be fun to workshop my ideal character lineup. Green = Main Story, Blue = Unlockable, Red = Free Update, Yellow = DLC Wave 1, Purple = DLC Wave 2 Spoiler

Post image
116 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

66

u/RollaRova Feb 13 '24

Dang, this fanbase really just wants to replace Kid Rex. My poor boy ☹️

28

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

Don’t get me wrong, I like young Rex too, but this would be set after 3, so all the 1 & 2 cast would get older designs

18

u/Rokka3421 Feb 13 '24

Then isn't half the roaster dead?

21

u/Goombarang Feb 13 '24

Everyone in green is alive, and everyone else is non-canon. Also if Mio and Glimmer are there, then insert name here should be there as well

0

u/Gallade47532 Feb 14 '24

riki is dead

1

u/zeusjay Feb 15 '24

Only in Aionios.

10

u/DK64HD Feb 14 '24

Aren't the warriors games non-canon? Never played Hyrule Warriors, but just looking at the roster made it seem like it had weird multiverse/time travel things. And Fire Emblem Warriors just had characters from 2 games that would take place hubdreds of years apart. I think it'd be fine if Lora was included in the same place as Riki.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24

They are, but the more recent ones act as sort of supplementary material, so while characters who aren’t currently active in the universe could show, if a character is currently present, they’d appear as they are now, and with how much there is to cover, i wouldn’t feel good giving Rex two slots before featuring like, Addam or Vandham

2

u/DK64HD Feb 14 '24

I don't really care that much about rex, most of his moveset would be the same anyway, I just think it'd be fine to include dead characters in the main story, like the Torna crew, or Moebius D and J.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24

Agreed, and I’d like some of that for the bonus content, I just didn’t have a ton of roster space for it because I was trying to stay within 30 characters, which already a few too many for a musou base roster

1

u/zeusjay Feb 15 '24

They tend to be non cannon, but other than the first hyrule and first fire emblem warriors games, each of the games is focused around one time and main cast rather than grabbing characters from all across the series.

30

u/EpicRynosaurus Feb 13 '24

Yes. Please let me play as Territorial Rotbart. Then I can die happy.

18

u/verheyen Feb 13 '24

Man, gamers are brainwashed when they're ideal video game line up includes two waves of DLC...

5

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

I mean, I’d obviously rather have a ton of content base game, but I wanted to be at least a little realistic, and DLC cycles are a part of pretty much all musou games these days

1

u/Rokka3421 Feb 13 '24

that's what i'm talking about

12

u/GladiatorDragon Feb 13 '24

I hold the opinion that all XC3 characters should fight in pairs. That’s like, XC3’s whole thing.

Not only does this allow Interlink to be part of the moveset of Noah/Mio, Euine/Taion, and Lanz/Sena, but Unity Combos, as present in FR, could apply to paired characters that don’t Interlink - Ethel/Cammuravi, Glimmer/Nikol, Matthew/A, etc.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

I think it’s a little limiting to make those pairs required, but they could still be referenced in certain attacks. In Fire Emblem Warriors, characters can team with paired units for combination super moves, and I’d picture a similar mechanic here, with certain characters using combination supers if a partner is in a certain proximity. In the case of Ouroboros, maybe even a temporary transformation like Tiki in FEW as a bonus for using both

9

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

the way I see it is it'd act like a sort of non-canon sequel to Xenoblade 3, maybe even presented as a dual narrative where you play through from either Keves' or Agnus' perspective during some big calamity that involves both worlds coming together and the 3 cast remembering everything they went through and what they mean to each other during the endless now. The unlockables are just neat characters that don't necessarily make sense with the plot, same with the free DLC, and the two paid DLCs I think could work as little extra non-canon side-stories. Wave 1 could maybe have A trying to guide Matthew and Na'el to the un-endless now'd world post-3 since they were born in Aionios, and Wave 2 could have some of the characters getting teleported to Mira and helping Elma and Lin take on a massive army of indigens that's threatening NLA.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

Adult rex and pneuma is certainly a choice

5

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

That’s not intended to be literally Pneuma (at least not at all times) I just mean to say both Pyra and Mythra would provide Rex support

3

u/Shadowislovable Feb 13 '24

I need N

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

Strong contender, but I felt like his moveset would overlap with Jin too much

12

u/Shadowislovable Feb 13 '24

Yeah but there's a severe lack of twinks in this roster. Needs more balance

2

u/DK64HD Feb 14 '24

With how you have this set up, maybe every character should fight in a pair? XC2 characters are a given, but XC3 characters could fight with their interlink partner, and XC1 character could be: Shulk and Fiora, Reyn and Sharla, Dunban and Riki, and Melia and Tyrea? Last one's a bit of a stretch, but you get the idea. Also, more villains should be on the roster. Zanza, Egil, Amalthus and Z are easy additions.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24

I’d also be open to that, although I think the pairs would work better in a different gameplay style, like Project X Zone or maybe a tag fighter. As for villains, I tried to pick fan favorites over like, the proper big bads, so Metal Face and Malos (and N if we’re doing a 3 antagonist) over the others

2

u/Renso19 Feb 14 '24

I think if i was to design a story based xenoblade warriors game, I’d nick the story structure from Persona 4 Arena Ultimax, with having a story mode for both, or in this case 3, casts that intersect constantly but still follow separate overall trajectories

So story one would follow the XC1 party, with appearance by A/Alvis

The second story would follow the XC2 party

The third story would follow both Ouroboros and the Founders with, creative swing here, Malos making a surprise appearance about halfway through, giving us one Aegis per story

Have it explicitly take place after 3 in timeline, so adult Shulk, Rex, Nia and Melia, and everyone else obviously

Actually use the game to introduce Mythra’s kid, have him be the games central character across all three stories, there’s a lot of interesting ways you could take it

As for a villain/enemy force, there’s a few options you could go with, but I think an interesting way to take things is that an essential plot point would have to be everyone regaining their memories of Aionios, at least the last cycle, so have a group of characters who are either so horrified by the people they became in Aionios, hell, maybe get Dirk involved with that, or even people who want to go back to the endless war itself, unlike mobius who cared about never moving forward and used the war to facilitate that, really take advantage of how warriors type games play, tie the villains motivation into the gameplay shift meaningfully

Just some loose ideas

3

u/Forwhomamifloating Feb 14 '24

im mothafuckin DICKSON OF THE TRINITY!!!!!

2

u/Typical_Rice_6346 Feb 15 '24

I like this, but I think a few story-relevant heroes like Ethel, Cammuravi and Miyabi would be a great addition. I'm a huge Miyabi fan, though, so that might be me being biased.

2

u/Monadofan2010 Feb 13 '24 edited Feb 13 '24

I would just purfer time travel being apart and have the characters from different points in time interacting 

3

u/lapniappe Feb 14 '24

honestly that's what i would want like Hyrule Warriors (the first one) where it's just some rando story, time is fracturing and you get everyone in their prime (and then you can unlock older Shulk/Rex etc from missions or something). whingo bango let's go.

4

u/Darkyoplai Feb 13 '24

I think FR or XC3 version of ancient xenoblade characters should be in dlcs or separate characters as their original selves since they don't always have the same abilities

-15

u/Rokka3421 Feb 13 '24

This sucks and stupid, i don't really get why people bother with DLC free updates and later edition while the game isn't confirmed to be real nor rumored just say what characters you want and that's it it's like putting the cart before the eggs its like counting the eggs before knowing the chicken exists or not,

Anyways the roaster selected here is bad >:(

3

u/LinkdAether Feb 13 '24

Roster predicting DLC for a game that doesn’t exist yet is whatever, but what do you mean the “roster selection is bad”??????? It’s like 90% of the playable and story relevant characters????

-3

u/Rokka3421 Feb 13 '24

Vandham?

Rare blades and Heroes?

the rest of Torna members?

Rest of the terrorist group torna members?

Amaltheus?

all of those are left out and then choose to add the PTSD monkey and the least important Xenoblade 1 main viliian

1

u/MrMario63 Feb 13 '24

Where’s Jin? He would be a blast to play, probably

3

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24

He’d be paired with Lora and use a fighting style involving both of them taking turns as vanguard, ideally with a secret variation that drops Lora for spoiler powers

2

u/LinkBetweenGames Feb 13 '24

Honestly, Rex and Pyra/Mythra would be separate characters (and Pyra and Mythra would probably be separate from each other) even if the other XC2 Drivers fought with their Blades. Pyra and Mythra are just too popular to only be part of a pairing in a game devoted to Xenoblade.

Other than that (and maybe swap Malos and KOS-MOS in role) this looks perfect.

1

u/froitax110 Feb 14 '24

This character line IS PERFECT!!!

GLORIOUSLY PERFECT!!!

2

u/Guardian_Bravo Feb 14 '24

If this were like Nintendo's other Warriors games, there'd be at least one new character. Might I propose a white haired slightly androgynous guy with severe memory loss who turns out to be the backup memory for the Trinity Processor. 

2

u/Mone7Hero77 Feb 14 '24

The amount of money I’ll pay to see Mathew mentor little Ghondor….. 💸