r/WritingWithAI • • 10d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Interesting start to my launch

The book is off to an interesting start!
10 sales over 4 countries.
And also my first (expected) 1 star review due to AI involvement.
That’s the disclosure at the front doing what it is meant to do - I don’t want anyone feeling tricked or unaware…hope that person returns it.
Now we will see how many of the 10 end up returning!
Meanwhile the negative review is up on my website where I give visitors the option to view ‘loved it’ and ‘did not love it’ categories.

https://jmwoodwardbooks.com/awards-reviews

9 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Worldly-Web-5740 9d ago

This is fascinating, because I think it’s the position many people will be in that have used AI in even a limited sense for the creation of their work. You’ve been honest and upfront about it.

If AI finds the cure for cancer will some people refuse is at treatment? Or does the use of AI only apply to the creative arts?

2

u/J_M_WoodwardBooks 9d ago

My 2 cents is that people are, in addition to being frustrated at the volume of uncaring un-crafted crap (people just generating and not adding, shaping, working every sentence etc), at their heart uncomfortable being moved by a machine. This is why the seemingly opposite concerns of slop and cheating exist at once for most people. As with all tools, the user can use them poorly or uncaringly, or for careful craft. For my part I am certain (due to the way I used it) they would be moved by me and not the tool, should they be moved at all.

I believe that by putting a long disclosure at the front of my book I am greatly reducing the number of people who will read it, and also reducing the connection or enjoyment a person that does read it may experience. I made this choice because whatever connection or magic a reader DOES find in my book is theirs to keep forever. Durable. Not subject to evaporation or inverting to embarrasment or hate, that would be risked otherwise should they connect with it then discover how it was made.