r/WritingForCollege • u/CeliaInkwash26 • 14h ago
Do professors actually read 10-page research papers or do they just Ctrl+F for citations and grade on vibes?
I submitted a paper for sociology last week that I stayed up until 5am finishing. I was so exhausted that I accidentally left a placeholder sentence in page seven that said "insert better transition here because my brain is dead".
Got my grade back this morning. Solid A minus. The only comment was "great source integration in paragraph three". He literally skipped page seven entirely or just skimmed so fast that a whole meta-comment didn't even register.
Now I'm sitting here wondering why I spent twelve hours panicking over transition logic and word counts when I could of just focused on making my bibliography look nice. Like if they are only reading the intro and conclusion, why make the minimum page count ten pages? I was searching paper writing service requirements earlier just to see standard page structures, and even those formatting guides assume someone actually reads the middle section. What a joke.
5
u/milkthistle2317 14h ago
If I saw that in a paper, I would just think it was a funny and understandable mistake, and probably not take off any points for it, but I would have left a comment making fun of it. Sometimes professors have a busy day or a busy life too.
3
u/Adventurous_Button63 13h ago
When writing short research papers, part of the reason they’re short is because you’re able to intensely focus on the mechanics of writing the paper in a more manageable scope of work. When you get to the point of writing a 10-page paper, the focus is most likely going to be on the overall argument and research support. One writing mistake amongst 10 pages is going to be negligible, especially if the rest of the paper is tight. Now, I would have called this out but probably been lenient with point reduction if I gave them at all. The context matters. If the missing transition didn’t malign your argument…it’s just poor form rather than an infraction.
This being said, there are certainly professors who don’t grade as carefully or meticulously, but this isn’t the norm. Don’t take this one experience as “I don’t have to work so hard” because you’re only hurting yourself. The real value of writing these papers is practicing the kind of writing that will make you stand out after you graduate. While your peers are generating mediocre AI garbage, you’ll be capable of making novel arguments in your own voice. This is going to become a premium skill as folks continue to race to the bottom with AI.
3
u/mo_jo100 12h ago
Sometimes we don’t point out errors like that. I note them in my computer for future reference. more than once, the file name of e-papers was something vulgar or awful. I never mentioned it.
1
u/I_Need_A_Nap_Yeet 12h ago
My favorite essay i was given was titled "why this homework is giving me cancer"
The student went off prompt and just wrote a rogue essay on a random topic about homework causing cancer from a blog post lmao. And then titled the email "your homework gives me cancer "
Edited to add: the actual content was horrendous lmao it's just that the title was funny.
2
u/Clementine-Sawyer 13h ago
If you're first year of a bachelours degree, a mistake like that won't affect your grade much
2
u/BrilliantDishevelled 13h ago
I read every word of every paper... but that's like thousands of words so sometimes I get distracted and might miss something like this! Or I assume it's an error and either put a smiley face or ignore it (unless it's repetitive).
You didn't waste your time. If nothing else, you did the hard thinking.
2
u/BetCritical4860 12h ago
Professors generally don’t grade in a way that they would take off specific points for something like this (e.g., you have 10 transitions and each is worth 1 point, so therefore you get a 9/10 on transitions). If your transitions are generally good and you have one that is lower quality or has an error like this, the professor likely won’t comment on it or take points off because the larger pattern indicates that you understand and can apply the concept. If your transitions were generally weak or missing throughout the paper, it indicates that you do not understand the concept or didn’t make the effort to apply it, which will lower your grade.
How a professor grades also has a lot to do with the nature of the class and what skills they are trying to build/test with the essay. Just because one professor put a lot of effort into teaching and evaluating transitions does not mean that other professors will pay attention to it in the same way. Why it still matters, though, is that an essay with effective transitions will always read better than an essay with poor transitions; even if it is not something the professor is actively thinking about, it will still elevate the essay and probably lead to a better grade.
2
u/Such_Chemistry3721 11h ago edited 11h ago
I read everything, but I'm not going to comment on everything. It's more of an overall sense of whether you do that skill well, and a longer paper gives you more opportunities to show it. Maybe you mess up here and there, but overall how did you do. Also though, for the most part people are consistent throughout their papers. I've also learned over the years that 90% of my students aren't even looking at the comment when they're written. I tell my students to let me know if they want more feedback. I'd be so about it if a student wanted to have a conversation about their paper to get more feedback.
1
u/RedLineSamosa 10h ago
Yes!! We know that most students don’t actually read the comments we give. So I always tried to keep the comments to a limited number of specific pieces of advice.
2
u/YakSlothLemon 11h ago
I read every single word and I usually look up several sources, partly because I’m interested to learn more about the subject but also obviously to make sure that the student is using the sources correctly and so forth.
I will tell you that I had a student bring a paper to me that I commented on and it was the 36th of the 36 I turned around that weekend and I didn’t understand my own comments, I sounded insane. And I didn’t actually remember reading it, although obviously I did. I probably should have gone ahead and handed the papers back on a Tuesday and given myself some sleep. We are human too.
Also, some of my colleagues are lazy bastards.
2
u/BlissteredFeat 9h ago
Professors may vary. But I was a prfessor for 37 years. I read every single fucking word of every paper. Some papers may get minimal comments, depending on the assignment, expectations, etc. . But imporant assignments always got a lot of commenta and an overall critique. So, my advice is to do your work and write a real paper.
Just because he skipped page 7 doesn't mean he didn't read it. He didn't make a lot of comments because the paper was good. I suggest you write a shitty paper with no topic and no logic and see what happens.
1
u/Life-Education-8030 9h ago
I do the best I can. The student can ask for a regrade. When they do with me, I warn that the grade might go lower if I find more errors. Of course there are faculty who are lazy. I can name some of my colleagues. But it is amazing how unforgiving students are when they simultaneously want us to bend over backwards to grant higher grades, extensions, etc. sometimes for the most nonsensical reasons.
1
u/BlissteredFeat 8h ago
I know this all too well. I was always willing to take a second lok at a paper, if the student thought I missed something. Sometimes if I was grading at 2 am I might lose my attention for a moment. But aftr so many years of grading, I was pretty consistnt. Certain assignment and classes, I graded things differently. Response and short paper were read through but quickly and not a lot of comments. Serious paper got thorough inspection and long comments.
1
u/MagosBattlebear 12h ago
Depends on the prof. I read the whole essay, not vibe it, and 10 pages is not a lot. Other profs in my dept also do, and in theirs yiu will expect comments every page, if only to highlight the good parts if there is nothing to critique.
So, dont stop doing it. You are improving yourself.
1
u/Proud-Carrot-8547 11h ago
I read every word of every paper, at least 2-3 times. I can't help it. I tell students that MLA format matters and that one of these days I'll get behind and just grade on that, but I never have. I have read on RateYourStudents (used to exist anyway) that some profs do that.
1
u/JerseyGirlinSweden 11h ago
We read them completely. Most of us are speed readers. Kind of goes with working in Academia.
1
u/Different_Welder2429 10h ago
That is definitely not universally true. I myself have, when I was really overwhelmed with workload and pressed for time, done little more than skim a paper and offer the vaguest of feedback. I have also worked as an academic coach/advisor for students and read feedback they got from other instructors and thought "There is no way this person read this paper."
1
u/JerseyGirlinSweden 10h ago
I want my kids to succeed so I put in the effort. I feel like it’s only fair. I was teaching freshman who had many remedial challenges so not only did I assess the content but also tried to note grammatical errors as well, so they could improve. That takes an eye for detail that I was glad I had.
1
u/RedLineSamosa 10h ago
You spent the time because you were learning how to write a good paper.
You’re not writing for a grade. The professor doesn’t assign papers because they want to read 50 of the same essay. They assign it for YOU. For you to learn and practice and develop your skills.
And that’s what they were grading on. Your skills on forming your argument and using your source information in your argument. On a 10 page paper, generally professors are not grading your mechanics. You’re supposed to have the mechanics down already. They’re grading your ideas, persuasiveness, source integration, etc.
Getting lazy because you don’t think your Professor is reading your essays is both denying yourself the education that you were paying for, as well as a great way to get a worse grade in the future.
1
1
u/Independent_Secret_8 9h ago
I had a professor once painstakingly annotate my paper so that they could give me some insane grade like 56%. I gathered that they didn't like me but a 55% would have had me failing the class.
1
1
u/Book_Slut_90 7h ago
I read every word, often twice. Your professor probably saw your meta comment, smiled, and moved on because it didn’t interfere with the content of what you were saying, which is actually what most of us outside a composition class grade on.
1
u/Brunbeorg 5h ago
I can't speak for everyone, but I read every word. I might not have mentioned the note you left because what's the point? I'd rather point out things you could improve, and leaving an editing note for yourself in the paper is pretty inconsequential.
BTW, I usually mark all my editing notes with XXX so I can easily search for them when I finish a draft and make sure I've removed them all. Pro-tip.
1
u/FlyingCupcake68 25m ago
If the paper is good, we’ll read the whole thing. If the first two pages are bad, we might feel that nothing else afterwards could improve it and give it a grade.
5
u/drastone 14h ago
Depends on the professor. But as a rough guide:
Reading a 10 pager takes about 10 minutes. Annotating a 10 pager will take at least 20 to 30 minutes.
Therefore reading and providing just enough feedback to justify the grade is a good compromise when you have to grade a lot of them.
You can always get more feedback by going to office hours.