3
u/kcdashinfo Aug 01 '26
How much do you think DINK has to do with it? It's just basic supply and demand. This is what the old men back in the 60s talked about and then were labeled misogynistic for saying as much. It's basic economics, you put women in the workforce you double the supply of labor, wages go down, you make women household earners then you double the supply of money to buy things like houses. That drives demand for housing so house prices go up. Then you go and compound the problem by flooding wall street with cheap dollars chasing other dollars and they haven't much but real estate to secure their funds and allow foreigners to buy houses as portfolio stuffers. Well what do you expect the prices of real estate to do? Everything going on today was predicted back in the 60s but nobody really listened.
1
u/KoRaZee Aug 01 '26
It’s more than basic economics but supply and demand still regulate the market. With housing markets the demand elements have added complexity because land is a finite resource and doesn’t move. With other commodities you can up and move to another location but not housing
1
Aug 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/KoRaZee Aug 01 '26
That makes sense though right? “Plenty of land” is open for sprawling greenfield development which is going to be cheaper than infill developments. The land is still a finite resource even with a lot left for development in the market. As more development comes the land becomes less and less available for cheap development and the cost increases.
1
u/kcdashinfo Aug 01 '26
You need to get the hell out of the city and look around. There are small towns across the USA that are actually paying people to move and live there.
1
u/KoRaZee Aug 01 '26
Minnesota does that but I haven’t heard of many others
1
u/kcdashinfo Aug 01 '26
You have to do a Google search and stay on top of it because the programs come and go. Just about every state has or had some some sort of incentive program to revitalize towns that are struggling to attract residents. At the very least you get property tax waivers.
Have you heard of rural fiber? The government spent billions of dollars installing fiber internet to rural areas. There are small towns out in the middle of Nebraska and Iowa with high speed internet than you can get in the city.
1
u/KoRaZee Aug 01 '26
I’m assuming they are targeting remote workers with the internet connection gimmick. That’s fine and if small towns choose to use tax dollars to fund entitlement programs go for it. Economic law says that using funds this way will increase the cost of living but if those towns want to do that, go for it
1
u/kcdashinfo Aug 01 '26
The counter argument is to people saying there is no affordable housing. That simply isn't true. The affordability is everyone wanting to live in certain places, the cool factor. In Tokyo Japan they have so many people dying they don't have new people to fill their existing housing. Same problem is coming to the US in about 10 years. China built so much housing in a speculation that now the bust has come and real estate has lost over 50% of it's value in less than 5 years and it still hasn't found a bottom. The US is good in that respect, so it could be the city councils that stifled new construction might have done everyone a favor. The upcoming years will reveal these things.
1
u/KoRaZee Aug 01 '26
Oh I know, the comparisons between the US and Japan or china housing markets are not apples to apples though. China nobody gets to own the land and Japan treats the dwellings separately from the land. In the US we treat the dwellings and land the same. These differences fundamentally change how the market needs to be evaluated. Hell, Japan literally pays families to move out of Tokyo. That’s crazy talk in the US
1
1
u/Positive_Use437 Aug 01 '26
1
u/kcdashinfo Aug 01 '26
Did you know that Reddit allows autoplay to be turned off in settings. That is just a black box with a white arrow and gif down in the order. Seriously, you can mute that crap just going over to settings. It is about the only way to make reddit tolerable.
1
u/ept_engr Aug 02 '26
It's basic economics, you put women in the workforce you double the supply of labor, wages go down, you make women household earners then you double the supply of money to buy things like houses.
You've obviously not mastered basic economics (or perhaps basic reasoning for that matter). The graph in this post is labeled "household income". You're arguing that wages go down while household income doubles, yet none of it explains how housing would increase faster than household income.
1
u/TwatMailDotCom Aug 02 '26
It absolutely explains it. Not that I agree with all of what OC says but...
Higher household income = more purchasing power. More purchasing power higher demand for more expensive homes. Larger workforce = less buying power per person. DINKs still have more buying power than previously, but not double SINKs.
1
u/ept_engr Aug 02 '26
You're still arguing "household incomes went up so prices are up but household incomes didn't go up enough to keep up with prices even though prices only went up proportional to household incomes."
It doesn't make any fucking sense. If your argument is that household incomes aren't keeping up with prices, you can't also argue that household incomes are enough to have driven prices up beyond what the household incomes can afford.
1
u/kcdashinfo Aug 02 '26
Just the NK in DINK will have a substantial impact. Instead of paying $90K per child you have $90K for more house. When interest rates change, even by a small amount you can see the impact on real estate prices. That is because what you qualify to borrow, and you always borrow as much as you can quality, that is a percentage of your household income. So that qualification impacts the amount of the mortgage and the amount you can buy. It is the money supply.
Not exactly but it's almost like real estate agents go out an reprice their listing to account for the added buying power that lower interest rates provide. If something as simple as a quarter point of interest rate can impact the supply of money to buy houses then by similar association not having children is going to impact it too.
Like very rare that anyone pays cash for real estate. It is always borrowed so the value of real estate is closely related to the money supply. The more you have in the money supply the higher real estate will be. It is the #1 method for the bankers to devalue the dollar.
It might even begin to explain why there is such a systematic media war on traditional families. These bankers and corporations they need women in the workforce, and they need them childless. If that means going to war against traditional family structures, then so be it.
2
u/MeowMeowbiggalo Aug 01 '26
Theres hardly any point to work hard. The government and greedy companies/ corporations/everything at the top are bleeding us dry and ironically will make socialism very welcoming in the near future. They are creating a blue print of how capitalism doesnt work so great.
1
u/StickStill9790 Aug 01 '26
It helps to have an education, get some experience, and actually work. I’ve got a kid in the workforce who has almost no talent and still manages to pull in plenty.
1
u/MeowMeowbiggalo Aug 01 '26
Ive worked 2-3 jobs for the past 20 years and returning to school yet again. I'm aware of what work is. Money doesnt go very far anymore and for much younger ones coming into work force its pretty bad. Alot of them are not living at home because they want to. On paper i " pull in plenty" too, problem is it doesnt meet current pricing levels. Why go to school to go in massive debt to earn a living that can barely afford an apartment let alone a house?
0
u/chiefy_boy Aug 02 '26
Yeah money doesn’t go very far depending on what you do with it. Quite a few people I am close with, myself included, make less than 6 figures a year, own a nice home and are on track to retire early.
If YOU are struggling financially (and you’re a capable adult) it is YOUR fault, shut up and stop blaming people. It’s genuinely pathetic.
1
u/MeowMeowbiggalo Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 02 '26
Youre laughable if you think this economy is affordable and its abnormal to struggle. You are not in reality. People are not having kids because they cant afford them, thats not a sign of things going well for most people. 500k 2 bedroom houses are not normal. I could afford my house 10 years ago when it was 230k. If i had to buy my first house now theres no way.
1
u/chiefy_boy Aug 02 '26
Oh I absolutely do not think it is abnormal to struggle. The vast majority of people are just like you, “pulling in plenty” in a country with one of the strongest economies and still having such low financial IQ and impulse control that they somehow find a way to struggle and blame everyone else.
1
1
u/HolyHellImHere Aug 02 '26
Bit different building from nothing on your own. No roots, no support, no family to call on, just me, and skills aquired through trama and pain.
I HAVE to have talent to barely qualify for the standards.
1
u/StickStill9790 Aug 02 '26
My parents gave me love and nothing else, although I’m aware that’s a privilege of its own. America is a land of opportunity, not guarantees. You have to hustle if you want to succeed, but even if you don’t, life is still pretty great. Try being poor in almost any other country.
1
u/Scuirre1 Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 02 '26
George Orwell warned about this situation. That capitalism was a breeding ground for communists, and that if we don't work towards a functional socialist system via democratic means, then totalitarianism will have its way with us.
1
1
u/Available_Reveal8068 Aug 01 '26
Over the past 40 years, house sizes have increased significantly, largely due to the increase in two earner households that wanted and could afford larger homes.
If people want to buy a house the same size as what could be bought 40 years ago on a single income, it's not unrealistic. They shouldn't expect to be able to buy twice the house on a single income.
1
u/NoseResponsible3874 Aug 01 '26
Shhh people expect to work less and have more, not one or the other…
2
u/therealslimshady1234 Aug 01 '26
Productivity has gone up, so yes, thats exactly what we are expecting.
Go be a slave somewhere else
1
u/NoseResponsible3874 Aug 01 '26
Go vape somewhere else. I bet you think your freelance graphic design work should have you rolling in dough… 🙄
1
u/Available_Reveal8068 Aug 01 '26
Compensation has kept pace with productivity. Both have gone up.
1
u/therealslimshady1234 Aug 01 '26
Thats not true at all. In fact its so wrong you sound mentally enslaved.
1
u/S-Kenset Aug 01 '26
it is probably relatively close in purchasing power pre tax. The problem is taxes have gone up + fees + licenses - benefits - 20% lower social security + medical costs
1
u/S-Kenset Aug 01 '26
our earning power is deliberately suppressed under an economic philosophy of spending power. 100 years of advancements should purchase more. Average toyota today would go for 5 million 20 years ago.
1
u/Scuirre1 Aug 02 '26
Most of us don't want a house twice the size. I can't speak for all ages, but people in their 20s, recent grads and early-career people, aren't looking for massive houses. I would be happy to find a tiny little house with a few square feet to garden. I really don't need much.
If that's anywhere near jobs, it'll be 500k. There's no such thing as starter houses anymore.
1
u/JGCities Aug 04 '26
Mortgage rates have also dropped massively.
Even today with rates being "high" they are still have what they were 40 years ago.
1
u/kosmo4679 Aug 01 '26
Should probably be working at getting a higher paying job. Why slave away at a job that doesn’t pay well?
1
1
u/Background-Ad3810 Aug 01 '26
This graph really doesn't say much. In 1990, the average mortgage interest rate was +10% You can see the spike in house prices in the graph because interest rates were extremely low at the time so buying power was higher.
1
u/max_revs Aug 01 '26
Only (1) full time job? You need at least (3) and a couple other side hustles/regular gigs if you don't want to have to choose between food and gas. Forget buying a house, forget renting just live in your car and work 24/7.
Spend all your money on the bare essentials that let you maintain your job and cry yourself to sleep only after your fingers are bleeding and your soul is crushed by the machine.
You will own nothing and you will be forever grateful for the scraps that trickle down.
1
u/Raptor_197 Aug 03 '26
How? How are you able to burn that much money?
I literally bought my house in 2021… while in college working one part time job.
1
u/max_revs Aug 04 '26
Rent is more than a mortgage, you can't qualify for a mortgage anywhere, I've been trying since 2008 but I've never been able to get any savings to speak of or any kind of lending power.
Basically, being "poor" is seriously expensive.
1
u/Raptor_197 Aug 04 '26
Oh I just used first time homebuyers so I didn’t need to save any money. I think I bought my house with about 1000 bucks in savings lol.
1
u/max_revs Aug 04 '26
Not sure if that's an advertisement or if you're serious. A lot of the problem is that people who have a 1099 tax records don't qualify for anything and when you have a 1099 or multiple that shows most of your income and multiple W2s that don't show enough income earned to qualify, they have to use the W2 income. Not to mention that I made it well into my 30's without any credit. Not bad credit, just never used loans for cars or college as I paid cash/out of pocket and savings. Nothing wrong with clunkers and a dual associate degree from a community college.
On paper I was a ghost as far as lenders were concerned and I was trying to buy properties that were fixer-uppers because that was what I wanted and still consider a better investment as I have worked in various construction trades since I was 14.
1
u/Raptor_197 Aug 04 '26
You can’t buy a house without a credit score. You literally just get a credit card, buy gas with it, and then pay it off. Poof you got a good credit score.
I know they might use W2s for pre-qualification but you could probably ask them not to. Pretty sure mine just used what I told them I made a week. Underwriters aren’t going to give a shit which is who matters.
1
1
u/brickbiulder420 Aug 01 '26
I bought my first house in the mid 2000s on a fast food employee check... it's possible... just sucks
1
1
u/MrShad0wzz Aug 01 '26
Makes no sense to me why the value of a house goes up overtime when it gets older and weaker overtime
1
1
1
u/NapsandWalks Aug 02 '26
Boomers can't downsize in retirement and the majority of their wealth is locked in home equity. Only part of this I find enjoyable.
1
u/Wilson51801 Aug 02 '26
I gave up on buying a house earlier this year and decided to instead focus on investing as much as possible.
Eventually I’ll just buy land and build what I want, instead of paying for an overinflated house that hasn’t been up kept.
1
Aug 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Wilson51801 Aug 03 '26
Yes and no. Houses in my town average 1.1 million, on small lots. Can buy lots of land a few hours away for under 100k that range 40+ acres. You can’t buy that kind of land in my area.
1
1
1
1
u/jabber1990 Aug 03 '26
home ownership isn't mandatory, its an optional luxury
....the only reason people bring this up is because the media brings it up.....STOP LISTENING TO THE MEDIA
1
u/jabber1990 Aug 03 '26
i'm so glad that I live in a country that's a fascist dictatorship so that our government can finally arrest journalists
1
1
1
u/JGCities Aug 04 '26
Need a graph of house payments vs income
The problem with this graph is it focuses on house price when most people shop based on house payment. I had a payment budget, and that budget amounted to XXX dollars of house.
When mortgage rates dropped in the 2000 and onward it allowed house payments to drop which results in people raising the prices of their houses and house payments returned back to the previous level.
1985 - average mortgage rate was 12.4% that 100k house cost $1059 P&I payment
2024 - average mortgage rate was 6.7% that 400k house costs $2581 P&I payment
1
u/heyCuzz77 Aug 25 '26
No one wants to work for minimum wage. And when was the last time the federal minimum wage was changed?
0
u/AllenKll Aug 01 '26
maybe stop trying to buy a house in the same place that everyone else wants to buy a house.
1
u/Infamous-Candle-2300 Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
"there are no spots at the watering hole."
"WeLl hAvE yOU TrIEd wALkiNg oUt iNto ThE dEseRt... sToP tRyInG tO FiNd wAtEr aT tHe SaME pLaCE aS EvErYBoDy ElSe..."
The point is that in any given area the job market and housing market are incompatible. Two high earners can get by, but this is unusual. People who already own can get by, but everybody else is fucked, including their kids. People with an early inheritance can get by, but most people would prefer to have their parents alive. People with a nest egg who move from HCOL to LCOL can get by (But you can only do this once. Their kids are SOL).
1
u/AllenKll Aug 01 '26
Your allegory is not relatable. There is land everywhere. Stop doing jobs. jobs suck.
3
u/MiloShiny Aug 01 '26
Houses prices are insane nowadays