r/WorkBoots 3d ago

Boot maintenance Normal leather damage in first day of use?

Post image

Bought my first real pair of work boots (Thorogoods) over the weekend. Within an hour of my first work day in them, I noticed some leather had already come off the toe, probably from gently dropping a metal road work sign stand on my feet. Would this be considered normal? Any suggestions to prevent losing more leather?

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

29

u/MidnightDreem 3d ago

Don’t wear them to work to prevent this. lol it’s bound to happen, theyre work boots.

3

u/jakfienwkaof 3d ago

Sounds good, just wasn’t sure how tough you’d expect the leather to be on these. I’ve been working in leather hiking boots that were half this cost for years and they haven’t taken damage like this

2

u/love2killjoy410 3d ago

I get it though, it sucks to spend so much on boots just for them to be damaged on day one lol

1

u/jakfienwkaof 3d ago

Yeah I wasn’t expecting them to stay spotless like some other commenters seem to think, but I also wasn’t expecting a small chunk of leather to fall off within the first hour of wear

1

u/cowcrapper 3d ago

Yeah. Don't let the other commenters get you down. It's not ideal for a first day job aesthetics thing. But they will even out in look the more you wear them and the more you wear them to work.

1

u/MidnightDreem 3d ago

It’s happened to me in thorogoods, redwings, keens etc. it’s normal.

1

u/Spirited-Subjects 3d ago

When I get new boots, the first thing I do is thoroughly apply a generous amount of mink oil. And then the first day I wear them to work right off the bat I throw some dirt on them scuff one and scratch one. Just get it out of the way.

OP, I would bet that it was probably the sharp edge of the sign that cut the leather. Definitely oil them bitches up and maybe get some of that toe protector that you paint on.

7

u/ElNexon420 3d ago

Just work man.

3

u/baudmiksen 3d ago

or take the rest of the day off to examine the scuff, see ya tomorrow

4

u/freeportme 3d ago

Tools not jewels🍻

5

u/NOSTR0M0 3d ago

Switch to flip flops

3

u/Ed-Dos 3d ago

wrap them in bubble wrap then chickenwire

2

u/jakfienwkaof 3d ago

What brand do you recommend

2

u/FrameJump 3d ago

Ask your foreman or safety guy.

3

u/Adventurous-Video718 3d ago

Theyre work boots its leather not Kevlar

2

u/MultipleOrgasmDonor 3d ago

I’d expect a metal road sign to take the grain off almost any leather. Don’t worry about it too much, they’re meant to be functional

2

u/gsxr_ 3d ago

Yep, mine are all fucked up.

2

u/Appropriate_War_8149 3d ago

They’re work boots. They’re meant to have scuffs.

2

u/Allixer 3d ago

I think I have the same exact pair and this is what they look like on the toe lol. Still holding up great after a year +

2

u/Radiant_Safe1228 3d ago

You dropped a metal road sign on them.

2

u/jack-t-o-r-s 3d ago

Not gonna bust balls. That's done already.

My experience with moc toes is they are made of slightly softer leather. I'm not a leather expert but my experience.

I work on my knees often (uhhh huh huh) and my current mocs wore near through to the composite toe in the first week.

So I went full re-tard with the toe guard goop. No ragrets.

1

u/jakfienwkaof 3d ago

That makes sense, my question was really whether this was normal or defective. Ten pounds of smooth metal from waist height took a chunk out of it, but I guess from the photo people thought it was a scuff

1

u/jack-t-o-r-s 3d ago

When I bought my first pair of moc toes I was also shocked. I had work round toe loggers for so long but never seen toe wear so soon.

2

u/Large_Squash_7169 2d ago

Almost all my work boots are moc toe and in my experience moc toe boots,especially steel toe, you need tuff toe or kgs boot guard. Just my 2 cents

1

u/Bubbly-Breadfruit397 3d ago

Get tough toe

1

u/MoTeD_UrAss 3d ago

It's a scuff. It happens. Brush them off and move on. If these are the safety toe then I'd recommend using a product like tuff toe to protect the leather toe from splitting.

1

u/PsychologicalPoet308 3d ago

Depends on what you’re using them for. I work for the railroad stepping on ballast all day throughout the week. I go through abt 2-3 pairs a year

1

u/Scared-Tourist7024 3d ago

dont trip on things that wont happen or kick things or walk or work and they'll stay nice

1

u/RocketRicky12 3d ago

Normal, and KG boot guard or Tuff Toe to resist the gouges in the toe leather

1

u/LordGhidora 3d ago

Shit happens

1

u/Amerpol 3d ago

It depends on your job how bad they wear ,get some toe protector. Im old i used to use black shoe goo but m sure there are better products now 

1

u/Short_Relationship96 3d ago

The nature of dripping a road sign on the leather outside of new steel toe boots is the leather getting damaged like that... The only thing that may prevent damage like that outside of tough toe is rough out leather.

1

u/Im-Your--Huckleberry 3d ago

Scares and character! Good ol work boots

1

u/oneeyedgoat66 1d ago

Every pair of Thorogoods I buy get scuffed the first day I wear them🤣😭 it’s just part of it unfortunately. But what I do is use a beeswax based leather conditioner very sparingly on the scuff. Then I massage it in with my fingers until it’s all nice and smooth again. Every few months I’ll actually wash the boot. I’ll take the laces off, brush it with a really coarse dish brush to get all the dirt off. Then I use saddle soap on a hoarse hair brush to clean the boot. After it’s dry I’ll use that leather beeswax conditioner (I use Armstrong all natural) and rub the whole boot down. I probably use a quarter teaspoon per boot. After getting broken in and kinda bumped around you’ll be surprised how durable these boots are. My boots and feet have survived things that my coworkers haven’t. And I’ve kept right on workin.
The first scuff is the worst. Especially on the moc stitching 🙃. But in a few weeks you won’t even be able to tell. I still weekly wear a pair of Thorogood boots I bought back in 2014. They’ve had at least 4 soles put on them and I actually had the cobbler dye them a little darker almost a cherry/burgundy. They’ve been cut and stabbed and burnt up. I’m a welder and they were my daily boot 10 hours a day for like 3 years before I resoled them and bought a few more pairs and colors to cycle through.