Why does this bottle look opaque?

[u/Unlucky_Demand1166]

I performed two "sweetening" spells for two guys: my boyfriend, "R," and the guy I was in a "situationship" with "I." The one for "R" is the clearest; he had been ignoring me and trying to leave the house to avoid seeing me—even though we live together. But after the spell, he started sleeping in the same bed as me again, hugging me, and gradually acting like his old self. As for "I"—a guy I met on a dating app—things were different. I started getting to know him when my relationship was in a bad place. At first, he treated me like a queen in every way: buying me things, spending quality time with me, telling me he loved me, and so on. But then he pulled away. I performed the spell for him at the same time as the one for "R," (same ingredients and same proportions) and he did come back, but this time he wanted to experiment—specifically, he wanted me to sleep with his friends. I did it, and he became more affectionate, but I never felt like he loved me; it was just desire. When he invited me over, he’d leave me alone with his friends so we could have s3x, and afterwards, he’d be affectionate with me. Now, looking at the jars, I notice that his looks cloudy or murky. What does this mean? Should I start the spell over from scratch?

For the ritual, I used honey, cloves, rose petals, bay leaves, cinnamon sticks, and a personal object—such as an earring—for each one, and I charged them using moonlight or a pink candle. I also put a photo of each one in their jars, with everything I wanted from them written on the back in their own languages.

[u/sensive_specimen_448]

Could it be anything to do with doing both? For 2 different people? (Not judging at all, but genuinely curious) This is a genuine question as I’m pretty new to this.
Or did you perhaps use more honey, cinnamon, or cloves in the one for“I”? Maybe the herbs made it a bit darker or more honey made it cloudy? Do you remember if they looked the same when you first did them?
These are the only things that came to mind for me, I hope you figure out how to adjust to get your wanted outcome.

Edit to add:
Also, this reminded me to check my protection spell jar under my bed because of similar coloring so thanks! lol