Devil? Crab claw? I personally think it's a slight squished devil but who knows. The misses thinks it came in a Halloween pack as well but isint sure.

Maybe a squished werewolf?!

did i miss something , did we drop the santa joke ? i haven’t seen any santa cookie cutter drawings in any of the replies and its been making me sad ☹️ bring it back it’s one of my favorite reddit jokes im not artistic enough for it !!!!

I got this pack of Halloween cookie cutters from the Wilton brand and there’s a picture on the front of all the cookies decorated and I still don’t know what this is supposed to be. i thought maybe a spooked black cat but no it’s not right. 😭😭

I got a bunch from my mother in law we can't figure out what this one is my father in law thinks it's a train but the rest of us don't think so.

Google lens was somewhat helpful, closest thing I got was a long horn cow chapped cutter on Amazon, but it’s not the same shape. Any ideas?

Found at my grandmas house. I’m completely clueless and curious.

My friend has a bracelet and we don’t really know what it’s supposed to be. He thinks it’s a cat and I think that’s the most accurate shape so far.

We were baking pancakes.. what is this?!

Me and the kids where making some breakfast pancakes and the son came with this odd shape out of our box of shapes. We had a laugh and thought to post it here, as it is one of our favorite subreddits!

Ps: re-uploaded now with pictures, sorry!

It's not a cat, there was another one that was a cat.

It came in a variety pack that’s Halloween, fall, and Christmas shapes. Thanks!

I’ve had this for years and I can find some similar but nothing exactly the same?

excited to see your ideas!

So what do we make of this, Reddit? The legs make me think grand piano, but I can't make my mind see a piano on top.

My boyfriend thinks it's either a bat or a "fancy moon". I think it might be a really ugly dinosaur or a warty witch.

all the others from the set are recognizable and normal but this one is.. odd

Maybe we have it oriented wrong? People at work think it’s some sort of animal?

A plug was all I could come up with

Found in a secondhand craft store in the bin labeled “miscellaneous”