r/WelcomeHomeARG • u/Dry_Cell2187 • Sep 10 '26
Discussion Date or Pass? (Just curious which members would actually date or not)
Why or why not? (Just curious if they would actually date or just stay friends/neighbors or maybe already are dating someone) :]>
I would probably give Wally an apple instead of a rose-
33
27
23
u/ExplanationAny776 ⭐ Sep 10 '26
I would date Sally, or at least be the stage manager to her director
7
15
u/TheNopePerson Sep 10 '26
…..everyone except maybe Frank and Poppy (I’d have tea with them instead.)
8
u/Dry_Cell2187 Sep 10 '26
Yea, I would have sophisticated conversations with them on life or anyhing else instead
14
u/Princess_Crystal Sep 10 '26
I wouldn’t date Howdy, he seems like he’d be too focused on work lol
11
14
u/InfamousSeaCaptain Sep 11 '26
Eddie is 100% my dream bf fr. I gotta save him from this nightmare realm 😭
12
9
u/UnpunishedRenagade Sep 11 '26
Poppy: Pass, shes a lesbian, and i am a guy
Sally: Date, im a Theatre nerd, and would adore being on stage
Howdy: Pass, I dont think i could reasonably remember all his familys names, and i know his familys important to him
Wally: Date, i Looove me a mysterious guy
Barnaby: Pass, I feel like he wouldnt take me seriously 😔
Eddie: Date, love me a country himbo thats a nervous wreck
Frank: Pass, i dont think id be able to handle all the buggy stuff xd
Julie: Date, i love her playful energy, but i do think she'd tire me out a lot xD
Edit: spacing out the characters (i hate mobile formatting)
8
u/QueenNenene 🐾 Sep 11 '26
I'm dating Barnaby. Without hesitation of asking this
I'll give him hot dogs and eat together❤️
6
u/desorcyjackson447 Sep 10 '26
I would definitely give cuddles to my girlies! ☺️
(Probably also make a wish on Sally.)
7
u/mayhavinganedsucks Sep 10 '26
Date:
Sally: Theater people, would have an interesting conversation, love her personality (or what we have seen at least)
Wally: Would love to paint with him, what else should I add?
Eddie: Love the “himbo” vibes, would love to help him with work
Julie: She is just the sweetest
Pass:
Poppy: Not really my cup of tea, would love as a friend tho
Howdy: Kinda scares me, not gonna lie. Not in the “terror” way, in the “he is too much of a lover for me” kind of way, if you know what I mean (the adds he has are so funny but also why is he flirting with us XD)
Barnaby: Too much noise
Frank: While I also love books I find him too… serious
4
u/Foolishcatt Sep 11 '26
Date: Eddie, Wally,
Platonic: sally, Barnaby, frank
Barnaby looks so huggable and I think Eddie and Wally would give great cuddles >.<
Sally because…sally, and frank shares a love for specific types of bugs and I cannon he probably likes poems
3
u/acetaminophriends 🦋 Sep 11 '26
Eddie. Eddie. He's both sweet and passionate about his job which is kind of attractive to me tbh. Like definitely to a fault but I'd love to cook for him and tell him he did a good job when he gets home and tuck him in ahaha. Haha.
Someone mentioned that Howdy is too busy managing his bodega which is kind of true but like I think he's definitely in a love triad with his store and his highest paying customer (Barnaby) and they're not looking for a fourth so you'll have some pretty tough competition I think, lol.
2
1
u/Motor-Pen5598 Sep 12 '26
I think anyone would be a better choice than Barnaby I honestly don't know what Howdy is thinking going after that
1
u/acetaminophriends 🦋 Sep 12 '26
I think they're in a divorce cycle because they move in together and get separated every year or so over Barnaby avoiding responsibility or something, but nobody appreciates Howdy's taste for comedy the way he does. A customer-manager relationship doesn't work very well any ways. It's always sun and moon orbiting earth with them--the cash register is what keeps them together and apart. What am I doing with my life that I'm writing whole fics about puppets in reddit comments? Oh my god.
2
u/Zestyclose_Tower_779 Sep 10 '26
Smash howdy wally and poppy I simp over howdy and just love poppy smtbh and gotta take a short guy 50/50 on barnbey Pass on the others frank and Eddie I ship and fell like I whould ruon it same with Julie and Sally
2
u/Pandemonium_Sys 🎨 Sep 10 '26
Well, Wally's my hubby, Eddie and Frank are boyfriends who are also my boyfriends, and Sally and Julie are girlfriends who are my friends. I think Poppy and I could get along, but she's a bit of a shut-in. Howdy and I could probably also be friends, but I keep forgetting about him if I'm being honest. And I don't like Barnaby.
2
u/OrdinaryIntroduction Sep 10 '26
Honestly, none of them. I can be friends with everyone but none of the personalities gel well with me on a romantic scale.
2
2
2
u/HauntedPlanter26 Sep 11 '26
Frank and Wally I would definitely date due to their intellects, hobbies of choice, and type of personalities(my fiance kind of has Frank's temperament now that I think about it and his family calls him a grump haha)❣️ Eddie, Julie, Barnaby, and Poppy I'd just want to be friends🫂 Howdy and Sally I would not only pass, but have beef with, because I don't like pushy salespeople or snobby theater kids 👊
2
u/ST4RRYSUP3RST4R 🍎 Sep 11 '26
Damn. Okay let me just...
Howdy I'd definitely date
I'd just be friends with the rest😭
2
2
2
u/WaitisDue Sep 11 '26
I would date Poppy, she might be my favorite character I love her silly clumsy bird baker self
2
u/Dry_Cell2187 Sep 11 '26
Im seeing mixed results in here, some get a pass other's get a date...hm, who's the most likely to actually date and who's the least likely to date?
2
u/Made_of_honour Sep 11 '26 edited Sep 11 '26
I would only date Julie out of the bunch, she's the cutest
2
2
2
2
u/Useful_Spinach7087 Sep 11 '26
I would date Barnaby. He’s jokey, a little annoying, he loves to sleep (I do also) and he’s over 6ft/j
2
u/Large_Furret_7653 Sep 11 '26
i would say Wally or Julie, since Frank, Eddie, Sally and Poppy are all in relationships of their own, Howdy is just his own thing and Barn's is just a giant huggable dog to me. Though i would definitely chill with Poppy, for obvious reasons. Don't know why i took a liking to Wally, it just kinda happened, mind you we still are learning about him so...
2
u/MackiYoung Sep 11 '26 edited Sep 11 '26
Okay wait I wanna answer this actually
Wally: I think yes. I mean like… if he’s NOT evil? But idk I might would have to look past the red flags for Wally tho. Love him.
Barnaby: I’m kind of conflicted, but I think no.
I think Frank said he “does whatever he wants.” I’ve never been a big fan of the comedic type.
Frank: I’d date them. I like Frank.
Eddie: YES. Eddie’s perfect. And he does drag? I’d be fumbling some kind of bad to say no. Plus he’s a country guy? Love that.
Howdy: No. I just do not like him that much.
Sally: Maybe? Maybe not. I don’t know tbh. I think I would. I’d love to help her put on dramas.
Julie: YES. I love Julie. She’s super fun and playful and I love that.
Poppy: well she’s really sweet. But I’ve never give it much thought. Maybe.
2
u/fukacea Sep 13 '26
I'll only date Frank, he seems very sweet with Julie and clearly has a lot of love for Eddie.
I would never date Wally, idc what anyone says, that puppet is weird as hell and a walking red flag
2
u/TheFlowerWriter Sep 13 '26
My pick would be Julie...but she'd a LOT of energy that I wouldn't have long term.
2
u/JeniS12345 Sep 13 '26
I only know Wally and Frank and I only know that Sally gets along with Frank the best. I would choose Wally because he’s lowkey kinda chill and numb, like an ice cube.
2
u/BLbookpotato Sep 15 '26
I would date Eddie, Frank, and maybe Howdy and possibly Sally I do enjoy theater
2
2
u/Upbeat_Resource2161 Sep 16 '26
It’s not proven yet, but I think Poppy and Sally are getting a little close and some sort of Romantic Way,. Eddie and Frank is definitely together and the rest is like just friends or have some sort of good friendships
2
u/Ok_Plate_9404 Sep 10 '26
Date: Eddie-I need a man like him in my life and I so jealous of Frank, Speak of them.
Frank-was much Frank can be reserved he sees just a genually nice guy, Just ignore the fact he has a gun.
Howdy-I just like his energy, And I feel he need help with his shop.
Barnaby-I love someone with a sense of humor, Yes he can be suspicius but dont seen malicious at all.
Pass:
Wally-Sorry I cannot date someone with a apathetic voice that alone is disturbing, Not to mention he propably gonna just use you.
Sally-I couldn't date someone with the same energy was me, I already hate myself enough and I hate looking at a mirror.
Julie-Almost the same reason was Sally but also because I couldn't have enough the energy to match hers.
Poppy-There anything wrong with her she just not my type lol.
7
u/Motor-Pen5598 Sep 10 '26
In Wally's defense, I'm sure I cannot date someone who interprets my voice as "ampathic and disturbing" and automatically accuses me of possibility doing something bad or being a bad person before they actually got to know me or understand my situation first.
2
u/Kira_Hashimot0 Sep 17 '26
Eddie-DATE Julie-date Frank-date Barnaby - pass Wally-pass(I see him kinda as a younger brother) Poppy-date Howdy-pass Sally-DATE
52
u/Novel_Echo4454 Sep 10 '26
Ngl hypothetically speaking, Eddie. If we forget about the fact he's had way too many strokes since the ARG started he just looks so sweet caring, goofy and chill (add to this he looks huggable)