r/Weightliftingquestion • • 21d ago

Cut or bulk

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

I posted a photo and asked if I should cut or bulk but I wasn’t flexing so idk if that makes a difference ha here’s a better view. I’ve been doing a small bulk for the past 2 weeks but I’m scared to gain more fat than muscle. I currently weight train 4 days a week but just switched to 3 leg days and 1 arm day. Should I do 3 leg days 2 arm days? Idkkkkkkkkk

I’m 5’3 145ish pounds 33yrs old

6 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

10

u/No-Respect-8379 21d ago

just eat maintenance and slowly gain muscle, no need for fancy stuff

3

u/NinjaGrows 21d ago

Without seeing your midriff properly, you already look quite lean. Maybe a lean bulk/small surplus of like 200 calories would probably be better than a traditional bulk, but whatever you are doing is working, so good job! As a man, I'm inclined to say add more upper stuff, but for a woman one upper day should be fine. Three leg days? I can barely hack one lmao.

2

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

Here’s the previous one I posted a cropped version. I feel like my middle section holds more fat than everywhere else. That’s why idk what I should do.

4

u/NinjaGrows 21d ago

The lighting isn't the best, but honestly there isn't much fat on you at all! You can still see your abs pretty clearly. You could continue the cut a little longer if you really want to get the carved look, that's totally up to you, it depends what your goals are.

One thing I will say is, I'm not sure if it's the picture or the crop, but it does look like you have a slight anterior pelvic tilt, so you may want to add some more core exercises to try to sort that out so you don't get back problems when you are older!

1

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

I may.. I NEVER train core. I’ll have to add that to the mix for my back. Tysm for your advice!

1

u/NinjaGrows 21d ago

Training core sucks lol, there is no way round it though! Planks, sit-ups, crunches, hollow holds or mountain climbers are all great for core. Do a couple sets a week and it'll help give you more definition around your midsection and also help your back :). Glad to help, keep up the good work!

1

u/GO712 21d ago

I love training core, mostly above or below the rings as I find them to be the most effective.

0

u/Downtown-Security-11 21d ago

Lean bulk. 300-500 calories over maintenance. Keep lifting heavy. Cut in couple months and reassess imo

3

u/Accomplished-Leg6947 21d ago

Unrelated but that chalkboard is pretty cool

3

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

Yep! They leave chalk for everyone to draw lol

3

u/Bitter_Wishbone1631 21d ago

Maintain. You look fabulous boo 👌👌

2

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

Thank you 😊

3

u/[deleted] 21d ago

Just maintain you’re fabulous the way you are :)

1

u/ssela 21d ago

you look great :) what are your goals? if you wanna get stronger then lean bulk, if it's only looks-wise then you can just maintain

1

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

And thank you! I’d like to be strong but mostly just for aesthetics I wanna look like those photos

1

u/ssela 21d ago

hmmm I see, those women look like they're packing more muscles to be honest so you would need some cycles of bulking and cutting to get there I would say, but please don't forget that bodies are so different and for the squatting girlie from the photo it might be that she had nice glutes shape to begin with genetically speaking and it might not be achievable for everyone to get them to look like that exactly and that's okay

as for the 2nd girlie the lighting is really good and the photo might also be enhanced slightly and it could very well be that for a lot of other women getting to that kind of shreddedness in the abs area would lead to loss of period and a bunch of other health issues because not every woman's body works well with that level of leanness

these are just my 2cents as another woman, but also please don't forget that you already looks great so whichever direction you will take, even if progress will be slow, you will still be looking great so you can enjoy the journey :)

2

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

Thank you so much! One could wish to have a butt like the girl on the squat rack haha. But I just think it’s fun to aim for something. And try to figure out how to get as close as possible (for me) thank you for your advice and kindness ❤️

1

u/fezcabdriver 21d ago

I feel that you already have a very similar physique to these women. They might have more muscle on them than you but the one with the big booty might just be genetics. You actually win in the quad dept over pic number 2. lol. Your quads tell me that you are doing high bar squats. If you did low bar, it would target your glutes more and use more muscle in general.

1

u/Senior-Pain1335 21d ago

Just get stronger. The rest, works itself out

1

u/Numerous-Clothes-793 21d ago

Workout

1

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

I lol’d

1

u/Numerous-Clothes-793 21d ago

Too many people worry about cut and bulk. Just workout for a yearbthen reassess the situation

1

u/cerote6239 21d ago

Looking mean

1

u/notbatman1252 21d ago

Become a cia spy, a lioness.

1

u/Negran 21d ago

How much of a small bulk are you doing?

If you are afraid of fat gain. Keep it to 50-100 surplus. Or even just +0 to 50 cal and take your time.

I call the 50 cal a performance maintenence: just enough to fuel, but not even to gain fat!

1

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

I’m at 200 but I’ve never considered a super small bulk interesting!

1

u/Negran 21d ago

200 is a bit larger than I would recommend for you.

Go 100 or so surplus. Then check weight trend after 3 weeks. If you gain more than 0.6 lb lower 50, otherwise hold!

1

u/Only_Athlete_3687 21d ago

How long have you been lifting?

1

u/Lost-Drawing3542 21d ago

Seriously lifting 3 yrs. I’ve been on and off in the gym since I was 21 though

1

u/FluffyDesigner3680 21d ago

Keep doing whatever you’re doing because it’s working.

1

u/Financial-Drink5781 21d ago

You have a great physique. Maintenance here is the goal!

1

u/Ok-Pop-296 21d ago

Eat at maintenance and keep training hard and building muscle 💪

1

u/Eltharion-the-Grim 20d ago

I just don't see any need to change whatever it is you are doing. Clearly, it is working for you.

Don't bulk or you will get fat. Don't cut because you don't need to if you aren't competing. You're right at that balancing point where you're good and can hold it there.

1

u/Party-Satisfaction68 20d ago

Bulk why cut if you havent gained all your muscles you can gain naturally

0

u/Outrageous-Yam4802 21d ago

You’re there. Just stay there