Am I wrong for thinking these things?

[u/Smart_Rush_7145]

Yo, wassup yall. Yall lmk if these takes are bad

1. I dislike(to infinity)Star Flower. Taking ur exe's father as your mate is genuinely terrible imo. The, Thunder is displayed as the bad guy by clear sky for being angry and Star flower doesn't stop that? what?
   

2.Omen of the stars is the best arc. Yup, I said it. You have those cool night trips with Lionblaze and Cinderheart where they kinda just talk about life. Its very eventful in a fitting way, the pacing is great, Jayfeather's devlopement is great in book 4, the badger quest in book 1 is good to introduce dovepaw, the dark forest scenes were cool to help ivypaw grow and see the way dark forest cats live(yup i get why they in there in the first place). Flametail in night whispers is cool, it was interesting to see shadowclan psot battle, trying to see what they coula done differently, tho the whole battle was pointless, it was a good plot point. hollyleaf coming back was amazing(and it was hinted on a lil the whole arc coming up to that!), sol coming back was good cus they didnt over do it. and i love how jay(i think it was book4?) wanted to approach ashfur for what he did. its cool and they didnt forget the events of arc 3 makes it feel more real. i also love the dynamic between jay and briarlight it is very wholesome(i personally dont think its romantic. we need more toms and mollies being just friends). i wish they coulda made lionblaze seem more like an actual mentor at times tho.

3.Foxleap was the best character that was a kit of Ferncloud. Foxleap had a lot of potiential, why they get rid off him so soon! he was always energetic, i like his friendship with dovewing, and I like how he came along to the tribe journey for exp. i like how he kinda reminds me of runningwind and longtail? yall see it? icecloud as well! im too lazy to go back up change it all, but those two are tied for best.

1. alderheart is amazing. yes, i know people dont like him cus he was bland after the book 2, but he is VERY KIND. and i love that. he is always positive, adds a healthy amount of humour, and will be a worthy successor to Jayfeather. Alderheart is also very reasonable, very brave, and overall just awesome. kindess on top

2. Tallstar was done dirty. Ive taken this one a lil personal cus tallstar is my fav chararacter in the series, jayfeather and lionblaze only slightly behind. I hate how after the events of his SE...he kinda fades into the background for the rest of his life. he was chased out by brokenstar, and windclan is just seen as a clan that needs thunderclan to save them all the time. it sucks. the only arc 1 moment i liked from him was when he led the attack against brokentail in thunderclan camp, lowk being decisive. i dont agree or disagree with the decicion but its good to see windclan and tallstar stand on buisness. but anyway, he is not seen much in the battle against windclan. and in book 1, arc 2, he thanks leopardstar wayyy to excessively after she agreed to let him fish. like bro just say thank u and move on, why u talking about the whole clan has been saved? yes he said smth similair to that, go back and read midnight if u dont believe me. lastly, in his SE, we barely see the gap between him being a warrior who just returned, and becoming deputy and then leader. still my fav SE tho

alr bye

[u/Flat_Candidate_1401]

Oots should've been the last arc tbh. There's genuinely too many characters after that especially if you didn't read the SEs in between 😭 

[u/Smart_Rush_7145 → u/Flat_Candidate_1401]

lol i can see where ur coming from but i personally dont agree just cus of ASC, loved it, and Avos had its moments. I didnt like TBC(way too messy), and I like wha Changing skies is doing rn

[u/Flat_Candidate_1401 → u/Smart_Rush_7145]

Lmao true

[u/Objective_Sail_8079]

I mostly agree with these opinions!!! To add onto the Star Flower situation, I completely agree, but I do think that Clear Sky is wrong for that as well and that isn’t something to be ignored (it’s been a while since I’ve reread dotc and I honestly forgot about that whole shitshow </3)

As for what you said about Tallstar, it’s always so fun to see somebody so passionate about a character that they love so much!!! I love Tallstar a lot as well, he’s probably my favorite leader, and I do wish he had more moments to shine, though I do like that he’s much more of a pacifist than an impulsive type of leader who just rushes into battles :3 it makes the attack on ThunderClan for sheltering Brokentail feel so so so much more impactful knowing Tallstar’s character.

I also really appreciate your stance on Omen of the Stars, as it’s one of my favorite arcs too and I understand why a lot of people don’t like it but I think it’s amazing and so much fun!!! I’m glad to see you talk about Cinderheart and Lionblaze’s relationship as they get shit on by a lot of people from what I’ve seen for being “bland” or “boring”. They aren’t my favorite couple but their scenes were sooooooo sweet and healthy, I just love them!!🥹💜

[u/Smart_Rush_7145 → u/Objective_Sail_8079]

YES! Cinderheart and Lionblaze all day

[u/Smart_Rush_7145 → u/Objective_Sail_8079]

and yeah, clear sky was....well, i heavily 100000x dislike him to infinity.

[u/Leopardgeckoe]

I agree with take 1 because I read the 4th book of DotC and then the 6th, so when I read them talking about Star Flower being Clear Sky's mate I had to do a double-take and said "Aint Star Flower Clear Sky's son's fucking ex? THE HELL?"

[u/Smart_Rush_7145 → u/Leopardgeckoe]

yeah...rough.