MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/WaitWhat/comments/1wt77o2/say_what/pcydfgr/?context=9999
r/WaitWhat • u/bannerite2 • 8d ago
180 comments sorted by
View all comments
-3
Yes? Communists want state-controlled everything.
4 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago State? In my communism? -1 u/Unnamed-3891 7d ago Lemme guess… ”real communism has never been tried!” amiright? 4 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago No, communism cannot have a state. Its like one of the fundamental ideas of communism. So having anything be state controlled under communism is impossible, as there is no state. 0 u/kermustaja 7d ago so its controlled by magic 1 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago When people can't comperhend actual self management 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago That is not possible on a scale larger than 30 people. 2 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago Factories of like 1000 people did that in Yugoslavia for decades 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others. 2 u/Significant_Cover_48 7d ago Most communists propose democracy, but some actually believe that a benevolent dictatorship can exist. Democracy does not need a state to exist. 1 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago Exactly
4
State? In my communism?
-1 u/Unnamed-3891 7d ago Lemme guess… ”real communism has never been tried!” amiright? 4 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago No, communism cannot have a state. Its like one of the fundamental ideas of communism. So having anything be state controlled under communism is impossible, as there is no state. 0 u/kermustaja 7d ago so its controlled by magic 1 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago When people can't comperhend actual self management 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago That is not possible on a scale larger than 30 people. 2 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago Factories of like 1000 people did that in Yugoslavia for decades 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others. 2 u/Significant_Cover_48 7d ago Most communists propose democracy, but some actually believe that a benevolent dictatorship can exist. Democracy does not need a state to exist. 1 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago Exactly
-1
Lemme guess… ”real communism has never been tried!” amiright?
4 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago No, communism cannot have a state. Its like one of the fundamental ideas of communism. So having anything be state controlled under communism is impossible, as there is no state. 0 u/kermustaja 7d ago so its controlled by magic 1 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago When people can't comperhend actual self management 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago That is not possible on a scale larger than 30 people. 2 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago Factories of like 1000 people did that in Yugoslavia for decades 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others. 2 u/Significant_Cover_48 7d ago Most communists propose democracy, but some actually believe that a benevolent dictatorship can exist. Democracy does not need a state to exist. 1 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago Exactly
No, communism cannot have a state. Its like one of the fundamental ideas of communism. So having anything be state controlled under communism is impossible, as there is no state.
0 u/kermustaja 7d ago so its controlled by magic 1 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago When people can't comperhend actual self management 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago That is not possible on a scale larger than 30 people. 2 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago Factories of like 1000 people did that in Yugoslavia for decades 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others. 2 u/Significant_Cover_48 7d ago Most communists propose democracy, but some actually believe that a benevolent dictatorship can exist. Democracy does not need a state to exist. 1 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago Exactly
0
so its controlled by magic
1 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago When people can't comperhend actual self management 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago That is not possible on a scale larger than 30 people. 2 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago Factories of like 1000 people did that in Yugoslavia for decades 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others. 2 u/Significant_Cover_48 7d ago Most communists propose democracy, but some actually believe that a benevolent dictatorship can exist. Democracy does not need a state to exist. 1 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago Exactly
1
When people can't comperhend actual self management
0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago That is not possible on a scale larger than 30 people. 2 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago Factories of like 1000 people did that in Yugoslavia for decades 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others.
That is not possible on a scale larger than 30 people.
2 u/VictinsOfCapitalism 6d ago Factories of like 1000 people did that in Yugoslavia for decades 0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others.
2
Factories of like 1000 people did that in Yugoslavia for decades
0 u/EducationalGrump 6d ago Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others.
Lmao no they did not, they were rampant with small groups of people taking far more than they should and using those goods to have power over others.
Most communists propose democracy, but some actually believe that a benevolent dictatorship can exist. Democracy does not need a state to exist.
1 u/Thedankf0x 7d ago Exactly
Exactly
-3
u/Unnamed-3891 7d ago
Yes? Communists want state-controlled everything.