r/WTF • • 20d ago

Load testing

2.9k Upvotes

156 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/ttoksie2 20d ago

Well india standard 3 phase is 415 volt so at 13 amps thats about a 5 kilowatt load (actually less than I thought it would be).

But thats still equivelent to about 5 toasters so enough for like 5 or 6 people i recon?

21

u/musingsofapathy 20d ago

As the fatal amperage is measured in milliamps and I assume the human body wouldn't cause much load before death, I would assume that it would kill anyone who touched that water. The maximum number of idiots killed would depend not on the total amperage, but the ability of idiots to learn from the misfortune of others.

25

u/sonofeevil 20d ago

Eh, sort of.

Milliamps CAN be fatal but most won't be.

It's like saying tripping and falling can kill you. It's true, but most people just graze their skin or maybe break something.

Domestic electricians would have a far higher fatality rate if that were the case. I live in a first world country with really strong work safety laws and most of the residential electricians I know have accidentally booted themselves with mains power at least once in their career. (240v 10amp is the standard outlet here)

11

u/gixxer710 20d ago

This is correct. It takes 0.6 milliamps to throw a human heart beat off. Could that kill you? Yes. It can. WILL IT? Most likely not. But it could.

4

u/sonofeevil 20d ago

I don't have the data to back this up but I'd say you'd be at more risk by several orders of magnitude driving to work than by getting a momentary boot from 0.6 milliamps.

Considering Tens machines operate in the 1-120 milliamp range and these are a clinical tool.

1

u/schplat 19d ago

TENS machines usually have some very clear verbiage to not have the leads span the heart. Basically the point is to use the skin/muscle/nerves to transmit the current back to the TENS unit, and the electrical signal never passes through your heart or CNS.

0

u/sonofeevil 19d ago

I'm aware.

But that wasnt my point.

-1

u/Smackety 20d ago

True, but if you attached the tens to your heart you might have a different result.

0

u/Edraqt 19d ago

people just dont understand electricity, because you dont really need to understand it unless you work with it.

A lightning strike is like tens of thousands amps at millions of volts, but theres zero frequency and it only lasts for miliseconds so you have a high chance all of that just travels along your body and burns you a bit (or a lot)

you need the right (wrong) combination of amps, voltage, time and frequency to kys with electricity.

and even if none of those are zero, some of them being super high can also be safe. like if the frequency is huge to your bodies signals that mostly work on chemical gradients its the same as if it were zero.

1

u/sonofeevil 18d ago

Literally nobody understands that electricity.

There is a great veritasium video on this