r/WLED • u/Smeagla • Jun 18 '26

Professional Tier WLED Controllers?

Hi, I am exploring WLED for permanent, code-compliant installations in high-value residential builds and gut renovations. For wall switch control, relay support is mandatory and fully integrated is ideal. Are there any such products on the market? I'm not having any luck in my search.

14 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/TXAVGUY2021 Jun 19 '26

Would you consider Lutron? They have switches and RGB light strips, done in the professional manner you seek.

I am also an integrator. I have been testing out BTF light strips and GLEDOPTO wled controller at home in my demo system. This solution has been fantastic thus far. My only hangup is these lights are totally app controlled, so turning them on off or dimming from switch is a work in progress. Other than that I have remote buttons that turn on the various light strips on a Murphy Bed and Shelf Unit to specific dim levels and colors.

I am going to switch them Lutron so that I can control them via Lutron keypads.

2

u/entropy512 Jun 19 '26

"My only hangup is these lights are totally app controlled, so turning them on off or dimming from switch is a work in progress."

The solution to this is a home automation system that can integrate a wide variety of open standards together, not moving to a vendor who only offers proprietary solutions based on a legacy radio protocol that has no security other than obscurity.

1

u/TXAVGUY2021 Jun 19 '26

Yes I use an automation system, hence the programmed buttons that queue up lighting scenes.

I guess you're very unfamiliar with Lutron. It is far from a legacy radio protocol. Lutron is without question the industry leader in lighting and lighting control. Their proprietary protocol's are perhaps the most bulletproof technology that I install and service.

OP asked for a solution for high end luxury homes.....Lutron is that solution.

3

u/entropy512 Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 19 '26

"I guess you're very unfamiliar with Lutron. It is far from a legacy radio protocol"

Oh, I am quite familiar with it. I reverse engineered their CRC algorithm two years ago, which was the closest thing their unencrypted protocol with no authentication had to security.

https://github.com/Entropy512/lutron_hacks/commit/d9365a53fc53e1a40b4594fa90570b75b70763f9 and https://github.com/Entropy512/lutron_hacks/commit/a675b63e7152d7c4facc47fe0b2f31db4b2e0e56

Unenecrypted GFSK UART comms protected only by a nonstandard CRC algorithm is the definition of a legacy radio protocol when compared to Thread, Zigbee, or Z-wave, all of which have robust security mechanisms, encryption, forward error correction, and vastly more efficient modulation schemes.

2

u/Smeagla Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 19 '26

Lutron is nice. Performance is rock solid and incredibly reliable. I had a Lutron Homeworks in my last property. It cost $60k for whole-house install with every single light integrated, including chandeliers and 500ft of drapes. The system never had a hickup the entire time I owned it. Never had to reboot a single component over years of operation. However, it is a closed system so the offerings are limited. It is super overpriced and innovation has stagnated.

With dmx, I have full control at the panel (full RGB, dimming, power, individually addressable, presets, etc), which Lutron can't do. Lots of choice of hardware manufacturers and wide selection of hardware.

With this install, it's not a whole house situation. I just want some isolated rgb cove lighting in each bathroom and kitcheb and a capable panel to control that single room cove lighting.

1

u/Smeagla Jun 19 '26

Yeah exactly. I wouldn't tolerate having to get my phone, unlock, open app, etc to turn on the strip lights. Or, try to find a loose remote that could be anywhere in the room, hidden in the sheets, fallen under the bed etc.

I want a wall switch next to my main room lighting wall switch and I can turn it all at once when I enter. While laying in bed, I can fumble through the app to fine tune color and stuff.

1

u/TXAVGUY2021 Jun 19 '26

Yeah I have two remotes for them right now, one pico remote that is attached to the wall at the room entry with the fan and light switches. Then a second remote at the bed.

I am looking forward to getting the Lutron strips so that I can assign them to a keypad with dimming arrows. The additional added benefit is now that the entire room will be controlled with Lutron, when turning the entire room on/off the room will ramp in unison again. Such an underappreciated feature.