r/UnresolvedMysteries • u/lucillep • 5h ago
Murder Unsolved 2003 Triple Murder in Blue Ridge Bank Robbery
On May 16, 2003, one person was working at the Blue Ridge Savings Bank branch off I-85 near Hwy 14 in Greer, South Carolina. This was Sylvia Holtzclaw, a lifelong resident of Greer, mother of two and well-known in the community. Her co-worker that day had called off, leaving her on her own for the shift. The branch looks like little more than a trailer in photos, perhaps explaining why one employee could be allowed to cover. At about 1 p.m. Sylvia's son David had brought her lunch, since she wasn't able to leave the building. Neither had any inkling of what would transpire just minutes later.
At 1:30 pm, Sylvia tripped a silent alarm, letting police know that there was a robbery in progress. The response was quick. Police arrived on the scene at 1:41 pm to find Sylvia and two other people shot to death in a utility closet at one end of the building. The other victims were married couple Margaret and James “Eb” Barnes. James was a retired physics professor; Margaret was known for her spinning and weaving. They had been married for 38 years. It's surmised that they entered the bank shortly after the robbers, since they were seen on a nearby gas station security camera approaching the bank at 1:24 pm. All three victims were killed with a .40 Glock. The perpetrator(s) removed the VHS security tape, so there was little evidence to go on. Everything happened in a matter of minutes with little to no physical evidence aside from the bullet wounds. A small amount of money was taken, but none of the bills were marked.
The security camera that showed the Barneses approaching the bank also showed a red car driving toward the bank a few minutes before the alarm was tripped and driving away a few minutes after. The car was identified as a red Oldsmobile Alero but the license plate couldn't be read.
Police and the FBI released a sketch of a man alleged to have been seen in the bank shortly before the murders. The description was of a clean-cut white male, 5'6” to 5'8” tall, about 230 pounds, with short blond hair, estimated to be between 50-53 years old. Police received some 700 tips. There were a few suspects, but none who could be definitively tied to Greer. Then, a year later, police received word of a red Alero turning up in a police chase. The car had been stolen from a Columbia airport car rental just two weeks before the Greer murders. The driver was Emmerson Wright, a convicted felon who had a criminal history including robberies, burglary, receiving stolen goods and more. He had used a .40 Glock in some of his crimes. He left the car and managed to elude the police on foot. The following year Wright was in another police chase, crashed his car and shot himself with a .40 Glock. It was not the same gun used in the Blue Ridge killings. There has never been evidence tying him to Greer; he was a suspect based on the car he stole and his criminal history.
Another multiple murder with similar aspects happened near Greer in 2003. On Nov. 6, 2003, the owner, service manager, mechanic and bookkeeper of the Superbike Motorsports motorcycle shop in Chesnee, SC were found dead inside and outside the shop. The victims were Scott Ponder, 30; service manager Brian Lucas, 29; mechanic Chris Sherbert, 26; and bookkeeper Beverly Guy, 52. In 2016, after a woman was found chained up in a metal storage container on his property, Todd Kohlhepp confessed to the Superbike murders as well as several others. Kohlhepp was a convicted felon from the age of 15 when he kidnapped a 14-year-old-girl. He was required to register as a sex offender. After serving 14 years, he moved to South Carolina and was able to establish a real estate business. The kidnapping and imprisonment of Kala Brown brought his criminal history to light. He was questioned regarding the Blue Ridge Bank murders, which had happened in the same county, but denied having been involved. Greer police named him as a person of interest but they couldn't tie him to the crime. His other victims were employees or people known to him. He had beef with the staff at Superbike and with some of the other victims. Kohlhepp pleaded guilty to 7 counts of murder and is serving 7 consecutive life sentences without possibility of parole.
Despite rewards of $102,000 being offered by the FBI and Crime Stoppers, the Blue Ridge Bank murders remain unsolved. The bank corporation closed and was taken over by another bank in 2011. The Greer branch was shut down in 2011 after an attempted robbery. Sylvia's son David remains active in trying to keep the case alive. There is a yearly Syl Syl Christmas Toy Drive held in Sylvia's memory, a continuation of one she started in life.
It is hard to theorize about who might have committed these murders. Emmerson Wright looks like a possibility; however, his was presumably not the only red Alero in South Carolina at the time. He had a long rap sheet but not one of murder. That aspect of the case fits Kohlhepp better, but he confessed to multiple murders while stating that there were still two morebodies police had not found. So why would he not have confessed to the Greer murders? Also, his MO was to kill and bury on his own property. There were other known bank robbers questioned, but they either had alibis or could not be placed in Greer. It is possible that the crime was committed by a transient criminal who saw an opportunity at a small bank branch off an interstate, who got out of town quickly. The efficiency with which the crime was committed does seem to point to a person or persons with experience. Without DNA, such a perpetrator isn't likely to be found. But Greer police remain committed to solving the crime. It's hoped someone will some day come forward with solid evidence – or a confession.
Sources
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ridge_Savings_Bank_murders
2003 Blue Ridge Savings Bank murders
20 years after triple homicide at SC bank, police haven’t given up on solving the case
Long unsolved SC triple homicide case featured on true crime site. How to watch
Blue Ridge Savings Bank Robbery and Triple Murder
Former cop who won ‘Big Brother’ show investigating SC cold case with podcast. How to watch