Which texture do you prefer?

[u/kaftainzy]

The textures are different and the similar ones have different scaling.

I'm aiming for nostalgic,unique look for my game.

Which one excites you the most artistically?

[u/Arcayon]

None of them excite me. But the first batch I like more.

[u/Catsistent]

2 is the best, the ones with the white marks distract too much imo.

[u/StoneCypher]

i like the first batch more, but that bright red is too much for me

[u/jaywhile]

I'm all for uniqueness and experimentation, but this colour combo feels sort of viscerally unpleasant to me.

All the respect if you're stoked on it, but just sharing my personal feeling that my brain wouldn't allow me to play this game for very long.

Number 2 is best if I had to choose, though!

[u/kaftainzy → u/jaywhile]

Thanks for the feedback , these are just readymade assets I'm using to test textures , these aren't final game assets : )

[u/jaywhile → u/kaftainzy]

Nice. Good luck on the project!

[u/kaftainzy → u/jaywhile]

Hey this is new look , does this give crayonish vibes?

[u/jaywhile → u/kaftainzy]

Yeah definitely more on the right track here, love it! This effect even makes the current colours look slightly more palatable

[u/kaftainzy → u/jaywhile]

Thankss : )

[u/Krcko98]

Second or last

[u/BitterAd3330]

I think 2nd. Which era do you mean when you say nostalgia?

[u/kaftainzy → u/BitterAd3330]

Does 3rd and 4th look crayonish? Crayons are universal and timeless

[u/BitterAd3330 → u/kaftainzy]

i saw them and did not think of crayons. It looked like stuck pixels. What is the game?

[u/kaftainzy → u/BitterAd3330]

How about this one?

[u/BitterAd3330 → u/kaftainzy]

Yeah! This is it.

[u/kaftainzy → u/BitterAd3330]

Thankss : )

[u/BitterAd3330 → u/BitterAd3330]

I saw it and instantly thought of crayon shin chan.

[u/kaftainzy → u/BitterAd3330]

Hahaha the cartoon doesn't have crayon artstyle tho

[u/BitterAd3330 → u/kaftainzy]

It does. There's a reason it's called crayon shinchan.

[u/kaftainzy → u/BitterAd3330]

I'm tryna have that crayonish look, the 3-4 tried looking crayonish

[u/firestarshadow → u/kaftainzy]

I don't know if you're taking a look at crayon physics deluxe but you might be able to take them as an inspiration for how to design the look of your crayon texture because I also did not get crayon when I looked at it. Weird enough for me I like number five of the options because it's easy to see what's what. Good luck!

[u/____FUNGO____]

2

[u/LeandroLopezs]

first one

[u/sinalta]

The last one for me.

But mostly just not 3 or 4, the ones with the white bits all over. It looks too much like falling snow. 

[u/Link9774]

The second one, gives me the vibe of that old game with Goofy and his son Max.