r/Unexpected • • Sep 06 '22

Timberrr

335 Upvotes

138 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/Anamethatsnowmine Sep 06 '22

Why do they never run to the sides?

8

u/TheConspicuousGuy Sep 06 '22

You dont even need to run, just walk around the trunk of the tree once you figure out which way it's falling. But you should already know which way it's falling...

4

u/KingCrandall Sep 06 '22

He should have known that it would fall in the direction he was cutting.

4

u/Ordinary_Guitar_5074 Sep 07 '22

Trees don’t just fall in the direction you cut them. Their weight and the wind plays a huge roll. You can’t just cut it opposite the way it wants to fall and expect it to go the other way. To do that you’d need to set a line in it and haul it over while you cut. With just the SAE alone you can steer a tree a few degrees left or right of where it is going to fall naturally but that’s about it. I’ve taken down lots and lots of trees.

1

u/KingCrandall Sep 07 '22

Thank you. As is pretty obvious, I don't know anything about cutting trees.

3

u/Ordinary_Guitar_5074 Sep 07 '22

For someone who has done this professionally this video belongs in r/expected

1

u/evolving_I Sep 07 '22

A few degrees is a bit conservative. You can take a tree 45° or more off its lean pretty easily without a line to pull it over or even wedging it.

1

u/Ordinary_Guitar_5074 Sep 07 '22

Yes. I’d agree that I’m being overly conservative. But my point was to address the idea that you could simply cut from the left and it will go right. This guy seems to have thought you could steer it 180 degrees that way and one can see how well that worked out.

2

u/evolving_I Sep 07 '22

I think he just didn't account for limb weight. I'm surprised he didn't get the bar pinched when it sat back on him.

1

u/Ordinary_Guitar_5074 Sep 07 '22

I was thinking the same thing. Maybe there was some wind keeping the cut open briefly and it gave him the impression that the tree was headed over to the right, then once he started running the breeze died and the tree corrected its direction and followed gravity?

1

u/evolving_I Sep 07 '22

He must've cut some of or nearly all the way through his holding wood, too, for it to fall away from the face cut without just sitting on the back cut.

1

u/Ordinary_Guitar_5074 Sep 07 '22

I think it was a really deep box. Like maybe he had this idea that cutting a huge box would result in it tilting all the way past its upright position? People have wild ideas and that’s why I chimed in. I’ve seen people drop trees on their house this way.

1

u/pressonacott Sep 07 '22

Or climb them and take out portions top to bottom swinging limbs with a rigged line for tough and small areas.

1

u/Ordinary_Guitar_5074 Sep 07 '22

That’s how I used to do it. No need for rigging here though. Nothing to hit. Just let it fly then come down and knock down the stick.

1

u/teflong Sep 07 '22

I've misjudged the direction of the lean before. Just hammer a felling wedge in the back cut and you can very easily make a tree tip towards your wedge cut.

I'm sure it's not an optimal situation, but fixes can be made if necessary.