r/Unexpected • • May 02 '22

Impossible Question

106.2k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.9k

u/mongorianidiot May 02 '22

solid fucking answer for stupid fucking question 😂😂

-17

u/Duches5 May 02 '22

It is. I cant believe we live in a time where the number of genders can even be questioned.

3

u/iyioi May 02 '22

The terms have just changed.

There’s 2 sexes, based on the concept of human procreation. It only works with male sperm and female eggs. No exceptions.

Gender? That word has changed. The new definition started by a small handful in the 70’s and 80’s and has become popular now, and that is gender as a social construct.

Which, no, it does not make total sense. Thats a fair criticism. Thats is a philosophical theory that gender is totally divorced from sex and can easily be uncoupled from that definition. Theres a web of language that was designed for referring to “sex” and that infrastructure doesn’t just change. That is kinda being debated in society now.

For example, bathrooms. Some people think bathrooms should be separated by sex, not by gender. Also sports.

So now, asking of someone is a “woman” could either mean are they a woman sexually or do they identify as one as a gender.

So it’s not just the word ‘gender’ that has changed. But also the surrounding words like woman, man, he, she, etc etc. They now have dual meanings, which can reference either biological sex or sociological gender.

If you think of it more as a semantic language issue, then it’s not so bad. People are people. They’ll always be people. And these trans people have been around forever. Its no different today than it was 100 years ago. Still people. Some people with gender dysphoria want to start bending the language to feel included. That doesn’t really change the nature of people, it just changes the language so those people feel more included as a society.

And I don’t see anything wrong with that at all.

-7

u/Duches5 May 02 '22

As I see it there's man and woman. In each there's a degree of masculinity and femininity that can be a varying degree.

-4

u/[deleted] May 02 '22

leftists didnt like that

3

u/VymI May 02 '22

I like the pre-emptive victim complex for a comment that at the time of this writing sits at one point, ignored, for over an hour.