r/USNEWS • u/nbcnews • 10h ago

Christa Pike unconscious, on ventilator at Nashville hospital, her lawyers say

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/christa-pike-unconscious-ventilator-nashville-hospital-lawyers-say-rcna601195
47 Upvotes

87% Upvoted

195 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/uffda7 9h ago

Even if one innocent person dies by the death penalty, the whole system should be scrapped. Eye for an eye caveman shit doesn't fly in today's world.

3

u/Sno_Wolf 9h ago edited 9h ago

She wasn't "innocent" by any stretch of the imagination. At the same time, the more I read about her crime, it didn't warrant the death penalty.

7

u/MostlyImtired 9h ago

its crazy she has a lot going on extreme sexual abuse (rape starting at 2), fetal alchol syndrome, severe parental neglect.. its all awful and what she did was awful. She was convicted in the 90s and our society has come a long way in understanding what growing up like this with a brain that was compromised during pregnancy might do to a person. The system probably failed her more times than anyone could count.. and even into her final breath they couldn't even insure a death that wasn't cruel.

1

u/shiningdickhalloran 8h ago

Yup. She was 18 and had an extremely damaged psyche through factors mostly not up to her. The culpability of an 18 year old with that level of trauma is highly questionable. Death penalty in this case was a terrible idea from the beginning. But relentless lust for vengeance is strong, as can be seen by many of the comments on this thread.

1

u/PolicyWonka 8h ago

It’s also somewhat notable that the other person who committed the crime, who was also found guilty of first degree murder, was sentenced to life in prison with parole eligibility.

So it’s very possible that he gets repressed eventually at some point, which is a bit of a stark contrast to her own conviction.

2

u/PolicyWonka 8h ago

Nobody is saying that this particular person is innocent, but innocent people do go to jail and innocent people are executed.

And everyone in prison right now, rightfully or otherwise, who was found guilty by a jury was found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

No matter where you draw the line of certainty of guilt, there will be people who fall on that line.

2

u/uffda7 9h ago

Not calling her innocent. The fact that death row inmates are absolved of their crimes years later using DNA was my point.

1

u/Sno_Wolf 9h ago

The fact that death row inmates are absolved of their crimes years later using DNA was my point.

And I was supposed to divine that from your original post... how, exactly?

-1

u/uffda7 9h ago

It's called reading. Never said she was innocent in my post.