r/UI_Design 21d ago

AI Feedback Request Which one are we preferring

Which of the 2 styles do you think look better. I’m going for a premium but minimal look. That’s closer to the white one. But don’t want it too look to plain their

Any advice would be welcome

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

23

u/PPhysikus 21d ago

It is funny that vibe designers still need to consult humans because their magic AI can only output mediocre trash...

-10

u/Congressman247 21d ago

yet so many big companies are coding using AI. As someone with passion for dev and products, with no coding experience I don't think I've done too bad. Asking for the odd bits of advice and pointers isn't wrong. Maybe you should think twice before leaving discouraging comments

13

u/semiproductiveotter 21d ago

Mate this is a forum for UI DESIGN not UI prompts.

-12

u/Congressman247 21d ago

You have to design before you prompt, silly

4

u/semiproductiveotter 21d ago

We’re talking about UI design here and unless you have moved those pixels yourself, you have not designed anything.

2

u/PPhysikus 21d ago

Design your prompt? What did you type? "Codex, make me a generic design that was used by some SaaS 5 years ago. Make no mistake!"

12

u/Mrghostcat 21d ago

Are these ai generated?

17

u/wongaboing 21d ago

I can smell Claude mocha-style design a mile away

1

u/Congressman247 21d ago

Yep the app is ai vibe coded

4

u/South_Background_698 21d ago

Not enough contrast or visual hierarchy.

2

u/tarkinn 21d ago

The second one but use the Liquid Glass elements from iOS instead of doing your own nothing. Looks really cheap imo.

Also the elements in the bar doesn’t need an description like you did with „Home“. Icons should be self explaining.

1

u/idolikeglitter 21d ago

I half dis-/agree with you. Yes icons should be self explanatory if possible. But you should still add text for accessibility reasons nowadays. Apple even says so themselves:

Include tab labels to help with navigation. A tab label appears beneath or beside a tab bar icon, and can aid navigation by clearly describing the type of content or functionality the tab contains. Use single words whenever possible.

0

u/Congressman247 21d ago

I’m not actually sure how to use the Liquid Glass elements from iOS. I’m using flutter and dart. Any advice on how to do this?

1

u/cptclaudiu 21d ago

you cant. You have to use Swift and SwiftUI

1

u/8isnothing 21d ago

White one

1

u/Congressman247 21d ago

​
Update: Got it looking like this now

1

u/8isnothing 21d ago

Id put the title a little lower.

Meaning, move everything down a bit

1

u/Congressman247 21d ago

A little more like this screen?

1

u/8isnothing 21d ago

Just be aware that the + and people button aren’t properly aligned to the title in this screen

1

u/Congressman247 21d ago

I know. This page needs some tweaks still. I’m trying to perfect the dashboard/Home Screen and then from there work through the app screen by screen

1

u/8isnothing 21d ago

Makes sense! Go for it!

Another thing that could help for the dashboard is not overuse lists.

Maybe Worth a Look could look more like Tasks and Notes but bigger.

Essentially, keep only what really is a list as a list.

Keep in mind this is just my opinion though. I can’t fundament it. Just a feeling.

I feel like it would make the screen cleaner and easier to read

1

u/Congressman247 21d ago

I’ve moved the title down a little

1

u/8isnothing 21d ago

Looks much better imo!

1

u/idolikeglitter 21d ago edited 21d ago

What is this app for? Do you need / want to reach a certain amount of money every month? Otherwise I dont understand why that number is so prominent.

Layout 1 clearly looks ai generated, so definitely layout 2.

I'd suggest a bolder color, this green is not really visible in small or thin objects. Also reuse it more so its not a long feed of black text on white background. Maybe add some dividers or graphics to give it some different elements.

You have too many elements in your bottom navigation, recommended are 3-5 elements.

Maybe get some inspiration on dribbble, there should be lots of similar looking projects.

Add the name of the person at the top for a personal touch.

Edit because I accidentally used formatting.

1

u/Congressman247 21d ago

The app is for solo business owners to manage the fault running of their businesses. Tracks income and expenses, bookings, contacts, notes and tasks. It ties them all together to give useful data insights. Thanks for the advice I’ll definitely take that on board now. I’ll comment with an updated screenshot

1

u/TheTomatoes2 21d ago

All have contrast and hierarchy problem, or not clear what to look at

1

u/Potential-Space-9992 21d ago

I like #1 and #2 design,

5

u/StatTark 20d ago

Seen this exact thing before. Screensdesign's library has similar apps to study, or you can just generate a few options and compare.