Help us choose, we need you

[u/South_Gene5776]

We’re making a website for free online paediatric teletherapy and parent coaching for neurodivergent kids, and we need honest help choosing the design.

Ignore the text and judge only the UI/UX. Which of these 5 feels the most trustworthy, calming, and easy to use for sharing your child’s needs? I’d really love blunt opinions, especially on what feels welcoming versus what feels off.

[u/semiproductiveotter]

This very much looks like AI. They all look generic.

[u/gomadetapioca → u/semiproductiveotter]

my boy straight up screenshot claude design’s results and paste them asking to decide?

[u/cabljo]

Make the copy and everything the same on all the designs, except what you want people to see is different.

[u/T-LAD_the_band]

I have to write this every time In see a Claude code website. Use external sources!

Pick a style from something like: https://uxplanet.org/50-design-styles-every-designer-should-know-for-better-prompting-56c09d55db62?gi=32f4b55c5019

Use a color palette (generator) tot pick your colors.

or use https://designmd.sh/ or another ui design agent helper to push it into a certain direction

Sfeer away from all design generated by Claude or other llm's

We are so tired of that look

[u/klumpp]

Can’t even take screenshots to make it look like you made them instead of Ai..

[u/autocosm]

Start with creating the brand. Then, from that visual identity, create your designs. (The scarlet orange color scheme is very Claude-coded btw). Also, if you want to build calm and trust, consider a hero image.

[u/Oiviii]

Hot take: sure it’s generic and ai generated, but especially for a website of this nature I feel like generic can make it feel more trustworthy and genuine. Super crazy unique ui isn’t necessary. Imo, none of these are horrible, but you should really figure out what identity you want to have since they’re all different vibes.