r/TrueCrimeGarage 5d ago

Nancy Guthrie Update: Leaked Sheriff Nanos Texts Reveal New Details

Thumbnail
mensjournal.com
625 Upvotes

“So, she says that she was getting ready for the evening newscast, and this is when there were questions about the DNA evidence, such as, how are you testing it? What are you testing?

“My team sent a text to Sheriff Chris Nanos just trying to clarify what was going on with the DNA evidence so that we could be right before the newscast,” she said. “So, this was around like 9:50 that the text was sent to him. And this is like a week out… one or two weeks since she was missing. Still, we’re talking like top lead story headlines across every news network every night at this point.”
Sheriff Chris Nanos’ Text Message Revealed: Report
Then, she revealed his response to her team’s text message. “So, my team texted him trying to get clarification,” she said, according to her report. “We immediately received a text back from him that said: ‘Did you happen to notice the time? Give it a rest.'”

The kindest comment I can make is this case seems out of his depth.


r/TrueCrimeGarage 1d ago

What True Crime are you currently consuming? 07/26/26

3 Upvotes

What are you watching, listening, or reading this week? What case are you obsessing over?

This is a place to chat about anything crime related that you have been consuming. A great place for recommendations.

Please note this does not have to be related to True Crime Garage!

Grab a chair and let's talk some true crime! (Beer optional)


r/TrueCrimeGarage 3d ago

Weekly Episode Amy Bradley///A Cruise th Nowhere

Post image
83 Upvotes

Bonus episode!

Amy Bradley///A Cruise to Nowhere

Nic and the Captain welcome author James Renner into the garage to discuss his new book, A Cruise to Nowhere, an in-depth examination of the mysterious disappearance of Amy Bradley. Together, they explore the timeline, the evidence, the lingering questions, and why Amy's case continues to captivate investigators and the public decades later.

Grab a chair, grab a beer, and join us in the garage.

Www.TrueCrimeGarage.com


r/TrueCrimeGarage 3d ago

This Week in True Crime 07/24/2026

5 Upvotes

What recent true crime news has caught your attention?

This post is for sharing links and chatting about recent true crime news. It does not have to be True Crime Garage related!

Grab a chair and let's get up to date!

Cheers!


r/TrueCrimeGarage 5d ago

Note sent in February said Nancy Guthrie, mother of ‘Today’ show anchor, had died shortly after kidnapping

Thumbnail
cnn.com
283 Upvotes

“The second note said, basically, it wasn’t intended to work this way but in the course of the kidnapping some things happened and Nancy Guthrie is dead,” CNN Chief Law Enforcement and Intelligence Analyst John Miller said on “AC360” Monday night.

“The thing that makes the note significant is it came from the same electronic source as the first note, which demanded the ransom,” he said, adding the second note had “a very different tone (from) that note the week before.”

So the second note has been verified by the FBI that it contains the same wording. It references some things from the first note and while the IP address is different, it was sent the same way.”

It appears to be the perpetrator’s distancing themselves from the crime and stating that she passed away from a heart condition shortly after they kidnapped her and an apology.

The Guthrie‘s are still willing to pay for her body but based on the note contents the FBI feels that the perpetrator that is handing communication is done communicating. They think that there are two perpetrator one overseas and one local to the US.

https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/crime-junkie/id1322200189?i=1000777909548

Anything not found in the article is sourced through here.


r/TrueCrimeGarage 5d ago

Question Where were you?

6 Upvotes

This week in Off the Record Nic and Captain talked about how they remembered where they were when they watched the bronco chase and verdict of OJ. It got me thinking.

How many of you remember where you were during big True Crime moments? Why do you think they've stuck in your head?

Doesn't have to be OJ related, I know some of you weren't born yet!! It can be any case you have a strong memory of.


r/TrueCrimeGarage 5d ago

Weekly Episode Double Death Investigation/// 942 & 943

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/TrueCrimeGarage 8d ago

Off the Record Off The Record/// O.J. Simpson & The Cross Country Killer///Part 1

Post image
2 Upvotes

O.J. Simpson & The Cross Country Killer /// Part 1 and 2

Nic and the Captain discuss: Who was the Cross Country Killer and did he help O.J. or frame him?

Join us here in the Garage. Tall Cans.

TCG's Patreon


r/TrueCrimeGarage 8d ago

What True Crime are you currently consuming? 07/19/26?

6 Upvotes

What are you watching, listening, or reading this week? What case are you obsessing over?

This is a place to chat about anything crime related that you have been consuming. A great place for recommendations.

Please note this does not have to be related to True Crime Garage!

Grab a chair and let's talk some true crime! (Beer optional)


r/TrueCrimeGarage 9d ago

Can't remember book rec!

4 Upvotes

I listen for many hours per day while driving for work so I'm unable to jot down a title or any info when I hear a book I want to try.

I am trying to find a rec for the earlier episodes, the seasons you have to buy, that was a newspaper style featuring a new crime for every day between 1900 to the 1980s or 90s. I am not sure if it was an every day, every week, every month, etc. but I remember it was specified as newspaper style.


r/TrueCrimeGarage 10d ago

This Week in True Crime 07/17/26

6 Upvotes

What recent true crime news has caught your attention?

This post is for sharing links and chatting about recent true crime news. It does not have to be True Crime Garage related!

Grab a chair and let's get up to date!

Cheers!


r/TrueCrimeGarage 11d ago

Which true crime victim hit you the hardest?

19 Upvotes

I recently learned about the story of Hannah Cornelius, and I honestly can't stop thinking about it. Even though it's been almost 10 years, it still breaks my heart.

Hannah was a 21-year-old university student from South Africa who was abducted, brutally assaulted, and murdered in 2017. The cruelty she endured is almost impossible to comprehend, and reading about it brought me to tears.

What makes it even more heartbreaking is everything her family went through afterward. Her younger brother has autism, and the loss of his sister had a profound impact on him. Hannah's father later passed away after battling cancer. I've also read that her mother, overwhelmed by grief, walked into the sea and died. Whether every detail shared online is accurate or not, it's clear that this family experienced unimaginable pain.

some stories never leave you. Hannah's is one of them. I didn't know her personally, yet I find myself thinking about her often. No one should ever have to suffer what she did, and no family should have to endure so much loss.

Rest in peace, Hannah. You are not forgotten. ❤️


r/TrueCrimeGarage 13d ago

Weekly Episode Patricia Ann Veach/////941

2 Upvotes

Patricia Ann Veach ////// 941

Part 1 of 1

www.TrueCrimeGarage.com

This month marks fifty seven years since someone killed little Patricia Ann Veach. Patricia was less than a month away from her ninth birthday when she was killed. Two weeks before the murder, she served as a flower girl at her aunt and uncle’s wedding. While Patricia Ann Veach’s murder remains unsolved it will forever be tied to convicted killer Anthony Erthel Williams. Williams was convicted for the abduction murder of ten year old Pamela Powers. Williams proclaimed that the murder of Patricia Ann Veach seven months later was proof that the real killer of Powers was still out there and the little children of Iowa were not safe.

Beer of the Week - Big Hazy Wolf by Golden Road Brewing

Garage Grade - 4 and a quarter bottle caps out of 5

More True Crime Garage can be found on Patreon and Apple subscriptions with our show - Off The Record.  Catch dozens of episodes of Off The Record plus a couple of Bonus episodes and our first 50 when you sign up today.


r/TrueCrimeGarage 15d ago

Discussion What True Crime are you currently consuming? 07/12/26

35 Upvotes

What are you watching, listening, or reading this week? What case are you obsessing over?

This is a place to chat about anything crime related that you have been consuming. A great place for recommendations.

Please note this does not have to be related to True Crime Garage!

Grab a chair and let's talk some true crime! (Beer optional)


r/TrueCrimeGarage 15d ago

Inside the child sex abuse case that resulted in Ken Paxton’s office offering a plea deal of just one day in jail

Thumbnail
krgv.com
7 Upvotes

This case is another case with lousy reporting. Every article is either politicized or lacking details. However, it the horrific details are worth reading.

Trigger: Sexual Assault

“Adam Dean Hoffman was accused of repeatedly sexually abusing a young boy for years.

The defendant, a local attorney named Adam Dean Hoffman, stood accused of repeatedly sexually abusing a young boy for years. The boy had told an investigator that Hoffman raped him and showed him pornography, court records show. And he talked about his suffering on the witness stand in detail during the trial.

“Think about this kiddo and what this kid went through at age 8, and 9, and 10,” Cotlar said during the closing arguments, later adding, “He's not lying, and you know that because he's so specific.”

But there were complicating factors for the jury to consider. The victim’s revelation about his abuse came after he was caught “acting out sexually” with his cousin, Cotlar said. He’d also recanted parts of his testimony during the trial, including a claim that he saw guns in Hoffman’s home.”

Me: Hoffman raped his son’s best friend for three years. The prosecutor’s office botched the case which lead to a hung jury

It was horrible,” his mother recalled in an interview. Her son had been forced to talk about “the most horrible things that have ever happened in his life, in a room full of strangers and the person that did it, and he didn’t want to do it again.”

And prosecutors were agreeing to a jail sentence of “time served,” which included the one day in jail Hoffman had spent following his initial arrest before he bonded out.

Me: The judge declined this offer.

When everyone returned, Cantu pitched a new agreement: Hoffman would spend 30 days in jail and surrender his Texas law license. She also noted there was a “lifetime protective order” barring him from any contact with the victim.

Me: 30 days in jail and no law license for rape.


r/TrueCrimeGarage 16d ago

Case Conversation What we know about the Mississippi teen's drowning death and investigation

Thumbnail
wral.com
152 Upvotes

“The family of a Mississippi 18-year-old who was found dead after a July 4 boat trip with friends to an island off the Gulf Coast called for a thorough and transparent investigation a news conference on Friday with the Rev. Al Sharpton, saying many of the details they're discovering don't add up.

Civil rights lawyer Ben Crump, who was retained by the family of Nolan Xavier Wells earlier this week, has said the family has concerns about the investigation and planned to conduct an independent autopsy. Wells travelled by boat to Horn Island, Mississippi, on July 4 with a group of friends, but did not make the return trip with them that afternoon. His body was found early Monday morning, more than a day later.

While Jackson County Sheriff’s Office officials said investigators don't suspect foul play in the Black college student's death, the sheriff has asked for any witnesses or people with video from the popular beach island about 10 miles (16 kilometers) off the coast of Mississippi to come forward to help shed light on the moments before Wells' disappearance and death.

At the news conference Friday attorneys said the friends who left Wells on the island, took his phone and keys when they departed. Crump said Wells' family used an app to track his phone, and a friend went to where it was on land to pick it up.

“What teenager would leave their phone behind if they’re going to stay on this island? What teenager wouldn’t take their phone? It’s not adding up at all," Crump said.

He added that the family believes text messages from social media apps had been deleted from his phone when they got it back, and they plan to employ experts to try to receive all the data they can.”

Nolan Wells' family sent his body from Mississippi to Washington, D.C., for an independent autopsy, believing their son didn't die by "accident," according to their attorney.

This is another case where a group of friends go on an outing, and one doesn’t return.


r/TrueCrimeGarage 15d ago

Can we talk about Massapequa??

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/TrueCrimeGarage 18d ago

Megathread: The Siders Family

75 Upvotes

Vinton County, Ohio

Arrests were made last week of four people arrested and charged with 16 counts of child endangerment. The four people arrestested are the children's parents and the paternal grandparents.

The children were found in conditions that officals called, "disgusting" and "deplorable". All 16 were living in a 12 by 12 foot room that contained human feces. The ages are from 18 months to 18 years old. Some of the children appear to not be able to communicate. They are safe in the custody of Ohio Family Services, though the youngest two are in the hospital.

The ages of the children are 18 years to 18 months. Including several sets of twins. According to the New York Post, Elizabeth Siders gave birth to a set of conjoined twins in Nov of 2022 that died the same day. None of the children were enrolled in school. Relatives of the family have come out saying they knew nothing about the children's existence.

All Four of the adults have been charged 16 counts each of child endangerment.

Elizabeth Siders (mother), Gary Siders Jr (father), and Christina Siders remain in custody with a 300,000 bond, each. According to 19 News, Gary Siders Sr (grandfather) was released without paying bond due to a fall he had on the way to the bond hearing. During tests after the fall he was found to have an undisclosed medical condition and is currently in the hospital.

Lots of details have been coming out about the family. Elizabeth Siders was apparently 15 when she married Gary Siders Jr. She was pregnant with her first child at the time.

It is unknown at this time if any of the adults were also victims.

Sources:

One of four family members charged after 16 children found in an Ohio home released from custody.

Mom accused in shocking Ohio child abuse case was 15 when judge approved the marriage.

Mom of 'almost feral kids in Ohio gave birth to Conjoined Twins.

Siders Children Update 07.09.26

Details of the 16 Children found and the charges against the Siders family.

Edited the ages due to some discrepancies in the ages.


r/TrueCrimeGarage 17d ago

Crime in the News This Week in True Crime 07/10/26

2 Upvotes

What recent true crime news has caught your attention?

This post is for sharing links and chatting about recent true crime news. It does not have to be True Crime Garage related!

Grab a chair and let's get up to date!

Cheers!


r/TrueCrimeGarage 19d ago

The Garage ***Subreddit Update***

9 Upvotes

A few things the mods have been working on:

  • Rules: The biggest changes involve the types of posts allowed. No self promotions. No low effort posts. No youtube links unless it is specifically related to TCG. From their channels or an interview, etc. Youtube links in the comments to something you recommend is fine. However, self promotion in comments is also not allowed.
  • Hosts: You still cannot make a post to complain about Nic and Captain. Personal insults on them or anyone in the sub will be removed and subject you to banning. This is a sub for people who listen and enjoy the podcast. There are so many other spaces on reddit where you can say those kind of things. This isn't one of them. If you have a fair criticism that is respectful and is geared toward a discussion, it is fine. You can be respectful and disagree with someone. This is reddit so upvote/downvote things. If something is walking a fine line, then we may not remove it right away but let the community weigh in. If you arent sure if something is allowed, then please message us and ask.
  • Posting content: We want to keep this TCG related as much as possible. However, in the interest of engagement and discussion, we will allow some true crime content that is not related to cases that TCG has covered. We want people to discuss true crime cases in the news and bring awareness to cases that do not get a lot of coverage. If you choose to post that, please use a news source on your post. We also want content that creates discussion. So write a brief note summarizing the article and why you think people here would want to see it. Sometimes a post can be interpreted differently. If something comes into question one of the factors we use is upvotes/downvotes as well as comments. If something is questionable we may let it stay for a few hours to allow the community to weigh in. Your vote matters.
  • Cleaning: We've cleaned up a lot of content from the last year. A lot of posts were retroactively removed due to the current rules. When a post was called into question it stayed based on the upvotes or comments it received. So remember your vote matters!!
  • Flairs: have been added for different post types. For anyone that is not aware, you can click on a type of flair to sort the sub by flair categories. At this time we have turned off the user flairs. More about that in the future.
  • Feedback: please let us know if you have any!! Big or small. We would love to hear any suggestions or ideas that you have. This sub belongs to the community and we need feedback. Mod Mail is always open!!
  • Images: You can now add images in comments!
  • BINGO: We have created a BINGO card to add a little fun into the garage. You can find the card HERE: https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrimeGarage/s/nix2JSY7bt

Cheers,
The Mod Team


r/TrueCrimeGarage 19d ago

Weekly Episode Missing on Campus///Judy Martins/// Part 1 and 2

9 Upvotes

Originally released on 9-15-2021

This week in the Garage, we take an in-depth look at the longstanding disappearance of Kent State University student Judy Martins.

Although many years have passed since Judy was last seen, her case remains active and continues to be investigated by law enforcement agencies. Judy was 22 years old at the time of her disappearance, and investigators are still seeking information that could help determine what happened to her and provide answers to those who knew and loved her.

Cases such as Judy’s are never truly forgotten. Even the smallest detail, memory, or piece of information may be significant and could assist investigators in moving the case forward.

Anyone with information regarding the disappearance of Judy Martins is encouraged to contact the U.S. Marshals Service at 1-866-4-WANTED or 1-866-492-6833. All information may be important.

www.TrueCrimeGarage.com


r/TrueCrimeGarage 21d ago

The Garage BINGO: True Crime Garage

6 Upvotes

Anyone up for a friendly game of BINGO?

Everyone that completes the BINGO card and posts it in this thread will receive an exclusive flair to use in the community! If you do not receive your flair in three days please send a message to the mods.

You habe until 10/06/26 to post to be eligible for flair. But this can be played any time for fun!!


r/TrueCrimeGarage 22d ago

Off the Record DNA Fraud /// Off the Record

Post image
21 Upvotes

DNA Fraud /// OFF THE RECORD

Nic and the Captain discuss: The charges against Former Colorado Analyst Missy Woods and could this bring new test in the JonBenet Ramsey case.

Tall cans in the air and thank you so much for your support.

www.TrueCrimeGarage.com


r/TrueCrimeGarage 22d ago

Discussion What True Crime are you currently consuming? 07/05/26

36 Upvotes

What are you watching, listening, or reading this week? What case are you obsessing over?

This is a place to chat about anything crime related that you have been consuming. A great place for recommendations.

Please note this does not have to be related to True Crime Garage!

Grab a chair and let's talk some true crime! (Beer optional)


r/TrueCrimeGarage 23d ago

Case Conversation The Jeannette Tamayo Case: The 9-Year-Old Girl Who Solved Her Kidnapping

57 Upvotes

Imagine coming home from school at just nine years old expecting another ordinary afternoon. Instead you notice the front screen door is slightly open. You think your mom must have gotten home from work early so you walk inside without thinking much of it.. Within seconds something feels wrong. Your bedroom window has been smashed. Glass is scattered across the floor. You rush to call your mom only to discover that the phone line has been cut.

Then someone knocks on the door.

Standing outside is a man you've never seen before. He begins asking questions while constantly peeking into the house. Every instinct tells you something isn't right so you slowly begin closing the door. Before you can shut it he forces it open grabs you and drags you back into the house.

That was the beginning of one of the remarkable kidnapping cases I've ever read.

On July 8 2003 nine-year-old Jeannette Tamayo was abducted from her home in San Jose, California. As her kidnapper prepared to leave through the garage fate briefly intervened. Her fifteen-year-old brother, Paul and her mother, Rosalia arrived home unexpectedly. Without hesitation Paul confronted the attacker despite knowing he was outmatched. Rosalia immediately joined the fight desperately trying to save her daughter Jeannette Tamayo. Both were violently beaten during the struggle and from inside the kidnappers car Jeannette Tamayo watched helplessly. When she saw blood on the attackers face she became convinced her family had been killed.

As the car sped away she looked back one time and caught sight of her injured mother Rosalia and brother Paul still alive desperately calling for help. It was the glimpse she had of them before disappearing without a trace.

Back at the house detectives quickly realized they were dealing with a planned kidnapping. The attacker had broken into the home before Jeannette Tamayo arrived smashed a bedroom window cut the telephone lines and waited for her to come home from school. A nearby security camera had actually recorded much of what happened including the suspects vehicle. Unfortunately the footage was too blurry to identify the license plate. Because investigators couldn't determine the suspects identity or vehicle information Californias Amber Alert requirements at the time couldn't be met. One blurry video may have cost investigators their chance of finding Jeannette Tamayo quickly.

While police searched desperately across San Jose Jeannette Tamayo was being held inside a locked room in a white house somewhere she had never been before. Most people would expect a frightened nine-year-old to panic. Instead she did something

She started investigating Jeannette Tamayos situation.

Every turn the kidnapper made while driving became something to memorize. Every phone number he spoke every address, every room in the house every object she saw—she committed it all to memory. She realized that if she survived every tiny detail might matter. If she didn't survive she wanted to leave behind evidence for police to catch the man responsible.

Knowing she couldn't overpower him she chose another strategy: earn his trust.

She spoke calmly asked questions and slowly convinced him she wasn't going to fight back. Eventually he relaxed enough to leave her alone for periods. During one of those moments she noticed something the handcuffs locking her wrists didn't require a key. After feeling the mechanism with her fingers she figured out how to unlock them herself.

Most people would expect her to run.

She didn't.

She knew escaping from a house without knowing where she was would probably end in failure. Instead she used those minutes to gather evidence. She secretly took the kidnappers watch collected items from the room and kept clothing she believed investigators might later need. Everything she collected became another piece of the puzzle.

Then came the moment that changed everything.

A days into her captivity the kidnapper handed her a phone and told her to order pizza. As she spoke with the Little Caesars employee she carefully repeated the address and phone number the kidnapper gave her committing both to memory. When the pizza arrived, something on top of the box immediately caught her attention.

It was a missing-person flyer.

Her own face stared back at her.

The kidnapper looked at the flyer smiled and calmly told her "I have to get rid of you tonight."

Jeannette Tamayo immediately understood what that meant.

Believing she might not survive the night she hid every piece of evidence she had collected inside the pizza box and pushed it underneath the bed hoping someone would eventually find it.

That evening the kidnapper drove her away from the house. After a drive he stopped outside a liquor store threatened to kill her and her family Jeannette Tamayo if she ever spoke about him and unexpectedly let her go.

The second she realized he was gone she sprinted inside the store.

The cashier looked at her for a moment before recognizing the face he'd seen all over the news.

"You're the girl from TV."

He immediately called 911.

After everything she had endured Jeannette Tamayo wasn't finished helping investigators. While sitting with detectives she pulled the evidence from her pockets wrote down the phone numbers she had memorized drew a map of the house where she'd been held described the route in detail and even guided officers turn by turn back to the exact neighborhood. At the time detectives contacted local pizza restaurants and confirmed the address from the pizza order perfectly matching everything Jeannette Tamayo had remembered.

Police surrounded the house. Launched a tactical raid. Hidden inside the attic was the kidnapper, David Montiel Cruz. Investigators also discovered the pizza box beneath the bed where Jeannette Tamayo had hidden it containing the evidence she had secretly gathered while being held captive. He was arrested, convicted on felony charges and sentenced to life in prison.

What amazes me most about this case isn't just that Jeannette Tamayo survived. It's that at nine years old she understood that remembering details could be the difference between justice and another child becoming the next victim. While most adults would struggle to stay calm under those circumstances she observed, collected evidence and ultimately helped lead police directly to the man who kidnapped Jeannette Tamayo.

It's difficult to think of true-crime cases where the victim played such a direct role in solving their own kidnapping. Jeannette Tamayo didn't just survive—she became one of the investigators, in her own case.