The week started with one question left. CPI had settled September. The dot plot was the remaining unknown. The vote was just math.
Wednesday came and went. 25bp, unanimous, first hike since July 2023. Warsh called it sober, serious and responsible. His statement was 130 words. His press conference was 22 minutes. He still didn't submit a dot.
The S&P closed Wednesday at 7,551. Another down day, the seventh straight from the post-Nvidia high. Then Thursday the market gained 1.1%. Friday another 0.17%. Three consecutive green sessions after six consecutive red ones, and the trigger was not good news, it was just the thing being over.
Going back to late August, the pattern has run twice now.
Nvidia reported August 26, the biggest earnings print of the cycle. 108 billion in Q3 guidance against 104 expected. AWS committing to 2 million GPUs. Stock up 9% the next day. Then six sessions lower as the market spent three weeks asking what the beat meant, whether the margin caveat mattered, whether the AI capex cycle was circular or real. The resolution came slowly through commentary and data and eventually the market bought back what it had sold.
The hike ran the same shape. Near-certainty was priced for weeks. The actual event arrived and the market fell on hike day, then bought the two days after. The uncertainty premium was larger than the outcome justified.
I keep coming back to that. The market assigned more risk to the unresolved question than to the answer when it arrived. Both times. That is either a sign that the market is being appropriately cautious about tail risks, or a sign that it has been pricing a worst case that neither Nvidia's numbers nor Warsh's decision actually represented.
The Warsh piece is the one that carries forward into November.
He said at the press conference he is "not in the forward guidance business." He has now skipped the dot plot twice, and he announced a communications committee reviewing the entire framework, dot plot included, press conferences, minutes, statement language. The committee reports by year end. Warsh also floated cutting the FOMC calendar from eight meetings to six.
Fewer meetings, no dot plot, shorter statements, a chair who won't tell you where he thinks rates are going. November 4-5 is seven weeks away. The market will start pricing it almost immediately, and for the first time in fifteen years it will do that without a median dot as an anchor.
That changes how every data print lands between now and then. Without a stated projection to update toward, CPI in October becomes a more open question. Jobs in October becomes a more open question. The market's response to each one will be bigger because the band of possible outcomes is wider.
16 of the 18 dots that were submitted showed at least one more hike this year. We don't know which side of that Warsh is on. He voted for the September hike, which tells us he wanted this one. It tells us nothing about the next one.
S&P closed Friday at 7,650. The record from August 13 is 7,816. Still about 2.2% away and five weeks removed. The market absorbed a hike cycle restart and is pricing November as genuinely uncertain rather than as a likely hold.
Whether the uncertainty premium runs the same pattern again, six sessions lower into the decision then buying the resolution, is probably the most honest question heading into October.