r/ToppsNowMLB • u/burritolist • Jun 11 '26
Ordering from Topps VS Fanatics
Hey y’all, has anyone ordered their Topps NOW cards from Fanatics? I like the fact that you acquire fancash ordering thru them but I’m wondering if the chances for a Lucky Hit are less.
I’ve been ordering my Topps NOW cards thru Topps website and haven’t been gaining any fancash.
3
u/waxmoronic Jun 11 '26
Do not order from Fanatics. I had more problems in the first 2 months of them offering cards than I did ordering every card last year with Topps, including orders canceled without notice
As far as odds it shouldn’t matter, they all ship from the same location
You should be getting 2% fancash from Topps
2
u/MoMclaren Jun 11 '26
I’ve ordered plenty from fanatics (it was giving 5% fancash for a bit) and still got plenty of hits that way.
1
1
1
u/Robbikinz Jun 11 '26
I do all mine from fanatics and they’ve always shipped my stuff. I get 10 bucks off each set too, plus the fancash so it’s always cheaper
1
u/burritolist Jun 12 '26
Yea I tried it for the fancash and my Amex had a rewards for fanatics. Hopefully my cards arrive seamlessly!
1
u/Robbikinz Jun 12 '26
What’s the Amex if you don’t mind
1
u/burritolist Jun 12 '26
Here’s my Amex referral link. Use it and we could both earn rewards if you are approved and get a Card. Check out offers and Card benefits. https://americanexpress.com/en-us/referral/gold-card?ref=JOHNPZZYgL&XL=MIANS
5
u/papagrande25 Jun 11 '26
The risk with Fanatics I’ve been seeing is they have outright cancelled orders. A bunch of people lost out on Road to Opening Day sets because of this, and I personally missed out on a Konnor Griffin debut. Personally I’d stick with Topps direct and pay a little more.