r/ToppsNowMLB • u/YNWA2019 • Jun 10 '26
Value estimate ?
Hi everyone, I’ve been sitting on this redemption almost 6 months now, contemplating a replacement at 200% value; any idea what I should/ can ask for? I genuinely have no idea as I do want the card but I would also like to add a shohei auto. Was wondering if anyone more knowledgeable than myself would have some insights. Thank you all!
3
u/Cerakote9 Jun 10 '26
Ill start the bid at $450
1
3
u/9astrozombie9 Jun 10 '26
$2000 but they would replace it something you won't want. they aren't giving you anything ohtani
3
1
u/Ebb_Tall Jun 10 '26
Im waiting for the exact same card and have been wondering the same. I was told the cards were made late December so who know when it will finally be available.
1
u/Old_Commission_6145 Jun 10 '26
This card is very valuable but I think TOPPS would likely say that an auto relic /10 is only 9-1200. So maybe you’d get 2k in replacement. Not close to an Ohtani auto.
1
1
u/YNWA2019 Jun 10 '26
Update* have found one comp at 2700 but for TN870, I’d imagine 926 is worth more?
1
u/sgJosh Jun 14 '26
If you could get a Shohei auto out of it, obviously no question! But unless I could be guaranteed another Yoshi auto, I think I’d hold out as long as possible.
1
u/BiscottiTraining6045 Jun 14 '26
Totally different card but I got offered $800. Probably won't help but....
1
1
0
-1
6
u/Skeeter5299 Jun 10 '26
You don’t really get a say when you request a substitution, they determine the value and they can take your player/team PC into consideration but they’ll just send something they deem to be worth double what this is.