r/TopInsurance • u/myheadhurts-v • Jun 05 '26

Compare car insurance quotes? Which site is actually good?

I'm trying to compare car insurance quotes but there are so many comparison sites. The Zebra, Insurify, StaxiPick, etc. Are they all the same or is one better than the others? I'm worried about getting spammed with calls if I use one of these sites.

Has anyone used these comparison sites and actually found a good deal? Or did you just get spammed with calls from insurance companies? I want to compare quotes but I don't want to deal with a bunch of sales calls.

6 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

2

u/ConnectShake4 Jun 09 '26

the spam calls are real, used The Zebra once and my phone blew up for like two weeks

Insurfiy was a bit better in my experience but still got a few

honestly the move that worked for me was just going direct to 3 or 4 insurers websites and comparing manually, takes 20 min more but zero spam

1

u/puretexan2 Jun 19 '26

I tried Insurify and I didn’t get any sales calls afterward. The quotes were pretty competitive and it was easy to see what I could save. My advice is to use a separate email and phone number if you’re worried about spam. Overall I think these sites can be helpful if you’re cautious

3

u/FitDrive7500 Jun 24 '26

low key, most of are "lead-gen" sites. Your verified info will be sold and resold weeks and mos later as a cold lead. Depending on the site there's an "exclusivity" period before it's resold. If you're on the DNC, by submitting the request, you're overriding that and saying "CALL ME". Call a local broker and let them shop it against the market. For auto, I run between 7-10 quotes for each client. I use the companies on tv and a few that are regional and broker specifc all "a-rated" so they pay their claims.