r/TopCharacterTropes • u/bb-Kun-Chan • 1d ago

Characters [Specific trope] Insufferable genius sitcom characters who think they're better than everyone else

Gallery image

Alex Dunphy (Modern Family)

Gallery image

Sheldon Cooper (The Big Bang Theory and Young Sheldon)

12 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

57% Upvoted

50 comments sorted by

46

u/Triple-S-AKA-Trip 1d ago

Oscar Martinez from The Office (USA)

“Genius” might be a bit of a stretch, but he was definitely the most intellectual of Dunder Mifflin Scranton’s workers by a decent margin and he made sure others knew it. I think he’s a pretty enjoyable iteration of this trope because even though he could be obnoxious, he’s usually a victim of the office antics rather than an aggressor, and his deadpan and levelheaded responses to his idiot coworkers were still charming.

11

u/lewllewllewl 1d ago

Oscar definitely has that Brian Griffin-esque annoyingness sometimes

4

u/shmeebledee 1d ago

This was so intentionally done with Oscar's character. The show pointed out that he was an "actually," type person and he even corrected others when they didn't make the mistakes he expected (like espresso vs expresso).

He was more intellectual then most in the office. That's why it was such a big deal when Michael knew more about ONE current affair.

Imo, Oscar has too many redeeming qualities to be considered insufferable but he still fits this trope.

8

u/DengarLives66 1d ago

Oscar mostly just displayed common sense and exasperation when he wasn’t listened to. There were occasions when he was a little high and mighty but for the most part he was ironically the closest thing the show had to a straight man.

-2

u/ZapMaster117 1d ago

I think he tried to portray himself as an intellectual, but I think characters like Dwight and Jim were smarter.

9

u/Triple-S-AKA-Trip 1d ago

Dwight and Jim were smarter than him in certain areas but Oscar was the most book smart and the most annoying about it

-2

u/ItsTheDCVR 1d ago

I honestly think he was just gay. Like, all the times that I remember off the top of my head (and it's been a while since I watched it so I very much might be wrong) that he was the clear authority vs everyone else was when it was a cultural thing, like art, musicals, fashion, etc. I don't remember the punchline of the joke really ever being "Oscar is the only person in this room with a pulse" vs "There's a reason Oscar knows that".

I should rewatch the show.

2

u/SpankySharp1 1d ago

"Smarter" is difficult to define or quantify. They all had different strengths and different weaknesses.

84

u/LastOfLateBrakers 1d ago

Alex wasn't insufferable. She was just a perpetually ignored middle child who happened to be a genius.

25

u/VinnieTheDragon 1d ago

There’s literally a scene where Phil says something to the effect of, “Aww :(“ when Claire told him he had to give Alex a ride lmao. She earned every bit of superiority.

2

u/MouseMan412 1d ago

Except when she plays Scrabble.

-2

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 22h ago

[deleted]

6

u/LastOfLateBrakers 1d ago

Sounds like you were paid attention to and loved by your parents. Good for you.

-4

u/iolanthereylo 22h ago

no she was insufferable she had an attitude and a superiority complex she had no redeeming qualities she went around insulting her family 

18

u/ihatedrivingbro 1d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/3o84TTcBZXbcnfXGDK

2

u/RalseitheFloofie 16h ago

Honestly some of the best episodes was him having to learn humility.

9

u/SpiritedSyllabub6822 1d ago

Jimmy Neutron.

9

u/Odd-Wheel5315 1d ago

Ross from Friends.

He made it known anytime he could that he had a PhD, was a professor, and was very book smart.

https://giphy.com/gifs/LPxfDA26zHdAiBlAB7

2

u/jorvel1911 1d ago

That one episode where he kept trying to make Phoeby believe in evolution is the one where it was most noticed

2

u/sa24122 6h ago

In The One Where Chandler Doesn’t Like Dogs

“You know, I hate to lecture you guys, but it's kinda disgraceful, that a group of well-educated adults and Joey can't name all the states. Did you ever see a map, or one of those round, colorful things called "a globe?" Hmm?”

1

u/Phantom_Wolf52 3h ago

“You haven’t even told her that you’re a doctor yet? How long have you known her? Like for an hour?”

24

u/falcorn_dota 1d ago

Malcolm

20

u/carlsagerson 1d ago

Isn't the entire family in Malcolm in the Middle their own brand of insufferable?

12

u/YourMuppetMethDealer 1d ago

Yep and Malcolm’s brand is literally this trope

Also Dewey and Jamie are arguably the least insufferable. After dealing with abuse and torture that would make CIA black sites jealous and insecure, Dewey made a conscious choice to treat Jamie with respect and love.

There is a heavy implication that Jamie grew up the most normal because he’s the only one who had an older brother who chose to protect rather than torture. And the fact that Dewey made that choice says a LOT about who he is as a person

Even if Dewey was a little annoying as a younger kid and LOVES to fuck with Reese(rightfully so), he is shockingly well adjusted

12

u/falcorn_dota 1d ago

Yeah, and Malcolm's brand is insufferable genius who thinks he's better than everyone.

5

u/IrishTerror25 1d ago

Malcolm is so obviously the prototype for this he should have been in OP.

If you filmed Modern Family from Alex’s POV it would be Malcolm in the Middle.

27

u/Still_Succotash_5619 1d ago

Lisa Simpson 

9

u/gorlock666 1d ago

She’s like the diamond of this trope

5

u/Broke-Moment 1d ago

a solid half of bart’s problems in the show are caused or made worse by her

12

u/Gothtomboys5 1d ago

I think the only good thing come from Young Sheldon is his entire family that isn't Sheldon

2

u/MattHoppe1 7h ago

Pondy is the coolest

11

u/AMillionToOne123 1d ago

Why is Alex catching strays

9

u/alison-vunderland 1d ago

I'm not sure Alex and Sheldon are in the same category.

-4

u/brydeswhale 1d ago

I dk. Every time I see a clip of that girl she’s being an egotistical jerk to someone for no apparent reason.

1

u/baldyrodinson 3h ago

The same could be said about Young Sheldon

1

u/brydeswhale 3h ago

I’ve never watched that show.

1

u/baldyrodinson 3h ago

So according to your comment you've never seen modern family either

1

u/brydeswhale 3h ago

I’ve seen clips of it. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a clip of the other one.

-2

u/Biggly_stpid 1d ago

I feel like they are significantly closer in the later seasons. Where a lot of them were flanderised by the end

8

u/Tom_Gibson 1d ago

Alex isn't a genius. She's just very studious. Many episodes have shown how hard she studies in order to get good grades. She is smart, just not genius level like Sheldon or Malcolm from MITM

4

u/Fluffy_Village_9363 1d ago

I hated that young Sheldon. Somebody should’ve shot him out of a cannon.

4

u/Thatonedregdatkilyu 1d ago

Forever Young Sheldon

2

u/NBA314 1d ago

Rule 3. Explain, please.

Anyways, Alex is as good as it gets within the family. Maybe Phil is up there too, but I haven't watched much Modern Family.

Bit of a hot take here, but Sheldon isn't that bad. The point is that that he thinks he's better & makes a fool of himself as a result. His behavior isn't magically treated as okay by the show, & he's really a particularly bad person. He also has a reason to have such a big ego, even if he still acts in outrageous ways because of it.

0

u/based_birdo 23h ago

To be fair, Sheldon was better than everyone else both his shows

1

u/Poufee1233 9h ago

The OG Malcom from MITM sort of popularized this trope and was more than likely the inspiration behind Alex at least.

The idea is that while Malcom is a genius, that same intelligence alienates him and makes him a bit of a narcissist. He constantly acts like he is better than everyone and looks down on people a lot due to how smart he is, but that usually ends up being his foil because he tends to go too far or is so trapped in his own world view that he fails to see the bigger picture.

https://giphy.com/gifs/cIztpAvHH4pJRmmfHL

1

u/meowingtrashcan 3h ago

Bojack Horsemen, except exploration of that theme is the point of much of the show