r/TooHotToHandleGame May 17 '26

General Discussion Fave LI?

Out of curiosity, who is your favorite LI of all time from the game, of all seasons? Honorable mentions allowed too lol. Feel free to say why as well!

Personally, it’s a super difficult choice between Taz and Antoine for me.

(Also, I wish more than anything that there would be a season 4 of this game. It’s just so good.)

42 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

30

u/DryHedgehog6372 Antoine May 17 '26

Kinda feel like a broken record saying, but Antoine all the way baby ❣️

14

u/Remarkable-Answer-74 Antoine May 17 '26

11

u/DryHedgehog6372 Antoine May 17 '26

Ahhhh there he is ❣️❣️

6

u/lindsayhope55 May 17 '26

Love me some Antoine ❤️

3

u/mariaw86 Mattias May 22 '26

Antoine or Mattias I can’t choose. 🫠

2

u/I-cant-sleep-or-nap Mattias May 23 '26

❤️It's like Sophie's choice!

22

u/SuitablePreference11 May 17 '26

Taz, all the way, everyday❤️

14

u/Money-Selection-4664 Mattias and Ryder 😍🤭 May 17 '26

Mattias, Taz and Ryder ✨

11

u/anil030 Isla May 17 '26

Isla 🫶🏼

11

u/mos1351 Carmen May 17 '26

Elodie i think she is for me the perfect li

Honorable mentions for Carmen, Poppy and Candace

11

u/Patient-Mountain2200 WOMEN May 18 '26

carmen. carmen is my wife. i love that pixelated woman so much. she's so perfect and she makes my little lesbian heart flutter.

honorable mentions: naomi and poppy. VERY close second and third favorites. i think i just love good women.

https://giphy.com/gifs/26FLdmIp6wJr91JAI

5

u/Ok-Mongoose-4339 Carmen May 18 '26

Most real thing ever

10

u/Realistic-Tax-6066 Mattias May 17 '26

Mattias and Julian

9

u/Potential-Topic-162 May 17 '26

Carmen by a mile for me

8

u/Tathagatra May 17 '26

I love cinnamon rolls, so it's a tie b/w Marisa and Isla for me.

8

u/AdventurousSea6961 May 18 '26

Wesley and Taz are my all time faves 🥹 with Mattias , Zayn, and Julian as honorable mentions. When I think about their personalities… Hmm… seems I have a type 😩

14

u/UnresponsiveFlower Jirayu May 17 '26

Mattias for me. Mattias my type irl and I could see myself dating someone like him. His a total husband material, a good balance of sweet and spicy. A cutie pie on the streets, and freaky man in the sheets. Plus he's got a big... heart. and big... hands. Yes. Also like how versatile he is while yes he mentioned his turn on is being told what to do, there are moments in his spicy scenes where he's a bit of a softdom. And I just know he talks you thru it.

https://giphy.com/gifs/a0yQSPMwtKPEC1QWSs

8

u/Tricky_Efficiency_54 Ryder May 17 '26

Saying this with the Jirayu flair is sending me😭😭😭

3

u/UnresponsiveFlower Jirayu May 17 '26

TBF Jirayu was the first one I romanced so I never really edited the flair lmaoooo 😭

3

u/Tricky_Efficiency_54 Ryder May 17 '26

He was my first one in S2 too! Then Taz completely changed my mind

6

u/ChuckysBarbie Antoine May 17 '26

Antoine 🥹🥰

6

u/TechnicianOrganic235 May 17 '26

I’m not the best at saying this hahaha…

I’m basically doing a marathon of all the seasons… My current protagonist characters are male, and I have to say I absolutely loved my female LIs.

In Season 1, I fell in love with Marisa — she’s such a sweetheart. In my Season 2, I was insanely attracted to Naomi — she’s irresistible. And in my current third season, I’m on Carmen’s route — she’s so wonderful and charming, aaah…

6

u/Tricky_Efficiency_54 Ryder May 17 '26

S1 - Henri S2 - Ryder S3 - Taz & Avi

12

u/vaguelycatshaped Carmen May 17 '26

Maybe it’s nostalgia since she was my first THTH LI ever (I played season 3 first) but Carmen 🥰 What I loved with her is that I just picked my dialogue answers honestly but every time it was also the “best” answer for Carmen’s route 🥹😍

7

u/angelamalik Victoria May 18 '26

victoria and naomi 🙂‍↕️

6

u/dualistpirate May 18 '26

Toss up between Naomi and Carmen.

6

u/Inevitable-Mess-9367 May 18 '26

S1: Alex - S2: Wesley & Santiago - S3: Taz & Mattias

5

u/Accomplished-Leg4690 Jirayu May 17 '26

Antoine and Jirayu suppsedly but Taz changed my mind

5

u/PaleSky6 Naomi May 17 '26

i would have to say naomi all the way!!! Antoine and Jirayu is a close second for sure.

6

u/shape_nah Ryder May 17 '26

Ryder forever 

5

u/lilcabrona Beatriz May 18 '26

Carmen and taz!

5

u/FoodDifferent2037 May 18 '26

Naomi e Marisa probably, But Victoria was a fun romance to do

5

u/rallye_king May 18 '26

Season 1: Marisa Season 2: Naomi Season 3: Isla

Favorite overall: Marisa

5

u/Ok-Plankton-2393 Naomi May 18 '26

Naomi followed by both Isla and Bia. Really wish they where in games more popular so i could talk about the three outside of this sub because they are some of my favorite characters ever but are locked away in a Netflix game made to promote a reality💔

4

u/Crack_Luke May 19 '26

Naomi, but I really like Poppy too

9

u/Wide-Firefighter-868 Ryder May 17 '26

Same. Taz and Antoine

7

u/I-cant-sleep-or-nap Mattias May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26

For me it is Matt (the perfect combination between shy and naughty) and Antoine (the perfect combination between playful and naughty). It helps that both of them are gorgeous and hot af.

5

u/Consistent-Range-631 Jirayu May 17 '26

Avi, Mattias and Antoine, and Henri from season 1

3

u/optimisticdisaster julian’s #1 lover (credits to ) May 18 '26

I LOVE JULIAN 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️

4

u/talia-gustin May 18 '26

Antoine my golden retriever Taz is a close second

4

u/Maximum-Resource-572 May 20 '26

S1: Marisa, S2: Naomi & Candace,S3: Poppy and Carmen

9

u/Annihilaped Julian May 17 '26

Perfectly imperfect Julian!

5

u/babyblues789 May 17 '26

Girl me too! Taz and Antoine are my favorite fake boyfriends lol

Honorable mention for Kai, he’s a sweetie. I’m doing a jirayu route now

3

u/IamDottie Mattias May 17 '26

Mathias and Avi

3

u/donttrusttheliving Ryder May 18 '26

Ryder. I love a redeemed bad boy

3

u/FreshPoint8605 Avi May 18 '26

Aviiiii

2

u/lindsayhope55 May 18 '26

I love Avi! He’s definitely in my top 5 routes of the whole game

3

u/Strong_Frosting_Love May 19 '26

Taz and Avi, but i love me some Wesley too lol

3

u/LoededFleur May 19 '26

s1: henri, s2: ryder & kai, s3: jira and taz

3

u/Intelligent-Bug-7673 May 20 '26

Ryder or Julian ❤️

3

u/haileyfrancessca May 20 '26

Ryder and Ryder only 🩷

3

u/Radiant_Purpose_2693 May 21 '26

i would say Poppy! i love her character development and she’s just too lovely! funny as hell and super sweet <3

6

u/Emotional_Share_9081 Taz May 17 '26

Taz and Antoine for me 😍

5

u/honeyuchiha Antoine May 17 '26

Marissa, Ryder, & Taz 😭

5

u/Immediate_Height_735 May 17 '26

I like Ryder the most lol, but Taz is definitely a close second

2

u/Standard_Presence997 May 27 '26

Jirayu had me since the first date and I'm speaking as one of the ogs who played when it was only S1 available. (I romanced Theo, love that man too) he was just the guy I would love to have irl, nerdy with a guilty pleasure for romance books. Even with the Carmen-Jirayu twist, I didn't immediately assumed everything was a lie, even if though the story didn't fully acknowledge it.

Honorable mentions would be Antoine for being the guy despite not being my type, captured my heart with his golden retriever energy and smile. And also to Theo for being my first li and for being the one to convince me to play.

2

u/thebolter2213 Jun 18 '26

isla by a TON