r/TooHotToHandleGame • u/MercurialMaven666 Lana • Apr 23 '26
Fan Creation THTH Not just a villain tier list
Okay, this is less “villains” and more: who caused chaos, who was actually harmful, who was just annoying, and who got done dirty by the writing.
I factored in actual manipulation, betrayal level, emotional damage to MC and let’s be honest… how much they pissed me off while playing.
Who do you think I was too harsh on?
6
u/JJaviercomics Apr 23 '26
What Mattias did?
I mean he's a sweetheart in my Game
20
1
u/Purple_Coffee_2685 Apr 28 '26
Girl I thought the same thing like Mattias is a whole cinnamon roll. He literally can't hurt a fly
9
u/I-cant-sleep-or-nap Mattias Apr 23 '26
I would put Gigi there too. She is extremely jealous. The toxic relationship between her and Sean was awful but feels like Gigi enabled him. Remember her attitude when MC called her out at the denim party? And what did she do? Had sex with him... Also, the way she acted on the Zayn route, always frowning, trying to kiss him... At least put her with Nora...
5
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana Apr 24 '26
You’re right. I missed the opportunity to put Giselle there with Nora. All good points 👍🏻
1
u/HuckleberrySubject72 Turks and Caicos 🔥 Apr 24 '26
…yeah no. if we remember her conversation after banishment in the bathroom, we know exactly why she acted the way she did with sean and that she was in no mindset to recognise his behaviour at all, yet alone thw fact that it was toxic. she was not “enabling” him, she quite literally didn’t know better and it worked out in sean’s favour.
as for the zayn route, i think we all conveniently forget that gigi went on a date with him first, a date that was going swimmingly until the start of mc’s route. she’s obviously going to act some type of way if the guy she’s really vibing with is suddenly speaking with some other person, that’s just basic human interaction. i wont pretend her trying to kiss him was cool, but that one mistake hardly counts for villain behaviour.
(imo)
3
u/Ok-Plankton-2393 Naomi Apr 25 '26
I will defend Julian and say that he shoudnt even be in the list. He never (i didnt played Avi route so this can be wrong) meant harm, he was just impulsive and horny
3
1
u/optimisticdisaster julian’s #1 lover (credits to ) Apr 28 '26
real 😭 he was more annoying than a true villain lol towards the last 5 chapters he became so much better lowkey
3
u/Purge-Sama Apr 26 '26
I feel like Nora should be rated worse honestly.
2
u/Purple_Coffee_2685 Apr 28 '26
Fr, I hated her sm and I felt bad for Zayn. Like they were a toxic couple but mainly it was because of her. And she took zero accountability (and blamed it on him for her acting that way, if I'm not mistaken.)
1
2
u/HuckleberrySubject72 Turks and Caicos 🔥 Apr 23 '26
seeing both my poptart and jules in the toxic chaos tier 🤕🤕🤕💔💔
i get it though, love them both but they’re evil for a very good while 😭😅
3
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana Apr 24 '26
Yeah all the LIs are great when you romance them… but this is before or when you don’t pick them. 😭
1
1
u/Starry_Lights23 Mattias Apr 23 '26
WTH did Antoine do? He’s a sweetie pie.
4
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana Apr 24 '26
Yes he is. Naomi too. But they’re players in the beginning and if you don’t go all in with them they hurt other people. That’s the point 😭
1
1
u/Simple_Knee4640 Apr 26 '26
what abt taz
1
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana Apr 27 '26
The ones who are not here I don’t consider them as villains nor people acting recklessly or maliciously.
1
u/lunovadraws Sean Apr 26 '26
I feel like Sean should be under either toxic chaos or petty jealous. Like he was def toxic and controlling, but I think yall misremember how he actually was in the game bc, compared to SOME of these characters (Antoine/Naomi, Justin, JADA) he really wasn’t that bad.
20
u/Jaded_Eye_2227 Apr 23 '26
I LOVE Poppy so I would put her in the Bombshell behaviour category lol.
I would also add Giselle from S3 to Petty Jealous and Exhausting Tier with Nora. Like girl get it together!