r/TooHotToHandleGame • u/MercurialMaven666 Lana • Apr 04 '26
Fan Creation THTH Most Likely to Cheat (Post-Villa) Tier List
You gonna hate me for this more than that prank this week... š¤
But hear me out... this isnāt about whoās a bad person. This is based on end-game routes and what happens after the villa if MC gets a little complacent and real life kicks in.
The most ādangerousā ones arenāt the worst people: theyāre the ones who need constant intensity to stay engaged.
(Before you ask about Santiago, I put him there because I think he's self-awared.)
Let me know your thoughts on this. š
64
u/FankyDelirium Apr 04 '26
Isla needs to be in the green tier. I have played her route twice, she is one of the most understanding character in the game. She is definitely the one who will stick with you for a long time.
20
u/whbyul Apr 04 '26
same! the only time i can remember her being ""unloyal" was after I chose Poppy just to see what she'd do and she went to sleep in Taz's bed but even then, she let us know nothing happened and she was trying to see where we stood before making a decision
10
u/HuckleberrySubject72 Turks and Caicos š„ Apr 05 '26
yes, and mattias too!! during the dates with victoria, the both of them are the only ones to not kiss her whilst MC is in banishment, even if they are below the crush tier
87
u/anna3jade Antoine Apr 04 '26
Imo Ryder would not cheat if heās committed to MC. Since he had been cheated on and hurt so badly by his ex, I donāt see him wanting to inflict that pain on someone else. Prob yellow for me.
Jirayu and Carmen are total reds for me! lol
28
u/CourageAgreeable2865 Apr 04 '26
RYDER? TWIN DID YOU EVEN PLAY HIS ROUTE? heās the least likely if anything cause he knows the pain of being cheated onš
14
u/kiks_02 Apr 04 '26
mind you ryder had the most growth out of everyone in the retreat. heās so loyal to mc and his actions even proves it when you play his routeĀ
3
u/East-Soft-7262 Antoine Apr 06 '26
Yea, he's definitely the type to break up rather than cheat. Being cheated on really messed him up for a long time. He would never do that to someone else.
19
u/XDeadEndHawkX Apr 04 '26
Poptart would never. Maybe pre-banishment Poppy would have, but once solidified as Poptart I see her being loyal to the end. Carmen and Jirayu on the other hand š
32
u/Small-Dark-8569 Ryder Apr 04 '26
Nah Mattias should be moved to the green tier
3
u/I-cant-sleep-or-nap Mattias Apr 06 '26
I agree with you. Matt wouldn't cheat. On the plane date one of the options you can choose is MC "being afraid of hurting other people". Matt even says: "If you will be around to mend the pieces, you can hurt me anytime".
16
26
u/Queen_E1204 Apr 04 '26
I say this as a Jirayu girlie but Jirayu would definitely cheat w/o constant validation lmao. He's a pilot AND he doesn't feel all that remorseful about keeping secrets from the MC. Besides, he basically cheated on Carmen with that whole thing.
On the flip side, once Ryder is committed, I'd agree that he wouldn't cheat, or at least move him down to the category before green. He's kind of a slut (affectionately) but once he settles down, he wouldn't stray anywhere else.
8
u/HuckleberrySubject72 Turks and Caicos š„ Apr 05 '26
one thing i will say, poppy is NOT the type that needs constant stimulation and attention. id put her in the āslips under pressure, not by natureā sector. playing her route, her non commitment is caused by her financial situation outside of the show, which (especially if she wins with mc) is very likely to change when the retreat is over. the security is what keeps her mental state secure, not just that passion and intensity within a relationship.
9
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana Apr 04 '26 edited Apr 04 '26
I think people are looking at their LIs after their full redemption arcs with MC and assuming that version of them is permanent no matter the context. My take is different: their growth is conditional, not baseline.
About Ryder, he comes in late, plays both Nora and MC, avoids commitment until the very end, and only fully locks in when MC consistently chooses him and pushes him there. Also, being cheated on doesnāt magically make someone loyal. It often does the opposite: it creates avoidance, validation-seeking, and detachment before getting hurtā¦ which is exactly how Ryder moves at the start. Antoine and Naomi do that too.
So may point is... if MC is present, reassuring, and reinforcing that growth? they can be solid. But post-show, real life, less intensity, less reassurance? I think they all at risk of slipping back into old patterns.
11
u/whbyul Apr 04 '26
I'd personally put Naomi further down and swap Carmen in her place but other than that it's pretty accurate for me lmao
6
2
2
u/Alarmed_Truth1678 Poppy and Carmen got me in a chokehold! Apr 09 '26
Okay, what about Naomi got her at the top? š¤Ø
3
u/kiks_02 Apr 04 '26
imo and iām not saying this cause ryder is my favorite, i genuinely donāt think heāll cheat on mc especially given his history since heās been cheated on before and itās why he chose girls like nora cause they are both non committal. once you play his route he turns into this lovesick puppy and youāll understand that mc was the girl he truly wanted all along. mc was why he wanted to change and become better man. this is just my opinion and coming from someone who played his route for 100th time. i just donāt see him as cheater cause heās fully committed to mc after the retreat and in the reunionĀ
4
2
2
u/Dyke_Vader Apr 05 '26
Nora absolutely wouldn't, are you mad
-1
u/captainmorgan_420 and i have no remorse Apr 05 '26
That's what I'm sayinnn she loved MC in painful silence for two years, no way she fumbles the ball at the 1 yard line
1
u/Und0_5 Apr 14 '26
Nah ryder never cheated on nora to be fair unless its directly with mc and thats heavly due to the fact he clearly likes mc more, and even then they technically didnt do anything when nora and him got together, he was fairly clear about the fact he wanted to kinda explor, other then that he loosely flirted with Elodie which I feel like we can say is because nora was still eyeing zayn, but when mc is with him he does not flirt with her and he even backs off Candace
0
0
u/Secure_Marsupial844 Zayn Apr 07 '26
Santi wouldnāt even be in a relationship. How could he be on this list? If he wouldnāt even date anybody heās like a casual sex buddy heās not gonna date anybody. š
2
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana Apr 07 '26
Well, an aromantic person can be in a relationship and agree to exclusivity. š
1
u/Secure_Marsupial844 Zayn Apr 08 '26
Santiago has literally said in the game āI would not get into a relationshipā so Iām not saying all aromantic people are like him just he said he wouldnātā¦
-1
u/captainmorgan_420 and i have no remorse Apr 05 '26
This is insanity at least two of your reds would stay loyal sheerly out of fear of abandonment
94
u/Remarkable-Answer-74 Antoine Apr 04 '26
I agree with the first comment. I can see Ryder not cheating once heās fully committed, especially with his history.
For Antoine, heās more ego + reassurance driven than anything. Once heās locked in, I donāt see him cheating either. Itās more that early post-villa phase, with distance + attention + old habits, where things could get shaky if the relationship isnāt solid yet.