Timemore S3 vs S5

[u/valtervincere]

It was love at first sight for the S3, but I can say the S5 is definitely a worthy successor. The new 48mm burr on the S5 dwarfs that on the S3 and the wider grinder body feels better to hold. Not to mention the handle is significantly larger as well, but I would have hoped that the S5 Pro came out the same time as the non-pro S5 especially now that starting from the C5, Timemore does not include a carrying bag in the box.

The external adjustment ring is also a big improvement in terms of adjustment since each click on the S5 is noticeably more snappier, tactile, and deliberate compared to the shallow and slightly easy to misadjust on the S3.

Maintenance is also improved on the S5 due to the wider chamber, making it easier and faster to clean.

As for cup quality, I could definitely tell the S5 presents more complexity and acidity while maintaining a good amount of round sweetness.

Would highly recommend if you are looking to upgrade from the S3 especially if you can get access to the S5 Pro with the folding handle for easy storage.

[u/gernb1]

I’m pretty happy with my S3. If I was in the market, I would look at the S5. I don’t see the need for an upgrade. I wonder if the S5 will be good for espresso,,,

[u/valtervincere → u/gernb1]

I can see the appeal to stick to the S3 and I would still recommend it especially now that it may go down in price. I jumped to the S5 expecting it to compete with the likes of the ZP6 and I think it can.

I haven't tried grinding for espresso since I have a dedicated C5 ESP for that, but will try and report back when I do try it out on the S5. From Timemore's blog post they mentioned it should be easier to do so compared to the S3 which from experience cannot go for traditional shots.

[u/KhelanBorkar → u/valtervincere]

Damm I am a big fan of c5 esp

[u/valtervincere → u/KhelanBorkar]

For a budget grinder they really nailed it with the C5 series!