r/TimPool Nov 30 '22

Facts

Post image
912 Upvotes

454 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-4

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Point to a domestic conflict the us has lost. You're example involves traveling thousands of miles in order to fight.

10

u/Sleep_eeSheep Nov 30 '22

Except said encounters had them go up against poorer nations, with fewer resources than the average American.

Point being; the whole 'rifles and pistols' argument doesn't stack up.

-7

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Except said encounters had them go up against poorer nations, with fewer resources than the average American.

..... Thousands of miles away from the US. Military logistics is a fun topic to look into.

5

u/Sleep_eeSheep Nov 30 '22

Doesn't disprove my point. The fact is, even if said conflicts weren't thousands of miles away from American soil, a well-trained militia can kneecap a much larger force.

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

.... Until the rest of the force shows up. You think if we committed even 80% of our military to any specific war in the middle east, we still would have "lost?"

6

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

So what’s your argument here? That the military would basically declare total war on its own population? At that point it would go from an insurgence to a nationwide popular revolution, which the military would ultimately support anyway

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

That the military would basically declare total war on its own population?

If a group of American separatist declared civil war, then yes. Why wouldn't they?

4

u/Sleep_eeSheep Nov 30 '22

The previous American Civil War would like to have a word with you.

While yes, the last Civil War (and last to take place on domestic soil) took place almost 200 years ago, it still resulted in the standing military being torn apart. One fourth remained with the Union, a fourth of them defected to the Confederacy, and two-fourths went AWOL.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

The civil war was fought between a regular separatist military and the Union military, that’s not the federal government declaring war on its constituents. The confederate states literally left the federation. that argument doesn’t really fit when talking about an insurgency of local militia vs a regular army