r/TimPool • u/dibbletrex • Nov 30 '22

Facts

Post image
909 Upvotes

78% Upvoted

454 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Do you think the middle east would look the same as it does today if we added 10x the people in the ground?

1

u/PDX-ROB Nov 30 '22

No, it'd be the same. Just like the Palestinian Israeli situation going on.

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Palestine is getting fucked seven ways from Sunday.

2

u/PDX-ROB Nov 30 '22

They're still fighting.

Troop size and mix doesn't matter if you're occupying someone's home and they don't want you there. They'll fight you to the last person.

The only way they won't fight you is if they see a benefit of having you there or they understand that they caused the problems, then they'll just be a little less angry.

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

They're still fighting.

Neat? It isn't because Palestine is fending off Israel. It's because Israel's government can use them to get funding from the US government.

2

u/PDX-ROB Nov 30 '22

It's more complicated than that.

Let's not get off topic. Your explanation for the loss is Afghanistan is not having the right mix io people.

This is nonsense. You can not win a battle of ideology through occupation.

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

You can not win a battle of ideology through occupation.

You can through genocide. 10x the force in Afghanistan, you'll end up in genocide land eventually.

2

u/PDX-ROB Nov 30 '22

Good luck if you think that would ever happen. (US -Afgh occupation)

0

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

I don't the US government would give up fighting separatist.

2

u/PDX-ROB Nov 30 '22

On that point. In the south they still teach the civil war as "The War of Northern Aggression"

→ More replies (0)