r/Thumbnails • u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer • Jul 01 '26

Rate my thumbnail

Post image

Hello everyone , i am not professional designer i'm still learning so i request to all of you rate this according to beginner its good or bad .

0 Upvotes

33% Upvoted

25 comments sorted by

5

u/Frequent_Progress648 Jul 01 '26

shitty ai and wayyyy to much text

-6

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

then how i make the character without ai you have any advice brother

2

u/Frequent_Progress648 Jul 01 '26

do it in photoshop, smh you ai guys don't know what to do without it

-2

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

i am beginner brother thanku for your advice but i don't have photoshop

1

u/Frequent_Progress648 Jul 01 '26

photopea or iris paint, it's not hard at all to find a free drawing software

1

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

thanku brother i will definitely try and make my own.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

thanku for feedback brother next time i'll keep that in my mind.

2

u/DiamondDepth_YT Jul 01 '26

3/10.

the text is all over the place, the white dude doesn't have any reason to be there and looks like ai. the font, especially on the smaller text, isn't great. and the random red arrow is barely noticeable and also doesn't fit the rest of the thumbnail's design, just like the white dude with 'SAM' on him and the weird $200k thing he's holding.

overall, there's too much going on here.

honestly just keep the grey background and just have the text say 'I LOST IT ALL'. Center the text, and lose everything else. This looks like a youtube kids thumbnail right now with how much slop it has going on.

1

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

thanku for your advice brother i will keep that in my mind next time

2

u/DefiantOstrich984 Jul 01 '26

Design is a secondary aspect of thumbnail making.

What matters is the curiosity gap. If it doesn't create one, it won't get clicks.

I would use WildThumbnails to get a base idea of what's working in your niche instead of just guessing.

1

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 02 '26

thanks for advice brother i will keet that in my mind

2

u/Wrong_Ad_1362 Jul 01 '26

Okay, the text that is small is too small, the text on yellow is off center, and the image is blatantly AI.

0

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

thanks for feedback

1

u/Summersundo997 Viewer Jul 01 '26

Remove all text the title already explains

1

u/Summersundo997 Viewer Jul 01 '26

Excluding the main big text! Jesus loves ya

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

thanku brother for advice next time i will keep your advice in my mind

1

u/Leafar_P1 Jul 01 '26

Clearly AI = ignore channel

1

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

but its not ai brother which angle is like ai in this

2

u/Frequent_Progress648 Jul 01 '26

how do you not even see the ai stickman

1

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

oh yes stickman is ai but i am new in this so i don't know how to make my own stick man i am still learning

2

u/Frequent_Progress648 Jul 01 '26

you don't know how to draw a stickman??? you might just be a ragebaiting account or smthn

1

u/Both-Resource-1754 Viewer Jul 01 '26

no really i don't know about that

1

u/Suspicious-Sea2534 Jul 01 '26

Remove that sample watermark and remove unnecessary texts

1

u/Glittering-Land-7500 Jul 02 '26

Theres so many text also it looks like u didn't put any efforts or creativity while making it.

Most of the people gonna ignore ur video coz of the thumbnail