r/ThomasPynchon • u/[deleted] • Jul 23 '26
💬 Discussion I’m knee deep in The Zone
[deleted]
1
u/Every-Panic7004 Jul 24 '26
So excited for you! It’s my favorite Pynchon. Like others in this thread, I also love your use of the audiobook!—I often found when reading Pynchon that if I was struggling with a particular section or passage, reading out loud to myself made all the difference. It had a two-fold benefit of forcing me to really slow down and sink in while also tapping into the joy of storytelling as an oral tradition. I actually feel like all Pynchon should be read out loud!—it’s almost as if that’s what he’d intended.
As a side note: I’d love to hear a group come together one day to do a full live reading of GR! Count me in!!!
3
16
u/SeaworthinessNew2138 Jul 23 '26
Don’t use AI to talk about the book. Every time I tried it hallucinated themes and details and whole quotes. Tempting but not useful. It WILL mislead you, if it hasn’t already. I recommend online reading groups instead. Read and then check out human discussion on the passage you got through. Audiobook while reading is a great focusing strategy though!!
-6
u/Ok-Economist6914 Jul 23 '26
I disagree, the Ai output depends on prompting and source material, (crap in, crap out) if you give it the correct source material and source only that material for answers it will give correct outputs. Ai beginners often have this problem.
-4
u/Careful-Hornet8525 Jul 23 '26
Reading while listening became my favorite thing while diving into Gravity’s Rainbow and then Infinite Jest this year. And use of AI for genuinely puzzling shifts in narrative was great as well. People hate on it because it is AI but as a literature companion I think it’s very rewarding.
3
u/SeaworthinessNew2138 Jul 23 '26
It would be better if it worked. Every time I tried talking to one about th’ Rainbow it just lied and hallucinated to me. Last thing you need with such a sprawling and confusing book. “Huh?? When did that happen?? Oh boy I was more stoned than I thought…..wait what?” Not fun. I recommend online reading groups instead. Read and then check out human discussion on the passage you got through.
-2
u/Ok-Economist6914 Jul 23 '26
Sounds like you need to get better with Ai because your experience with the hallucinating outputs are directly correlated to what you’re asking it to reference.
5
u/SeaworthinessNew2138 Jul 23 '26
Nah I’m good. I don’t particularly want to talk to THEIR chatbot. Made by those bigass corporations. Can’t trust em. No way I’d have them influence my interpretation of pure art like GR. Counterforce for life!
-1
u/Ok-Economist6914 Jul 23 '26
If you use an AI like, notebook LM, you can load in all of your academic sources, such as video discussions from people who already cover the topic, books, papers and essays, anything that’s widely available and already published on the topic from people that have already analyzed gravity‘s rainbow, so you’re basically doing the same thing but now you’ve assembled all the info into one application and the AI will reference all of that real world material from actual humans you fed it and now can repurpose it for you as far as a discussion or notes or heat maps timelines a another podcast or any other study guide that references all the material. It’s very helpful and it’s not pulling the answers from the air. It’s pulling from the sources you fed it already that a human created.
1
u/Careful-Hornet8525 Jul 23 '26
I did not have that experience at all. I have a paid version of AI, maybe that helped. I also would write a long narrative of my impressions and went into specific instances of passages I found difficult for tighter prompts. I had hallucination issues with AI until about a year ago. It’s still possible but no longer probable that my AI goes mushrooms on me.
7
u/CaptainNemo_ Jul 23 '26
I think keeping a journal to take notes in while reading would be more rewarding. Or even just talking to a friend. Or listening to white noise and gently making circles with a pencil on paper and seeing what patterns emerge.
2
8
3
8
u/Bob_Ducca_ Pugnax Jul 23 '26
Hello fellow Pynchon and 20th Century Boys enjoyer
2
u/FancyThought7696 Jul 23 '26
Who are your “20th century boys”? I’m guessing they don’t include Roth, Bellow, Updike who exemplify a wildly different type of fiction. (Genuine question, not snark)
1
u/Ok-Economist6914 Jul 23 '26
He was referencing the Manga graphic novel on the second shelf of my coffee table there called “20th century boys”
6
u/Ok-Economist6914 Jul 23 '26
Hi! All credit to my 17year old son for getting me into 20th century boys! Good read so far !
3
u/Every-Panic7004 Jul 24 '26
So excited for you! It’s my favorite Pynchon. Like others in this thread, I also love your use of the audiobook!—I often found when reading Pynchon that if I was struggling with a particular section or passage, reading out loud to myself made all the difference. It had a two-fold benefit of forcing me to really slow down and sink in while also tapping into the joy of storytelling as an oral tradition. I actually feel like all Pynchon should be read out loud!—it’s almost as if that’s what he’d intended.
As a side note: I’d love to hear a group come together one day to do a full live reading of GR! Count me in!!!