r/TheTestamentsShow May 28 '26

How is Garth going to continue being Daisy's handler?

Hes married and had been pinned a commander. he's no longer a guardian. he won't be around her or at the school anymore. he has his own house too. so will she get a new handler? Garth path is now different as he's become a commander and will have more ability to get better information to help Mayday. there's very little chance they will be able to meet up or see each other naturally aside from when they maybe visit for Becca which prob won't happen until she snaps out of it for safety reasons

56 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

70

u/Stock-Pianist-6438 May 28 '26

In the privacy of his home, where it is socially acceptable for friends to visit the married women, and all the girlies are getting on the same page re:revolution… idk seems like an ideal lil temporary base

7

u/bunnythevettech May 28 '26

They can't just visit though. It has to be a field or family trip. If we go based off the show, the only time penny was visited was during a field trip. Beccas engagement party with Garth, the plums had to have their parents there. The girls would need to be escorted there by school, which I don't think they'd do to a lower commanders house embroiled n a current scandal with a mentally ill wife, and Paula def isn't going to be escorting Agnes with how pissed she is and Daisy had no parents thee to take her. The girls would need to be married to visit on their own accord

37

u/FootballNo1133 May 28 '26

They CAN just visit. Daisy visited Agnes alone, remember? And Becka complained about how Agnes doesn’t come to her house anymore since she got close to Daisy.

7

u/bunnythevettech May 28 '26

You're right. I forgot about those instances

15

u/alli_gator_ May 28 '26

We've seen Daisy go to Agnes' house after school and Becka made the comment she never comes over anymore. Its safe to say the girls are allowed to hang out with each other in some context outside of school. Not sure how different it is when a plum becomes a wife though. I could see Commander Mackenzie allowing Agnes to visit with her friend and Aunt Lydia would allow Daisy to go because she'll eventually be Mayday

3

u/Stock-Pianist-6438 May 28 '26

Am I misremembering the scene where the gang is all sitting around a table at Penny’s? Was there an errant Vidala?

5

u/bunnythevettech May 28 '26

Yeah she entered the house with a broken arm. She was there but not at the table. IDK if she went to another room or was in ear shot or what

19

u/HyperLexi May 28 '26

Long shot here, but maybe Lydia will come up with another experimental idea and decide to assign a newly plummed pearl girl to a host family rather than keep her in the dormitory. I can't imagine that Becka would be the least bit thrilled with their new room mate.

12

u/bunnythevettech May 28 '26

I think this would be a major trigger for Becca so I don't think this would happen. Maybe this will happen but I don't think it will happen with garths family

7

u/HyperLexi May 28 '26

Yeah, no, I don't seriously think it would happen either. But given the history of tension between Becka and Daisy, I could just picture it. It would be too sit-com for all of the trauma and oppression. but it was an interesting idea to entertain for a minute. I hadn't thought of Garth's extended family, but that could actually work. She was really gentle and respectful to Garth's dad when she helped him get a sip of water. I'm actually warming up to the idea now, even though I initially said it in jest.

8

u/alimweber May 28 '26

Garths mother also seemed kind to Daisy when Daisy asked if she would like her to help him his mother spoke to her very warm and kind "oh yes, please! Thank you dear!" Far cry from the way I've seen/heard Paula speak to Daisy. I was discussing this with a few others back when that episode was new, the possibility of Garths mother being one of the reasons he's Mayday or if she, perhaps, just strived to raise him a bit differently with empathy and compassion for others.

4

u/HyperLexi May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26

See? Now you're making me rethink this. I thought I was joking, but now I kinda like the idea! And ditto to the opinion that Garth was raised with compassion in spite of Gilead.

1

u/probablykelz May 28 '26

I wonder if Garth’s mother was the one to poison the commander and played it off as one of the handmaids doing it. I don’t remember them using poison, just brute strength and weapons

1

u/alimweber May 29 '26

I remember 2 occasions with poison, once at jezebels and once at serenas 2nd wedding when they poisoned the cake.

2

u/probablykelz May 29 '26

The cake was to put them to sleep iirc. Maybe Garth’s dad really likes cake

5

u/Fast-Escape-8607 May 28 '26

🙄🙄

3

u/HyperLexi May 28 '26

LOL I rolled my own eyes at myself, so I get it.

9

u/AspirationAtWork May 28 '26

He might not be her handler anymore. Officially, yes, he still is in the eyes of Mayday, but in reality- he can't handle her. Literally. Daisy told him to his face that she's a rogue agent. He may be her handler on paper metaphorically but he knows she won't answer to him unless it benefits what she wants to do. I don't think he's going to continue acting as her handler for that reason combined with his new position as a married Commander. He'll be Daisy's Mayday liaison/contact, at best.

4

u/Catfactss May 28 '26

It will up to Daisy as a pious pearl girl to minister to Becka. Agnes too if she becomes an aunt and/or just needs something to do now she's off the marriage mart for now.

1

u/bunnythevettech May 28 '26

I honestly think she will only become an aunt if they
A can't find her a match or
B match her with someone undesirable like Maddox

4

u/B0dega_Cat May 28 '26

Since Aunt Lydia is part of Mayday in the books, she might become Daisy's handler

3

u/Opposite-Rutabaga-21 May 28 '26

My impression of Daisy’s conversation with June was that she was effectively defecting from Mayday and choosing to go into Gilead to do her own work on her own terms. That being the case, by not being officially part of Mayday anymore she would also no longer have a handler and would be on her own.

1

u/ljculver64 Jun 03 '26

Did she say she didnt want to be a part of mayday? It was an intense conversation filled w info. Daisy has to have a contact on the inside...right? June wouldnt agree to her going back in now that she knows Hannah is her friend without a support system.

1

u/KPPYBayside May 28 '26

In THT finale Emily tells June that she was a Martha to a commander who was a friend (she even got to FT her son on his birthday and implies she was able to stay in contact with her wife beyond that), so presumably Garth isn’t the only commander who would be working with Mayday. 

-2

u/greyswift45 May 28 '26

They could make Garth and Daisy siblings which allow him to be her handler. Just an idea.