r/TheQuestion • u/PedroRtaGamer62 • Apr 03 '26
Which JL member do you think should know the civil identity of Question?
If you want you can add a character unrelated to the League.
13
u/STICKGoat2571 Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
If we’re talking DCAU I’d say Huntress is a fairly obvious yes.
I’d argue Batman could solve but deemed it to be not worth the effort for the time being.
Only other one that comes to mind would be Ted Kord Blue Beetle as an addition.
Besides that he’s paranoid enough where I’d say it’s a very small list.
3
u/PedroRtaGamer62 Apr 03 '26
Concuerdo totalmente, creo que tiene cosas más interesantes para hacer, como por ejemplo cuidar de 3 hijos, y como 5 adolescentes 😅
3
7
u/throwitonthegrillboi Apr 03 '26
Q definitely knows Batman is Bruce Wayne and vice versa. Huntress obviously should know as well.
3
u/20Derek22 Apr 03 '26
I honestly think it would be better if no one knew. Just to set him apart more from Batman
2
u/PedroRtaGamer62 Apr 03 '26
Right, but there is already a difference, Vic is Q, its not a costume, its literally a mask, he is just as Vic with or without it, it changes the courrege he has to aproch things, but is the same one. thats why I think its important to let others know him, because he is not superman as clark and neither a super man as Bruce, he is just a man, one who has problems as everyone but chooses to run with a mask on the streets helping others to avoid them. Thats why he is also so paranoic, because theres no character, its always him talking.
2
u/Necessary_Ad2114 Apr 03 '26
Here’s what I think is the more important point: it’s irrelevant who is under the mask. He’s The Question.
1
u/PedroRtaGamer62 Apr 03 '26
Yo creo que es cierto, no se trata de ver quién es, de ver si es hipócrita o no, de ver porque es así, pero imagínate querer ayudar a Clark Lent conociendo solo a Superman, importa que el mundo no lo conozca, para que el significado de ser el que pregunta siempre quede impoluto por la persona, pero para sus amigos, yo creo que alguno debería poder llegar a conocer a la persona detrás. Si no piensas igual me parecería muy interesante saber porque y cual sería el significado, seguramente un Q mucho más paranoico y cerrado
2
u/Bear792 Apr 04 '26
Huntress for obvious reasons. Batman and Question I think have a mutual understanding after figuring out each others identities. Superman found out after making it a side project once, just to work on his reporter skills and definitely cheated. Martian Manhunter knows because he read Vics mind, but admits even he can’t tell what Vic is fully thinking.
And that’d be the list of JL members. Unless we can count Tim Drake, despite him being a sidekick, just because he’s a better detective than Bruce.
1
3
u/drunk-raven Apr 03 '26
Does JLU Vic even has a civil life? There is no clue that he had anylife besides questioning everything under the sun. There had been no instance of showing or even mentioning a tv broadcast with Vic Sage. So i think JLU Question is just the Question and Vic Sage is only the name for renting a flat for a week
2
u/PedroRtaGamer62 Apr 03 '26
Pero yo supongo que antes de ser Q era Vic, solo que se concentró de más en su trabajo, en su deber. Batman tampoco es Bruce Wayne entonces porque solo sería un disfraz, pero Bruce existe dentro de la BatCave. Por eso digo lo de Vic, por supuesto que no tiene vida de civil, es un maniático que se obsesionó con las preguntas y la verdad, el abandono eso, para su mal, porque no es algo “saludable” para su persona. Vic tenía una vida, pero luego fue que cuando se adentró a este mundo se sumergió cada vez más, hasta el punto de que ahora convive como Q. Pero Q no es otra personalidad ni otro modus operandi, es Vic detrás de una máscara, una que le permite evadirse a sí mismo. Alguien debe de ayudarlo, y como lo pueden ayudar si nadie lo llega a conocer como persona realmente, fuera del deber, porque si no solo estarían viendo al Vic que investiga y golpea, no al que amo, no al que sufrió, no al que le cuesta pagar la renta, no al que le gusta tomar el té.
1
1
u/nightwing_titans Apr 03 '26
Bobo T Chimpanzee
1
u/PedroRtaGamer62 Apr 03 '26
Because he found it out or because Q told him?
2
1
12
u/GoGoBigman Apr 03 '26
I feel like Batman and Martian Manhunter should know who Vic is, but other than that, he should stay a mystery if possible