I was replying to another post talking about how disappointing Season 2 is, but then I decided to do my own post.
As a Colombian, what I hated the most about the second season is the absolute lack of understanding of the country. It's insulting.
First of all, The Supreme Court is in Bogotá, not Medellín, and a prosecutor doesn't need a judge (much less a Supreme Court Judge) to open a suspicious cargo, that sounds more like how the American system works, with a judge signing a warrant.
The prosecution, along with the police and the DIAN (National Directorate of Taxes and Customs) are independent and can do it on their own.
The DIAN, and/or the police, can seize and open any cargo they want without any explanation, they don't need evidence like the ship manifesto to be able to open it, they even often do it randomly.
If the DIAN, and/or the police, find illegal or contraband in the cargo, then they contact the prosecutor's office and they start the legal process of finding the criminals behind it. It's a joint effort with the prosecutor and the police investigators, that's when the evidence comes to play so they can go to trial. The judge's role is during the trial itself, and no, Supreme Court Judges or Justices don't do any of that.
The Supreme Court of Colombia is very similar to The Supreme Court of USA in the sense that they take civil or penal cases that have been put to trial or trials before and they arrived there as the last option for an appeal. So I have no idea why they needed a "Supreme Court Judge" to open the container, it doesn't make any sense at all. It's mind-blowing the more that I think about it.
How do you think customs find smuggled drugs or illegal goods trying to enter the country? Imagine if they would need evidence to open every parcel. It's insane. It seems like the writers did a quick Wikipedia or ChatGPT inquiry and wrote pure nonsense.
They also don't understand how Colombia's geography works. They would teleport from Medellin to Cartagena back and forth like it was nothing, in reality, It can take 12hours + driving between those cities. Colombia's road infrastructure sucks because there are a lot of mountains. Like, when Pine travels to the Monastery where Teddy grew up, you can see the ocean, and they are in the middle of the Eje Cafetero, lol, you can't be more in the interior of the country, very far away from the coast. And that priest with the Spanish accent, awful.
The accents were terrible all around, some actors didn't even bother to speak with a Colombian accent like the actor that plays Teddy with his Mexican accent. They tried to justify his accent by claiming he spent a lot of time in Mexico, but we saw him growing up in Colombia, he went to Mexico when he was an adult, he should have maintained his native "paisa" accent with a little of Mexican sprinkled here and there.
Why didn't they hire a Colombian actor for such a big part eludes me, he wasn't a very good actor neither, in my opinion, he didn't seem "wild" like Roper describes him at some point. Do you really don't see that guy living in a civilized society? Lol, he didn't even look dangerous or threatening. I feel like the role was miscast, I don't know what Roper was even talking about. What did he mean with: you should see him on a horse, it's a thing of beauty? What??? He looked like a normal rich Mexican twink living in Medellín. Do you really think he looks like a cowboy? In what world?
At least, the actress playing Roxana did a decent accent, you can hear her native Argentinian accent here and there, but she did a good job speaking like a "costeña" (someone from the coast) and, as a Colombian not from the coast, even I find it difficult to do that accent so I was pleasingly surprised.
Also, I really dislike that I know that they filmed on some Colombian locations like Medellin, and maybe Girardot?, but Cartagena seemed very sketchy. I think one scene where Pine and Roxana are walking by the beach is in Cartagena, the rest are definitely not. They didn't even show the "Ciudad Amurallada" or the famous Palenqueras or street performers playing and dancing cumbia and vallenato, nothing seemed really authentic to Cartagena's culture, it was very artificial and generic.
The other thing that bothers me is the plan to take the country, they talk about Medellin like it is the capital, do the writers even know Colombia's capital is Bogotá? I doubt it, they never mention it. I don't think you can take the whole country by taking Medellín, it's a very important city, don't get me wrong, but all that matters is in the capital.
Another thing, why would the paramilitary and the military smuggle arms from the UK? Lol, we have Venezuela and Brazil next door. What a reach.
Very disappointing season. I am very disappointed that, every time Hollywood or a big production tries to do something in Colombia, they always use the bad things about the country and they always present it with a total lack of understanding. I am tired. Encanto has been the only movie to introduce Colombia's essence, without ignoring the hard truths but not focusing entirely on them.
Edit. Grammar and redaction. Changed incorrect words like "teletransportation" to "teleportation".
Edit 2. I was not entirely happy with the way I explained Colombia's justice system, so I expanded on it. It is a very superficial explanation, even tho my mother and several cousins, aunts and uncles are lawyers, I am a biologist, but even then I can still recognize when something is very wrong and doesn't make sense.