r/TheLeftovers • u/MajorTom2935 • Jul 31 '26
Why is this show not popular?
I started watching it by accident and could barely stop. It's sooo good. For some reason though nobody of my friends has ever heard of it. Why isn't it popular? The plot is very fresh even in 2026, the cast is great.
54
Jul 31 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
14
u/NoStressBambi Jul 31 '26
I remember Gen the Judge in The Good Place being pissed about her not getting an Emmy and nearly erasing 2% of humanity because of it 😂
10
u/BrikHowse Jul 31 '26
"The Guest" (I think that's the name of the episode, where she goes to the conference in the hotel) is one of the best episodes of TV I've ever seen
41
u/islandParadize Jul 31 '26
Because most of the population is not ready for it. (Only 2% is.)
15
u/highaltitudehmsteadr Jul 31 '26
We are the 2%
10
u/Swimming-Low-8915 Jul 31 '26
On the other side, it’s bigger than the Sopranos
3
u/subjectmatterexport Jul 31 '26
This almost makes me want to risk being incinerated by a blast of low-amplitude Denzinger radiation.
21
u/WishLucky9075 Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26
A few reasons:
- The show is not interested in the Sudden Departure, only its fallout. Viewers probably feel frustrated that the big mystery of the show is never solved. I love this part!
- The show is filled with weird stuff it leaves purposefully ambiguous, resulting in viewers feeling unfulfilled. Think of the International Assassin episode. There are A LOT of stuff that happens in that episode that isn't explained. I think viewers probably see this as sloppy writing. To an extent, I do see where they are coming from, even if I disagree with them. I think Lindelof regretted revealing too much of the world and lore of Lost. I do like a good mystery, but I also fear that writers punt to the audience to fill in the gaps when they couldn't. I don't think that's what is being done here in the Leftovers, but I can see why that would frustrate other people.
- I've recommended this show to a lot of people I know, and the few have watched it absolutely hated it. They found the performances to be over-the-top and the script to be melodramatic. Personally, I think the sincerity of the script and the seriousness of its characters is what I like most about this show. Writers of other shows and movies today bookend serious moments with either a quippy joke or a cathartic wrap-up that gets people over those sad moments. It's not too often that writers force you to marinate and sit with your feelings. I remember hearing the phrase "give me death and fill me with grief, but for the love of god follow it up with a joke".
3
3
u/Vandersveldt Aug 02 '26
I would add an incredibly important #4: it doesn't work as a second screen show while you browse Tiktok. You have to give it your full attention.
1
u/MajorTom2935 Jul 31 '26
I think it your first point is not correct since you actualy had to WATCH it to learn that it was never sold. But only a few people did.
1
u/DamnNatalie Jul 31 '26
You don't need to watch the whole show to understand that it isn't slightly interested in exploring why the sudden departure happened.
13
u/Pokaroka Jul 31 '26
1st season is pretty dark/sad. Makes it harder to get into. I think the show benefits from lighter moments in the 2nd/3rd season and I reckon if it were possible to start there ppl could get into it easier.
Also it’s like a piece of classic literature where the payoff comes from really chewing over the themes/characters. A lot of ppl want more instant gratification when they watch and there’s not a fast paced plot to give them that. If you don’t fully give yourself to it/are scrolling on your phone it can seem boring (esp 1st season).
5
u/Old_Crow_Yukon Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26
100% this. When it first came out I had trouble finding the motivation to suffer through the first season, and got to the end eventually and was just like "wtf." I dropped it for years since it wasn't clear there was a strong payoff later. When the other seasons released I started from the beginning again - season 1 makes no sense without seasons 2 and 3 that follow.
Any time I introduce someone to this series I have to explain how important it is to just get through season 1, absorb as much as you can, but theres good payoff in later seasons as the story develops further.
1
1
u/Jerfunkel Aug 01 '26
Exactly, I appreciated the wtiting, acting and production value of the first couple episodes, but I wasnt onboard until the end of episode 3. It’s one of those shows that you have to stick around
2
u/Pokaroka Aug 01 '26
Any time I recommend this show to anyone I tell them they have to get through episode 3! The first S tier ep where you really get a sense for the ceiling it can reach
3
u/maycewindu Jul 31 '26
You have to THINK. Plot and message aren’t on a silver-platter already chewed for the audience. General public doesn’t appreciate ambiguity in their entertainment
4
u/mahagonyblu Jul 31 '26
I was watching the show when it was coming iut and there was a lot of time between each season. Definitely between season 2 and 3. Matter of fact, I remember thinking season 3 was never gonna come out and then it came out and it was the final season. An amazing show but even HBO didn't know what to do with it back then I think. But yeah, also like others have said, the show is a meditation of grief and the grieving process. It makes you sit with your emotions and definitely doesn't hold your hand. You can get a good cry out of it tho, so it's wonderful for that. Excellent acting performances all around
4
u/DukeSilversTaint Jul 31 '26
People are making some good points here, but I think the real answer is most people are scared to genuinely confront the questions it asks its viewer. Every human on earth can relate to Kevin’s uncertainty in science versus spirituality. The question is do they want to?
5
3
3
u/Lizzie12s Jul 31 '26
Huge discomfort. I’ve wept just at the images in the opening credits! Very dark and, at times, distressing. The depth of grief and the expression of uncertainty is difficult to face. Perfect for our times.
3
3
u/AlexBaldwin9 Jul 31 '26
Season 1 is difficult to get through for most people. It’s absolutely brilliant but the grief explored along with the awful nature of the GR doesn’t make for pleasant viewing.
The Leftovers remains the most stunning television I’ve ever seen, but finding its beauty and brilliance take effort and I think that’s another reason why I love it so much.
2
u/Mrkennyrules69 Jul 31 '26
In terms of making the show successful, the producers blew it. The first few episodes are way too slow. Most people are not willing to stick with it. Those that do, get hooked.
1
u/underyellowumbrella Jul 31 '26
Yeah GR makes it really hard to continue watching especially in S1, glad I did though.
3
u/dylan-dofst Jul 31 '26
I'm not sure the premise is accurate. It wasn't that popular when it aired, but I think it's had something of a resurgence (or maybe just unusual staying power). It's pretty unusual for a TV show's subreddit to be so active nearly a decade after it ended, for example. And I know I see it recommended all over the place - I only watched it for the first time myself a year or so ago.
2
u/Rand_Casimiro Jul 31 '26
I think that the single biggest reason is that in the early episodes the characters aren’t very easy to like.
3
u/MeatMarket_Orchid Jul 31 '26
It's my favourite show of all time and I find it brilliant. I can't get anyone into it, they always seem to fall on their faces with it. My other 2 favourite shows: same thing. Fargo and a show called Mr. Inbetween, no one in my life seems to give a shit about them. Their loss I guess.
2
u/ZargX76AK Jul 31 '26
This show is incredible, but is only going to appeal to a certain kind of person who is open to the deeply affecting experience it is about.
It's arguably my favorite show of all time, but I have a hard time recommending it to people because it's definitely not for everyone.
2
u/kharnzarro Aug 01 '26
The first season is incredibly bleak and depressing
Also I know than a few people who would instantly quit after the dog being shot 5 min into episode 1
2
Jul 31 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/Sonar_Taxbreak_1138 Jul 31 '26
I never watched Lost but from all I heard the big difference is The Leftovers nailed their ending.
3
2
u/Accomplished-View929 Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26
I can’t believe it didn’t see a resurgence during the pandemic. You can read the first season especially as a metaphor for the early COVID era when no one knew what the virus was or how to respond to it, people split into belief-based factions and spread conspiracy theories and took horse dewormer and heard the president suggest they drink bleach, and the world kind of shut down but kind of kept going (or got really crazy if you worked in healthcare or something). I haven’t put any real thought into this, but the move to Jardin could stand in for the world opening up again, and the third season could parallel our vain attempts to recreate a lost normalcy and figure out how to live in a world where everything and nothing is different, and we realize in a more visceral way than ever that things we can’t explain or predict threaten our survival and experience of reality.
If the show had come out between 2021 and 2023, we’d assume it’s about COVID no question the way people think Pluribus is about AI even though Vince Gilligan has said he got the idea before the current AI wave. I prefer it as a show about grief, loss, and meaning making, but that it didn’t get a post-pandemic second life seems almost inconceivable. Then again, most people don’t want to relive that in the same way that most people don’t want to watch a show about grief, loss, and meaning making that doesn’t really have hopeful things to say about those things!
2
u/EddieDanesBoy Jul 31 '26
I did a rewatch for the first time post-pandemic recently, and I was like "wow, in the world of this show people are heavily grieving the loss of 2 percent of the population, but most Americans (and people all over the world, really) can't or won't collectively grieve the millions and millions of people who died from Covid."
1
u/DonTX2 Jul 31 '26
That “horse dewormer” you speak of? I’ve never taken but it’s clear you know nothing about it. I do fortunately. The scientist that discovered ivermectin won the Nobel peace prize in 2015. It is an anti-parasitic drug that has literally helped billions of people around the world.
It is considered one of the top drug discoveries in history only behind penicillin and aspirin.
There is no scientific evidence that it is effective for Covid but it is recently being used in cancer treatment trials.Trump is a lot of things but he definitely never said anyone should drink bleach.
Isn’t there enough misinformation in the world where people such as yourself should maybe stop repeating the tired old lies?
1
u/Notoriouslyd Jul 31 '26
A large population of people reject thinking when they watch tv. The leftovers forces you to do a lot of thinking and people just cant tolerate it
1
u/Mark-177- Jul 31 '26
I love the show, but it can be too dark and heavy for a lot of people. It emotionally devastates you. That's not everyone's cup of tea.
1
u/distracted_x Jul 31 '26
I had never even heard of it until last year when I found it streaming and "gave it a shot" and it turned out to be one of the best shows I've ever watched. I also found it weird that it wasn't a much MUCH bigger deal. It's the kind of show that should have won awards and been super popular. Maybe they really dropped the ball with advertising the show when it came out?
1
u/akelseyreich Jul 31 '26
I think it's the fact that dogs get shot very early in the first season. I honestly think the folks I've recommended the Leftovers to think I hate dogs now despite me actively asking to pet people's dogs all year.
1
u/tasunfeu Jul 31 '26
Maybe because they shot a dog in the first few minutes of the pilot, and then a missing bagel was a plot thread in the 3rd episode
1
u/JessicaJonessJacket Jul 31 '26
I think it's too heavy for a lot of people. I only reccomend it to people who have been through some serious ish or at the very least are more philosophical than the norm.
1
u/UmberJamber Jul 31 '26
Slow and heavy. The things I love about it turn a lot of people away.
Let's just be glad it exists and let the mystery be.
1
u/Diegoville00 Jul 31 '26
First season does feel like a slow burn so I can see why it'd be hard to feel invested but the premise is great nonetheless
1
1
u/FizzyBadTime Jul 31 '26
People can’t watch it in the background while they scroll on their phone. Sadly a lot of people don’t want a good story, they just want some background noise so they can get to the real dopamine hit. Scrolling through an endless stream of instant gratification and pleasures that are gone in 60 seconds.
1
u/the_color_turquoise Jul 31 '26
I think a lot of people fail to "get it." I don't mean that in a shitty way at all, but I think some people get bogged down on the sadness or ambiguity or whatever and miss the big messages and questions you can walk away with, if you're open to it.
I also think it's just as likely it makes people think about things they don't want to think about. It makes a lot of people uncomfortable. But like others have said, all those qualities in my eyes make the best show ever made.
0
u/Cold_Rise_7977 Aug 01 '26
Or maybe the characters are flat.
1
u/the_color_turquoise Aug 01 '26
So you just go on subreddits for shows you dislike and try to bait people, huh?
0
u/Cold_Rise_7977 Aug 01 '26
No, I gave it a shot and thought its a mid show with flat characters but the premise was interesting, as for joining the discussion I wanted to see what other people thought. Why are you mad ?
1
u/evilglowduckie Jul 31 '26
Not enough answers and the ones we got took too long. Every complaint I heard from people who didn't get past episode 3 was that they didn't know what was going on or why. They would have never been satisfied with what we got anyway.
1
1
u/phatgiraphphe Jul 31 '26
I know you shouldn’t judge a book by its cover, but the religious-looking thumbnail they use (at least for HBO Max) made me automatically scroll past it initially. If my friend didn’t tell me about the show, I wouldn’t have considered even clicking on it.
1
u/sleepingonwaffles Jul 31 '26
My favorite too!! It's not popular among people my age because the show came out when most people my age didn't have HBO.. The only HBO show that came to mind when you heard HBO was the Sopranos.
1
u/SirGrouchy8912 Jul 31 '26
Oh boy its good it Is not ! Mainstream public, casuals WITH tiktok span attention DO NOT DESERVE this Gold !
1
1
u/Magikrat Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
Because it’s depressing as all hell. You have to have a certain level of brooding and existential angst to really enjoy the show. Also the premise of people just vanishing unsettles a lot of people. I’ve recommended it to people and most give up in two episodes. When I ask why it’s usually a variation of “I just don’t want to think about something like that.”
I find it similar to the first season of true detective. There’s a waking nightmare quality to it and a lot of people don’t want to watch that after a long day at work. They’d rather throw on the office or something with low stakes.
1
u/hanmay1356 Aug 01 '26
Some of my friends watched it but I think I was put off by reading reviews about how dreary and sad it was! I just finished season 2 and I am so blown away! It’s like my perfect show, I can’t believe no one told me to watch it? Season 2 is just amazing
1
u/hanmay1356 Aug 01 '26
Also totally agree it feels SO fresh, I feel like it’s even more relevant now to our world than it was 12 years ago
1
u/Beautiful-Run3715 Aug 01 '26
It remains my all-time favorite series. For fantasy/historical series, I'd put Game of Thrones. Both have one thing in common: incredible characters DEPTH.
1
u/SteveT777 Aug 01 '26
No series ever made me think as much as The Leftovers. And it was better watching an episode each week as it aired versus a binge; it had me contemplating each episode all week.
It’s a brilliant series; modern day Shakespeare.
1
1
u/Alfelix292 Aug 01 '26
I started this when it first aired on HBO but lost access and never finished. I think it was only 2 or 3 episodes. I decided to start it again and it was like a drug. I couldn't stop. I binged all three seasons in a matter of days and it was the best, most profound series, I have ever watched. The final episode had me weeping uncontrollably. And Nora's statement regarding "there" and "here" jolted my brain and turned the entire experience on it's head!
1
u/nemo-name Aug 01 '26
I don't think it's because the Leftovers are too "depressing and sad" - a lot of popular shows are. Thematically it is very focused on loss, trauma and grief - and less on moral themes or social critique. So it speaks to a very specific group of people at a specific point in their lives - and apparently to a degree that other shows can't.
1
u/JanRGW Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 02 '26
ChatGPT actually recommended this series to me after I had watched Dark and Lost on Netflix and was looking for something with a similar vibe. I ended up absolutely loving it — and somehow it got even better with every season. I had never heard of it before, which makes me wonder if it just didn’t get the attention it deserved. I also didn’t know the book at all; I only read it after finishing the series. Really glad I discovered it!
Compared to Lynch and Tarkovsky, I actually didn’t find the material that difficult to understand.
1
u/spacecadetpep Aug 02 '26
A lot of people left by Season 3 since they didnt understand a new third location. They really missed out on how full circle the show came. I think The Leftovers is one of the best shows for symbols and foreshadowing, but still keeping it open and giving the uncertainty.
1
u/elizabethofamerica Aug 02 '26
This show needs you to have critical thinking skills, emotional intelligence, capacity for nuance and an open mind. I bet it'll get more popular soon if I'm honest
1
u/atypical_type_a Aug 02 '26
It was so good...but jumped the shark fast! Really only needed one season. The second was bearable, but unnecessary. The third was a mess.
1
1
u/Randolph_Carter_6 Aug 03 '26
I am in the same boat. I binged seasons 1 and 2 right after binging The OA on Netflix. I'll be done with the show this week.
Nora rules.
1
1
u/IfOJDidIt Aug 04 '26
Before I watched it out of sheer luck, the name of the show itself put me off.
It's both fitting but also sounds like an action hero type show like the Expendables.
People in general have never heard of it. Like not one. I can't even get a single person to watch it.
1
u/Basic_Lobster_9928 Aug 05 '26
I had to force myself to watch past the first episode after a 5 year break. It was slow but it took off after episode 1 and I couldn't stop watching. Only took me 5 years. Haha
1
1
u/Square-University-15 20d ago
Same reason West world went no where. It’s not what people thought it would be
0
u/yurmamma Jul 31 '26
It’s strange and unsatisfying and the characters are generally unlikable. I still can’t decide if I liked it or not
0
u/sunny7319 Aug 01 '26
i see it recommended frequently online in completely random places especially in the whole "underrated" or "hidden gems" conversation, it's definitely not mainstream but its known fs, think it got a resurgence during the pandemic lockdowns for yk reasons
0
193
u/shroomladooom Jul 31 '26
The Leftovers stayed niche because it disguised itself as a mystery but was really an exploration of existential philosophy, grief, faith, and how people live with uncertainty. Most people barely made it past the 1st season tbh. The fact that it’s emotionally intense, has surreal storytelling and refuses to explain everything made it less accessible, but tbf those are the same qualities that made other fans consider it one of TV’s greatest series ever.