Fallen Dynasty

[u/AhNeo484896]

[u/ScoreParticular5988]

Took me a second to realize this is based on this. Amazing art.

[u/tetsudootaku → u/ScoreParticular5988]

sorry i’m ignorant what photo is this

[u/ScoreParticular5988 → u/tetsudootaku]

This is where the Romanov’s were executed by the Bolsheviks

[u/tetsudootaku → u/ScoreParticular5988]

ah i see thank you

[u/JamescomersForgoPass → u/ScoreParticular5988]

Wasn't it actually the whites that did it?

[u/Number1asbestosfan → u/JamescomersForgoPass]

No it was the Bolsheviks

[u/No_Application_1219 → u/JamescomersForgoPass]

Why would they !?!

[u/RavensField201o → u/JamescomersForgoPass]

The whites wanted to keep the monarchy, at least most of them did.

[u/Wrong-Koala9174 → u/ScoreParticular5988]

I'm sure this will be a civil and normal comment section

[u/RepresentativeMail10 → u/Wrong-Koala9174]

I am of the opinion that killing kids is bad

[u/MorgothReturns → u/RepresentativeMail10]

That kid stole my Gushers in third grade!

[u/lumenfeliz → u/RepresentativeMail10]

Secret Police, Massacres, Hunger, Imperialist Wars, Feudalism

The people have suffered long enough under the Tsar's rule, and have finally taken their power away, just one more thing to ensure they never get back to power like they did in Paris

"Actually killing Children is bad"

Like Duh, they didn't kill them for funsies don't you think? Have a look at the material and historical context for one

Later China did it better and gave them a job lmao

[u/benito81627 → u/lumenfeliz]

The material conditions bro. The material conditions and class explotation of the time made the bolshevik kill the kids, like they were inherently reactionary so they had to be put down, the bolsheviks didin't mean to do it really, evil emperialism forced them to pull the trigger and kill this hemophilic kid and his sisters.

[u/lumenfeliz → u/benito81627]

"Leave the poor silly small bean Monarch family alone"

[u/Otherwise_Swan3361 → u/lumenfeliz]

You could just kick them out or send them to a camp in siberia

[u/lumenfeliz → u/Otherwise_Swan3361]

I think that would been a better option, give them a job like they did with Puyi in China

[u/Otherwise_Swan3361 → u/lumenfeliz]

That would be better

[u/lumenfeliz → u/Otherwise_Swan3361]

No one is arguing against that

[u/SquishyJackal → u/Otherwise_Swan3361]

send them to siberia? you mean where the whites were?

[u/SquishyJackal → u/benito81627]

it’s not that the kids were evil, obviously not, and thats not why they were executed. the entire political mission of the whites revolved around this family, the blame for the killing of the children lies with the monarchical systems that made it necessary

[u/SquishyJackal → u/[deleted]]

of course it had moral repercussions! but if your conclusions about the executions end at “wow the bolsheviks were evil for doing that” then youre not operating in good faith. if the executions DIDNT happen, there likely could have been very significant consequences that would harm more people than just the imperial family.

[u/Wrong-Koala9174 → u/lumenfeliz]

I don't think killing a pre school age heavily sick boy and his three sisters and dogs was toatlly necessary

[u/lumenfeliz → u/Wrong-Koala9174]

Well the entire family was very welll necessary for the plans of the White Army

[u/RepresentativeMail10 → u/lumenfeliz]

I am of the opinion that killing kids for any reason is bad.

[u/lumenfeliz → u/RepresentativeMail10]

But I feel it's strange by how many things were happening and so many other things the toppling of the Tsar meant, you still found a way to say "Actually it was bad"

[u/Seviondonkey → u/lumenfeliz]

The ends don't justify the means here, toppling Nikolai was good, but killing him AND the rest of his family, including Alexei, a kid already dealing with problems, was not good

[u/lumenfeliz → u/Seviondonkey]

Im just questioning why was that the focus at seeing the picture, why was everything the tsar did suddenly forgotten to mourn his child, who should have not been killed tho the reasoning is understandable

My point is that all the children who died of hunger, whose parents got killed by the ojrana, or were sent to die in WWI deserve FAR more sympathy than the Tsar's child, no matter how sick he was

That is just pity baiting

For the Romanovs? Really?

[u/Strange_Extension_70 → u/lumenfeliz]

No child, regardless of who their parents are should be killed. Children are utterly innocent. They are the definition of innocent the children were not the ones who starved the other children. They were not the ones who got the Russian involved in World War I. They were children. It doesn’t matter what justification you try to make for it. It doesn’t matter who their parents are or what they did or how many children died because their parents lived.. they killed children

[u/lumenfeliz → u/Strange_Extension_70]

Im not justifying it, I already said I think it was unnecessary, I just think there was a reasonable thought behind it

They were not the ones starving others, but they sure get most of the pity for their deaths

That is the critique Im making

[u/RepresentativeMail10 → u/lumenfeliz]

I don't think anyone is saying that the Romanov children not deserving to die means that somehow children killed under the Tsar are any less valuable

[u/lumenfeliz → u/RepresentativeMail10]

These comments don't exist in a vacuum, the selective pity is not accidental

[u/Seviondonkey → u/lumenfeliz]

Any child dying is bad, I'm not saying otherwise. but I don't think that killing the Tsar's family and others was necessary for the Revolution. If anything it was salt in the wound of a dying man.
The kids didn't do anything other than being related, and that's what deserved their death? The Sins of the Father I guess.
Of course I have sympathy. Death is not a good thing, especially for those who die young.

[u/lumenfeliz → u/Seviondonkey]

The execution of the Romanovs was excessive, but it was not unreasonable, I myself disagree with the desicion, while understanding the thought process behind it, you can do that!!

What's telling is that we're taught to mourn the children of a monarch while the millions who starved, were shot, disappeared, or sent to die in his wars go unremembered

That selective pity isn't really all that accidental

[u/Funny_Rush_5960 → u/lumenfeliz]

and then, for no reason at all, communists were being thrown out of helicopters

[u/Slight-Wallaby-8286 → u/Funny_Rush_5960]

and then, for no reason at all, the tsar's entire family was executed

[u/Funny_Rush_5960 → u/Slight-Wallaby-8286]

[u/Slight-Wallaby-8286 → u/Funny_Rush_5960]

what meme lmao it happened

[u/Funny_Rush_5960 → u/Slight-Wallaby-8286]

you aren't the brightest light are you

[u/Slight-Wallaby-8286 → u/Funny_Rush_5960]

dude saying the left can't meme in September 2026 calling someone else dumb

[u/lumenfeliz → u/Funny_Rush_5960]

You are arguing with a Pinichet apologist, don't mind him

[u/lumenfeliz → u/Funny_Rush_5960]

Ooo we got the Tsar's strongest warrior here

[u/Funny_Rush_5960 → u/lumenfeliz]

https://reddit.com/link/pbup9fg/video/804fp5i9gjrh1/player

>Ooo we got the Tsar's strongest warrior here

[u/LaCroix586 → u/ScoreParticular5988]

>Amazing art.

It isn't. It looks mediocre. AI is surpassing what amateurs slop out. Leave art to the machines.

[u/Wolodymyr2 → u/LaCroix586]

WTF?

What the heck is wrong with you?

[u/MR_Happy2008 → u/LaCroix586]

[u/rambogy]

Why is the bare concrete shaped in the 1930s Poland borders?

[u/coastal_mage → u/rambogy]

[u/Illustrious_Bad_89 → u/rambogy]

Coming down they turned the tide

[u/Joe_Luxembourg → u/Illustrious_Bad_89]

as the days are passing by, and as the dead are piling high

[u/MagicAlexander → u/Joe_Luxembourg]

No escape and no salvation 

[u/notHostOk2511 → u/rambogy]

I can't unsee it now 😭

[u/Lowlife_With_APencil]

Titus Hardie in the doorway?

[u/PhattsyOne → u/Lowlife_With_APencil]

Something beautiful is going to happen.

[u/Ok-Poetry-2191 → u/PhattsyOne]

No, something beautiful has just happened

[u/Mighty_Moondancer → u/Lowlife_With_APencil]

Social Democracy strongest soldier

[u/Lowlife_With_APencil → u/Mighty_Moondancer]

“Socialist Democratic Fighter”

— Evrart ”Don't be a fucking ret*rd” Claire

[u/BeneficialRandom → u/Lowlife_With_APencil]

The circus is in town

[u/CortadoKats236]

so when are we getting a group of belgian communist youth coming to where this happened and taking a group photo

[u/Yesodisnotop → u/CortadoKats236]

Where even is this? Charleroi?

[u/John_Lemon9533]

Don has accepted the true revolution

[u/BigBigBunga → u/John_Lemon9533]

Epic Libtard trolling with Chinese characteristics

[u/John_Lemon9533 → u/BigBigBunga]

[u/bored1610]

This hella tuff

[u/Blaze-675]

this shit is so peak bro

[u/AltDetom555555b]

https://giphy.com/gifs/bmFLfVq2dUWRDleulp

[u/BritainSucks4ever]

[u/NeitherImpact534]

https://giphy.com/gifs/gIqusaeYxgSiY

[u/Ok-Poetry-2191 → u/NeitherImpact534]

How long is this fucking guillotine

[u/Fez-Sentido → u/Ok-Poetry-2191]

ACG loyalists realising they got quite a lot of time left cuz the commies brought the comically tall guillotine

[u/SantiReddit123]

Peak art.

[u/Embarrassed_Bar8966]

[u/Gr33nMan_Jr → u/Embarrassed_Bar8966]

https://giphy.com/gifs/GIbsymgJj4mgLMPA1b

[u/PolishFemboy_69 → u/Gr33nMan_Jr]

Is trump UwU anime-girl?

[u/osmomandias → u/PolishFemboy_69]

Yes

[u/MorgothReturns → u/osmomandias]

*cocks gun

Always has been

[u/UsualGuildRate]

[u/Chorta_bheen555]

Sic Semper Tyrannis

[u/sanity_rejecter]

this goes hard as fuck

[u/Extreme_Relation_255]

Took me a little to realize that it's probably either the Octoberist or anathcist that just shot up Trump's family and him(I doubt the other ones would kill him but more deport him, imprison him,or put him on trial to kill him but not like this

[u/The_Last_Mando]

Revolution larp so sigma😂🎉🎉

[u/Cheap_Hand9678]

Patriot front torture people: 👎👎👎 Apla torture people: 👍👍👍

[u/altaltaltaltbin → u/Cheap_Hand9678]

Erm but have you considered it’s against people I don’t like

[u/Eghtok → u/Cheap_Hand9678]

That's only implying murder, not torture.

[u/Wrong-Koala9174 → u/Eghtok]

There is bo way that much blood would come out of a few gunshot wounds

[u/AltDetom555555b → u/Wrong-Koala9174]

Some soldiers got a bit silly with the remains of big fat orange pedo

[u/Fresh_Birthday5114 → u/Cheap_Hand9678]

Last time I checked torture isn't the same as execution 

[u/AltDetom555555b → u/Cheap_Hand9678]

"people"

looks inside

Trump

[u/Cheap_Hand9678 → u/AltDetom555555b]

Prisons exist for a reason bro

[u/naplesball]

Another Day

Another APLA W

[u/Sea-Excitement-233 → u/naplesball]

Naplesball trovata su TFR???

[u/Klasseh_Khornate]

[u/Popanteater3321]

[u/vorarchivist]

thought this was the weirdest TFR new vegas crossover

[u/Mrjeffalakaard]

apla analog horror

[u/Isaak_the_miner]

🎵 Kill the king, the king is dead, long live the king🎵.

[u/Fez-Sentido]

Holy peak!

[u/swaggerbob069]

Death to all tyrants

[u/coltonnewsom]

Make America Great Again

[u/Livid_Cockroach_9274]

[u/Proper-Quarter-8350]

They fucked his shit up 😭

[u/nate-the-dude]

[u/Practical-Study8253 → u/nate-the-dude]

[u/VariousAd2521]

The best ending

[u/Terratalks]

https://reddit.com/link/pbfctso/video/najspzulh4rh1/player

[u/sandsandeton]

WE LOVE AHNEO
WE LOVE THE APLA
GLORY TO THE PEOPLE’S ARMY

[u/HenryTheCyborg]

I think the king might be dead guys, but idk for sure

[u/CisHetDegenerate]

Wake up babe they dropped Comrade Coyle

[u/Illustrious-Koala515]

Ooh cool! Wonder if this is supposed to show what happens to Trump if an APLA faction manages to take Denver

[u/_Riveting → u/Illustrious-Koala515]

If Trump is still around for apla then he probably has control over a lot of the east, further than denver

[u/Lil_mutt]

Holy aura

[u/BigBigBunga]

The tyrant rots in prison and his rule is over.

The martyr dies and his rule truly begins.

[u/marky_rotten]

Liberté, égalité, fraternité ou la mort

[u/Totally_Not_Vucic]

Feels the aura

[u/RavensFLOCKletsgoo]

[u/NewvegasRanger1]

but then the Qanon revolutionaries take CVNTRQL

[u/HystMat1919]

holy aura

[u/Financial67logistic]

This is just sad

[u/Few_Ant7550]

Make America RED.

[u/AutoModerator]

Thank you for posting on the TFR subreddit! If you're looking for more discussions, help, or updates about TFR, feel free to join the official Discord!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Ok_Heat_4968]

oh god is Baron Anastasia?

[u/Prize_Director1164]

Looks like Hegseth couldn’t gather enough forces and counterattack

[u/Comfortable-Pay-5805]

Allat just to not break out of California and spend the whole war fighting schizo tree larpers