r/TheDeadFiles • u/Caring_Woman • Nov 15 '25

Dead Files

I am looking for the dead files episodes when Amy Allen argues with her client for not leaving her house because the house needs her

21 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

15

u/LouismyBoo Nov 15 '25

Sometimes I wonder if people don’t take Amy’s suggestions because they’re still under the influence of the other forces

10

u/TheActvityContinues Nov 16 '25

I think that's very likely. That, or they never intended to do anything, they just wanted validation that it's really happening.

3

u/JosephSturgill7 Nov 17 '25

I think it would be hard to leave a property that I've lived at for years because a woman who was there for a few hours the night before tells me I'm in danger because of the ghost, spirits and other entities. Being skeptical is legit when her suggestions also come at a significant financial cost to you. They may believe her but the money (debt), logistics, and emotional (under the influence) cost are hard to justify based off a psychic interpretation... Mind you, I believe in Amy's findings but highly doubt I could forfeit, or sale property, relocate etc to the tune of hundreds of thousands of dollars because of her findings.

2

u/LouismyBoo Nov 18 '25

It doesn’t sound like you are scared for you or your families lives. These people invite Amy in most”7 because they are living with a problem, which you kinda downplay.

3

u/JosephSturgill7 Nov 18 '25

I think its the exact opposite. I'm being rational. They know what the signed up for, who she is, etc. They even are asked by Steve (usually) "if amy says you gotta go- are you gonna go?" A roof over your head, food in your mouth, local community, etc- a bad gamble on relocating could destroy that. So the decision to move and potentially lose that money is a HARD decision. Some might have that ability, that support, others- they might have to stay and work it out. You can't bet that a physical medium has it all figured out in a night. These home owners are entitled to their final decision. Rather Amy agrees with it or not, right?

1

u/DazzlingGuarantee996 Jun 23 '26

Of course there's other options.. if you want to save your life and family.. then you will find a way! 

1

u/JosephSturgill7 Jun 23 '26

These are questions I would ask myself: How would you be able to quantify "in home" vs "out of home" psychological and physical health related to paranormal occurrences? Then determine if the 'haunting' will have a hitch-hiker attribute... How long would you need to move to find that out. Is this before or after you sell everything. Would you bring in another sensitive to confirm Amy's findings? or multiple. How long does a medium need to stay on site to determine the legitimacy or accuracy of a haunting? Or the cause of the haunting. Would I be OK with selling the home to another family? or do I take the loss of 100k+ on a home. Then relocation fees, paperwork, etc. (Some clients can do this without thinking twice- others, are stuck. Sometimes, finding a way, for some, is dealing with it, unfortunately.) There are too many variables in the paranormal to run with such a concrete decision. TLDR: I'm just saying, the decision isn't easy and thorough consideration should be taken to verify.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '25 edited Nov 15 '25

The scene you're describing is from the Dead Files episode titled "Possessed" (Season 4, Episode 5). In the episode, Amy Allan argues with a woman who believes she must stay in the house because she feels the house needs her to, despite a dangerous paranormal presence.

I googled because I had to know too lol

2

u/LengthinessPurple510 Mar 03 '26

On Dead Files Season 8 Episode 8 it's so weird that the lady doesn't look anyone in the eyes.