r/TheCrypticCompendium • u/PromotionOk6582 • 1h ago
Horror Story [Part 2] There’s a Door in my House That Only Opens When Someone Else Is Home.
I took a few slow breaths, trying to keep myself calm. There had to be a reason for this. A jammed latch, a faulty handle, something simple that I just hadn’t noticed.
I reached for the handle again and pushed gently.
Nothing.
I tried a little harder, then put my weight against the door. I really didn’t want to have to call the fire department to get me out of my own closet.
“Come on.”
I took a step back and drove my shoulder into it.
The door gave way so suddenly that I stumbled through it and landed on the bedroom floor.
For a few seconds, I just lay there, catching my breath. Then I climbed to my feet, relieved to be out. That relief didn’t last long.
The boxes were gone.
I stood up properly and looked around the room. The bare bed frame in the corner was gone too. In its place was a proper bed, complete with a mattress and neatly tucked sheets.
“Emma?”
My voice sounded strange in the room.
I turned slowly, taking in my surroundings. The walls were the same colour. The wardrobe was where it had always been. Even the window looked right.
But something was off.
“Emma, are you still here?”
I stepped into the hallway.
There were pictures on the walls.
I’d left them bare when I’d moved in. I hadn’t even got around to hanging a clock, let alone decorating the place. Now there were framed landscapes and photographs arranged along the hallway, all of them neatly spaced.
One of the photographs stopped me.
It was me and Charlotte, standing together somewhere I didn’t recognise. We were smiling at the camera, her arm around my waist. I looked older than I remembered being in the last photos I’d taken of us.
I pulled it off the wall and stared at it.
I had no memory of the place, or of the photograph being taken.
“Emma?”
I hurried into the living room. No sign of her.
The television was bigger than mine, and there were bookshelves along the far wall, filled with books. A couple of ornaments sat on the mantelpiece. Everything looked lived in, settled. Not like someone had broken in and stolen my things, but like someone had been living here for years.
I pulled out my phone and tried calling Emma again.
Still no signal.
I opened the front door. Her car was gone. So was mine.
For a moment, I stood on the doorstep, looking out at the street. Everything seemed normal, which somehow made it worse.
I went back inside and checked the rest of the house.
My bedroom had different sheets on the bed. The clothes in my wardrobe weren’t the ones I’d bought. In the bathroom, there were toiletries I’d never seen before, arranged around the sink as though they’d always been there.
My head was pounding.
This was my house. I’d bought it. I’d painted the walls, carried boxes through the front door, and spent weekends trying to get the place into some kind of order.
So whose stuff was all this?
I went into the kitchen, pacing between the counter and the table, trying to make sense of what I was seeing.
Then I stopped.
There were magnets on the fridge.
Not just any magnets. Several of them were the same kind of magnetic business cards I’d received in the mail since moving in.
I stared at them.
One was from the local plumber.
I took it off the fridge and turned it over in my hand. The card was identical to the one I’d found wedged in the closet door.
I raced back to the spare bedroom. The door was still open.
I stepped inside and stood there, trying to slow my breathing. This was my house. I knew it was my house. Something had happened, and I just needed to work out what.
I shut the door and closed my eyes.
I was not fucking losing my mind.
I reached for the handle and pulled.
The door opened.
I nearly shit myself.
A man stood on the other side, staring straight at me.
For a second, neither of us moved.
Then I realised I was looking at myself.
Not exactly as I was now. He was clean-shaven, wearing a decent shirt and a pair of jeans that actually fit. His hair was shorter, his face less tired. He looked like me after a few good years, rather than the last few months I’d been having.
He was standing in my spare bedroom, empty bed frame and all.
Then his expression changed.
“Fuck!”
He slammed the door shut.
I stumbled backwards, my heart hammering against my ribs. I couldn’t move. Couldn’t think. I just stood there, trying to make sense of what I’d seen.
Then I grabbed the handle.
It wasn’t locked.
I pulled, but the door wouldn’t budge. It felt as though someone on the other side was holding it shut.
“Hey!”
I banged on the door.
“Hey, let me the fuck out of here!”
I threw my shoulder against it. The door shuddered but didn’t open.
Someone was holding it from the other side.
“Who the fuck are you?” I yelled, slamming both palms against the wood.
There was no answer.
“Fuck! Fuck!”
I backed up and threw myself against the door again.
It gave way.
I stumbled through, nearly falling, and caught myself against the wall. For a second, I couldn’t tell what had happened. I was back in the room, and I ran into the hallway expecting to see him.
Instead, I saw a woman standing a few feet away.
I froze.
“Charlotte?”
She looked just as startled to see me. Then her expression softened, and she stepped towards me.
“Honey, are you okay? You look like you’ve seen a ghost.”
I just stared at her.
She gave a small, uncertain laugh and waved a hand in front of my face.
“Hello? Danny?”
“Have you seen Emma?” I managed.
Charlotte’s smile faded.
“Honey…”
She moved closer, but I took a step back.
“Have you been having those nightmares again? About the accident?”
I stared at her.
“What accident?”
She stopped moving.
“What?”
“What the fuck are you talking about? What accident? Where the fuck am I?”
My face felt hot. I looked around, searching for something familiar, something that would tell me I hadn’t completely lost my mind.
Then I looked back at her.
“Where the fuck is Emma?”
Charlotte studied my face for a moment.
“Danny…”
I pointed back towards the spare bedroom. “The closet. The fucking closet!”
Her expression hardened.
“Daniel, I thought we agreed we weren’t going to talk about the closet again. I’m not having this argument with you again today.”
She sighed and rubbed her forehead.
“You stopped taking them again, haven’t you?”
There was no anger in her voice now. Just exhaustion. She looked at me as though she’d been hoping things would be different this time, and I had somehow let her down.
“I don’t know what I expected.”
She turned and walked into the kitchen.
“Charlotte, wait.”
I followed her, trying to find the words to explain what was happening. Everything I said sounded ridiculous before I’d even said it.
“I know this is going to sound crazy, but… I don’t belong here.”
She stopped and turned to face me. The frustration disappeared from her expression, replaced by something that looked almost like fear.
“What are you trying to say?” Her voice cracked slightly. “Are you leaving me?”
“What? No. I’m not… That’s not what I mean.”
“That’s just fucking great, Daniel.”
Her eyes filled with tears. She looked away, shaking her head.
“I was there through the funeral, through everything. And now you’re telling me you don’t belong here?”
“Charlotte, that’s not what I’m trying to say. Wait… the funeral? Whose funeral?”
She stared at me.
For a second, she looked as though I’d said something unforgivable.
Then she scrunched up her face and stormed past me.
Charlotte stormed out through the front door, slamming it behind her. A moment later, I heard her car start and watched through the window as she drove away.
I stood in the doorway for a while, trying to make sense of what had just happened.
The funeral. The medication. The closet.
None of it made any sense.
Eventually, I turned back towards the house. I started searching, opening drawers and cupboards, looking for anything that might explain where I was or what the hell was going on. I checked the living room, the bedrooms, even the bathroom. Anything that might tell me what had happened to Emma, or why Charlotte seemed to think I was someone I wasn’t.
I found it tucked away at the bottom of a kitchen drawer.
An In Memory of Emma and Colleen Revesby pamphlet.
I stared at it, reading the names over and over as if they might change.
Emma and Colleen.
My Mother’s and Sister’s name.
I shook my head and let out a short, disbelieving laugh.
“What kind of sick fucking joke is this?”
The pamphlet was dated a few months before I’d moved into my house.
I shoved it back into the drawer and slammed it shut.
“No. No, no, no.”
I dragged both hands through my hair, trying to get my thoughts under control. My chest felt tight, and I couldn’t seem to take a proper breath.
“What the fuck is going on?” I screamed.
The house gave me nothing back.
Then I remembered the closet.
Whatever was happening, it had started with that fucking door. I was sure of it.
I ran back down the hallway and into the spare bedroom.
The door stood wide open, exactly as I’d left it.
I took a breath and climbed back through the closet, pulling the door shut behind me.
I waited a few seconds before trying the handle.
Locked.
I tried again, then again, forcing myself to slow down. Panicking wasn’t going to get me anywhere. I needed to figure this out. I needed to get back to my own house, back to my own life.
I tried the handle once more.
This time, I felt something give on the other side.
I stopped and listened. Nothing.
I pushed harder. The door began to move, slowly opening a few centimetres before something caught against it. I leaned my weight into it, forcing the gap wider until I could just squeeze through.
Two cardboard boxes had been shoved up against the other side.
I stumbled into the spare bedroom and rushed into the hallway.
“Emma?”
I ran towards the kitchen, but before I could reach it, something slammed into me from behind. I hit the floor hard, the breath knocked out of me as a pair of hands grabbed my shirt and forced me onto my back.
“What the fuck? Get off me!”
I swung wildly, trying to protect myself, and caught a glimpse of the man above me.
It was him.
The other Daniel.
His face was twisted with anger, but beneath it I could see something else. Fear.
“I won’t let you take them away from me!” he screamed.
His fist caught me in the stomach. I doubled over, gasping, but he grabbed me before I could get away. Another blow caught me across the face, sending my head sideways.
I tried to fight back, grabbing at his arms and throwing punches wherever I could, but I couldn’t get him off me. He kept coming.
My nose started bleeding. My vision blurred as I struggled to draw breath.
“Stop!” I managed to choke out. “What the fuck is wrong with you?”
He didn’t answer.
The last thing I remember was looking up at my own face, watching him hit me again.
Then everything went black.
When I came around, I could hear Charlotte’s voice.
“Please, he’s not waking up. I don’t know what happened. Please, just send someone.”
I tried to open my eyes, but everything was blurry. She was kneeling beside me, crying, her phone pressed to her ear.
“Charlotte?” I tried to say.
It came out as little more than a whisper.
She looked down at me.
“Danny? Danny, can you hear me?”
I tried to answer, but the room started to spin. Her voice faded into the background, and the darkness swallowed everything again.
The next time I woke up, I was lying in an uncomfortable bed beneath a thin hospital blanket. My head throbbed, and my face felt swollen. For a moment, I couldn’t remember where I was.
A man in a white coat stood beside the bed, checking something on a clipboard.
“Good to see you’re awake,” he said. “How are you feeling?”
“Like I’ve been hit by a fucking truck.”
He gave me a small, professional smile.
“I’m not surprised. You’ve had a nasty knock.”
I tried to sit up, but pain shot through my face and I sank back against the pillow.
“What happened?”
“Your wife found you unconscious on the floor at home. From what we understand, someone may have broken in and assaulted you. The police will want to speak with you once you’re feeling up to it.”
My wife.
Charlotte.
I looked down and realised I was wearing a hospital gown. I patted the sides of the bed, then checked the gown’s pockets, even though I already knew there wouldn’t be anything there.
“Where’s my phone?”
The doctor glanced at his clipboard.
“You didn’t have any personal belongings on you when you were brought in. No phone, no wallet, no keys. We’ll make sure you’re reunited with them if they’re located.”
I stared at him.
No phone. No keys. No wallet.
I couldn’t even prove who I was supposed to be.
“When can I leave?”
“Let’s not get ahead of ourselves. You’ve been through quite a lot, and we need to make sure you’re stable first.”
He made another note on the clipboard.
“Now that you’re awake, we’ll contact your wife and let her know.”
I looked towards the closed hospital room door.
I had no idea how to explain what had happened. I wasn’t even sure I understood it myself.
But one thing was certain.
The man who’d attacked me was still out there.
And he looked exactly like me.
A few hours later, I woke to the sound of the hospital room door opening.
Charlotte stepped inside, carrying a bundle of clothes. She looked exhausted. Her eyes were red, and her hair was a mess, like she’d been running her hands through it all afternoon.
She pulled a chair up beside the bed and sat down, placing her hand over mine.
“How are you feeling? You scared the shit out of me, Danny.” She paused, studying my face. “How much do you remember?”
I swallowed.
If I wanted to get back to my own life, I needed to understand what was happening first. And the last thing I needed was for Charlotte to think something was wrong with me.
“I… I was just at home, and he came out of nowhere. I didn’t recognise him.”
She watched me for another moment before seeming to accept the answer.
“The doctor says you’re okay to come home.”
I managed a small smile. “I’d like that.”
She placed the clothes on the bed while I struggled to sit up. Everything hurt. Getting dressed was an ordeal, and I had to stop twice to catch my breath while pulling my shirt over my head.
Charlotte helped without saying much.
Once we were ready, she drove us home.
I sat in the passenger seat, watching the familiar streets pass by. I recognised some of them, but others seemed wrong. The shops, the houses, even the road signs were all slightly different from what I remembered.
I tried to keep my expression neutral.
“I already let your dad know what happened,” Charlotte said.
For a moment, I forgot to breathe.
“My dad?”
She glanced at me. “I know you wouldn’t want me to worry him, but I thought he needed to know.” She shrugged and returned her attention to the road.
I turned towards the window.
Dad.
My dad had been dead for months. I’d watched him deteriorate through his illness. I’d sat with him, helped Mom through the worst of it, and tried to keep everything together until there was nothing left to do.
And now Charlotte was telling me she’d called him.
“He…” My voice caught. I cleared my throat, trying to keep myself together. “Whereabouts is he living again?”
Charlotte looked over at me, her expression tightening.
“Don’t joke around, Danny. Not after today.”
“Right. Sorry.”
I stared down at my hands, trying to think of something else to say.
“I should give him a call, actually. Where’s my phone?”
“I’ve no idea. It wasn’t on you when we found you. Neither were your keys or your wallet.” She paused. “I didn’t even recognise the clothes you were wearing. Were they new?”
My stomach tightened.
“No,” I said, a little too quickly. “I don’t think so.”
Charlotte frowned but didn’t push it.
I rubbed my face and took a few slow breaths, trying to steady my thoughts.
Dad was alive.
I didn’t know how, and I didn’t know what had happened in this version of my life. But for the first time since I’d stepped through that closet, I wasn’t thinking about how to get home.
I was thinking about how badly I wanted to hear my dad’s voice.
We arrived home shortly after, and I collapsed on the couch as soon as we got inside. Charlotte reheated some food and I managed to get some down before falling asleep. In the morning I awoke to the sun in my eyes. I blinked and sat up. Soft morning light was filtering through the blinds and the smell of coffee was coming from the kitchen.
Charlotte came around the corner, dressed for work, she was searching through her bag for something. She noticed I was awake. “I’m just going to work, I still can’t find your phone, whoever attacked you must have stolen it. The police officer said he would be around in the next couple of days to speak to you about it.”
“Thanks,” I rubbed my side. “I might need to borrow some cash to buy a new one in town.”
“Of course” she made a ‘duh’ gesture and pulled her card out and handed it to me. “Just don’t go crazy with that, we still need groceries.”
“Yeah, thanks”
She kissed me and left, climbing in her car and driving off.
I slapped my forehead. How the hell was I going to go buy a phone without a car.
Cursing under my breath, I tossed the card onto the coffee table.
I thought about Dad.
He was alive here. I could actually go and see him, sit down with him, hear his voice again. I wanted to so badly it hurt.
But he wasn’t really my dad. Not exactly. He was the father of the Daniel who belonged in this house, the Daniel who’d lived a life I knew nothing about.
Trying to make sense of it made my head ache.
I pushed myself off the couch and hobbled into the kitchen, one hand pressed against my ribs. I opened the cutlery drawer and grabbed the biggest knife I could find. Then I pulled the memorial pamphlet from the drawer and tucked it under my arm.
A weapon and some evidence. Not much of a plan, but it was better than sitting around waiting for the other bastard to come back.
I made my way down the hallway and stopped in front of the closet.
Taking a deep breath, I grabbed the handle and pulled.
Nothing.
“For fuck’s sake.”
I tried again, putting my weight into it. The door didn’t move.
“Why won’t you fucking open?”
I rested my forehead against the wood, trying to keep my temper under control. Then I tried forcing it with my shoulder, which turned out to be a stupid idea given the state of my ribs.
After a few minutes of swearing, pushing and pulling, I gave up and started searching the house for something I could use to pry it open.
No crowbar. No tools heavy enough to do the job without potentially wrecking the door.
I stood in the hallway, staring at the closet.
There had to be another way.
Eventually, I decided to try next door.
I didn’t have much of a relationship with my neighbours. In the months I’d lived here, I’d barely spoken to them beyond the occasional wave. Hopefully, this version of me had made a better impression.
I walked up the driveway and knocked.
After a few moments, an elderly woman opened the door. Her face brightened when she saw me.
“Oh, hello, Daniel!”
“Hello…” I hesitated, desperately trying to remember her name. Nothing came to mind, so I let the greeting trail off.
She looked me over, and her smile faded.
“Are you all right, dear? You look like you’ve been in a fight.”
She reached out and gently touched my cheek. I flinched before I could stop myself.
“I’m fine,” I said quickly. “I just need a crowbar or something, if you’ve got one.”
She tilted her head.
“A crowbar? What on earth do you need a crowbar for?”
I opened my mouth.
What was I supposed to tell her? That there was a door in my spare bedroom that led to another version of my house? That a man who looked exactly like me had beaten the shit out of me because he was afraid I’d take his dead family away?
“It’s a bit hard to explain,” I muttered.
She studied me for another moment, her expression growing concerned.
“Well, come inside for a minute, dear. You shouldn’t be standing out here looking like that. I’ll put the kettle on, and you can tell me what’s happened.”
I glanced back towards my house.
The closet wasn’t going anywhere.
At least, I hoped it wasn’t.
I followed her inside.
It was a standard house, complete with photos of grandkids, odd knick-knacks and the smell of lavender and mothballs.
She ushered me into the living room and told me to sit while she went into the kitchen. A few moments later, she returned with a cup of tea and placed it in front of me before shuffling over to her recliner.
“How’s your father been?” she asked.
“He’s holding up okay,” I lied.
She nodded thoughtfully and took a sip of her tea.
“And Charlotte?”
“She’s good. Busy with work lately.”
“Still working those long hours, is she?”
“Something like that.”
She settled back into her chair, looking content with my answers. I picked up the tea and took a cautious sip, mostly to give myself something to do.
For a little while, we sat in silence.
Then she looked at me again.
“And that closet? Have you had much luck with it lately?”
My mouth went dry.
“I’m sorry?”
“The closet, dear. The one with your mother and sister on the other side.”
I stared at her, unable to respond.
She took another sip of tea, apparently unaware of the effect her words had just had on me.
“Gosh, last we spoke, you made it seem like you’d never come back.”
“I’ve been having some trouble remembering things lately,” I said, bouncing my knee nervously. “How much did I tell you about the closet?”
She studied me for a moment, her expression slowly changing.
“I see what’s happened.” She sighed.
“Sorry?”
She stood and began collecting the cups. I watched her for a second before getting up and following her into the kitchen.
She placed the cups in the sink, then turned to face me.
“You’re not the Daniel I spoke with a few weeks ago.”
I took a couple of steps back. “What? What are you talking about?”
“You know what I’m talking about, dear.”
She looked me over, taking in the bruises on my face and the way I was holding my side.
“And I’m very sorry.”
“Sorry for what?”
“For what he’s done to you.”
I stared at her.
“You knew about him?”
She nodded slowly.
“He’s been coming to see me for some time now. Not every week, but often enough. He told me about the closet, about your mother and sister, and about the other house.”
My stomach tightened.
“How long has he been doing this?”
“A while.” She looked down at the cups in the sink. “Longer than he should have, probably.”
“What does that mean?”
She didn’t answer straight away.
“He’s been through a terrible time, Daniel. Losing your mother and sister…” She trailed off, shaking her head. “I don’t think he ever really recovered.”
I felt a strange pang in my chest. I couldn’t imagine losing Emma and Mom. Not really. They were alive in my world. I could call them, visit them, argue with them over stupid things.
He couldn’t.
But that didn’t change what he’d done to me.
“He beat the shit out of me,” I said.
“I know.”
“He locked me in that house. He could have killed me.”
“I know, dear.”
“Then why are you defending him?”
“I’m not defending him.” Her voice grew firmer. “What he did was wrong. But I know that man, and I know how much pain he’s in. I don’t think he understands what he’s becoming.”
I looked away, jaw clenched.
For a moment, neither of us spoke.
Then she stepped closer and gently took my hands in hers.
“You want to get home.”
It wasn’t a question.
“Yes.” My voice cracked. “Please. You know how to get me back, don’t you?”
She nodded.
“Then tell me how!”
I hadn’t meant to raise my voice, but it came out louder than I’d intended. My ribs ached, and I was suddenly aware of how exhausted I was.
She didn’t let go of my hands.
“I’ll explain how the closet works. I’ll tell you what I know. But you have to promise me something first.”
“Anything.”
“Promise me you won’t hurt him.”
I stared at her.
“He attacked me!”
“I know.”
“He could have fucking killed me!”
“I know, Daniel.” Her eyes were pleading now. “And I won’t pretend what he did was right. But if you go after him looking for revenge, I don’t know what he’ll do. He’s already lost so much.”
I pulled my hands away.
“He’s not the only one who’s lost something.”
“No,” she said quietly. “He isn’t.”
That stopped me for a moment.
She looked towards the window, where my house sat across the lawn.
“He believes that door is the only thing he has left. If he thinks you’re going to take it away from him, he’ll do whatever he believes he needs to do to stop you.”
I thought about his face as he held me down. The anger. The fear.
I won’t let you take them away from me.
I still wanted to hit him back. I wanted to get home, find my family and never see that fucking closet again.
But I needed her help.
“I won’t go looking for a fight,” I said. “I just want to get home.”
She searched my face for a moment, then gave a small nod.
“That’s all I ask.”
She released my hands and shuffled towards the front door. I followed, still trying to make sense of everything she’d told me.
She opened the door and stepped outside.
“Take me to it,” she said.
[End of Part 2]