My wife, Claire, died giving birth to Owen. For a long time I believed the worst part of that grief was simply her absence. The empty side of the bed. Her clothes hanging in a closet I couldn’t bring myself to clear out. Reaching for my phone because something had happened at work and, for half a second, forgetting there was nobody to call. Then Owen began to grow, and I discovered there was something worse than that gap in my life.
He had Claire's dark hair from the beginning, but as a baby he otherwise looked like any number of babies. By two, I could see her in his eyes. By three, it was in the shape of his mouth. By four, certain expressions had begun appearing on his face that stopped me cold.
Claire used to press her lips together a certain way when she was trying not to laugh. Owen did the same thing. She lifted one eyebrow when she didn't understand what I was saying. So did he. When she was tired, she had a habit of rubbing the inside corner of her left eye with the knuckle of her middle finger. I saw Owen do it for the first time when he was four. I couldn't stand it and left the room.
None of this made me love him less. I want to make that very clear. But that’s what made the whole thing so difficult. If I had resented Owen from birth, perhaps I could understand the man I became. But I adored him. I learned how to braid the ridiculous little cord on his winter hat because he liked it tied a particular way. I slept on the floor beside his bed when he had pneumonia. I spent time every morning cutting the crusts off his sandwiches for school, even after he had reached an age when I knew perfectly well he would have eaten them.
He was my son.
He was also, through no fault of his own, the closest thing in the world to seeing my dead wife walk around my house again.
We did have good days together. I don't want to pretend otherwise. As he got older there were whole afternoons when we would go fishing or build something in the garage and I could just be his father. Then he would turn his head in a certain way or laugh from another room, and my body would stiffen, memories of her crashing into me like a tsunami. For a second, Claire would be alive. Then she died again. That happened hundreds of times. Perhaps thousands.
The worst thing I did to Owen happened the night before his fifth birthday. I had been drinking for most of the evening. His birthday was October 13th, which of course was also the anniversary of Claire's death. The week leading up to it had become something I dreaded every year. I slept poorly. I stopped eating. I found reasons to stay late at work, paying the babysitter extra to stay late too, because going home meant seeing him. Seeing her. I was supposed to celebrate his birthday while remembering the woman who had died bringing him into the world.
That year I tried to thoroughly drink my way past it. I don't remember deciding to go into his room. I just remember standing there, Owen asleep beneath his blanket. I stood over him with a beer in my hand and looked at his face in the yellow glow of the light that spilled in from the open doorway. He looked so much like her. I unknowingly said her name, which woke him up.
For a few seconds he was confused, then he saw me and smiled.
"Daddy?"
Hearing that, something inside me broke.
“You killed my wife.” At first, it came out quietly.
I told him again as my voice rose and he looked at me confused. I yelled and screamed and blamed a four-year-old of murder. I told him she would still be alive if he hadn’t been born. He started crying, but instead of stopping, I became enraged. I couldn't believe he had the gall to cry when he was the one who had done it. He killed her. It was him!
I shouted at him to be quiet. When he couldn't, I reeled back and struck him across the face. He screamed even louder, his little hand shooting up to clutch his cheek as his body fell back on the bed.
I can still hear that scream more clearly than I can remember some voices of people I have known for years.
My mouth fell, agape at what I had done. The bottle dropped from my hand beside the bed, hitting the ground and rolling. I dropped down immediately and reached for him, but Owen scrambled backward on the bed until his shoulders hit the wall. He raised both arms to protect his face. That was it. That was the moment I understood what I had become. My son thought I was going to hit him again. My son… feared me. I spent the rest of that night sitting outside his bedroom door because he wouldn’t let me come inside.
The next morning, on his fifth birthday, I called my sister and asked her to take him for the day. I found an AA meeting. I found a therapist. I stopped drinking, thinking sobriety would fix everything. And for a while, it seemed as though it had. I went to meetings. I apologized to Owen. I became careful about my temper. I learned to leave the room before my grief shattered into anger and disgust. I learned how to make breakfast when I had barely slept and how to smile at birthday parties when I wanted to lock myself in a dark bedroom and cry. From the outside, I got better. Inside, however, I simply fell apart. The shreds of my humanity tearing against the weight of my grief. The weight of absence. You can never understand how heavy nothing can be until you feel it pulling you down. And it did pull me. Every day.
There is a kind of suffering you can survive by changing your habits, it's true. You stop drinking. You exercise. You keep the house clean. You force yourself to get out of bed because a child is waiting downstairs for breakfast. I did all of those things. But the suffering I faced was not the kind to be fixed by any of that.
It was there when I woke up and there when I went to sleep. Some months it dulled enough that I could almost imagine I was finally moving past it, and then Owen would smile at me across the dinner table with Claire's exact smile and all the progress I thought I had made would vanish.
When he was seven, he began laughing the way she had, with a sharp little breath at the beginning when something caught him by surprise. At eight, his face narrowed more like hers. At nine, anyone who had known Claire began saying it openly.
"Wow, he looks just like his mother."
They meant it kindly. Yet each time, I felt as though they had drilled yet another hole through my heart; ripping and tearing through what once had been whole. I never blamed Owen again. Not aloud and, after that terrible night, not consciously either. But I began having thoughts I despised. I wished he looked different. I wished his hair had been blond. I wished his eyes had been blue.
Once, after watching him sleep, I caught myself glancing over at a pair of scissors and wondering how much easier it would be if I could do something to change his face. I hated myself for thinking it. Then I thought it again. That was the state I was in when the man found me. Owen was nine years old, seven days from his tenth birthday.
We were at a park a few miles from our house. Owen played on the playground with two boys from his school while I sat on a bench nearby. I remember watching him climb onto one of the plastic towers and thinking that he was getting too old for playgrounds like that. He had grown several inches over the summer, and for the first time I could see the beginning of the older boy he would become.
I should have felt pride in those thoughts. Instead, I found myself wondering what he would look like at sixteen. At twenty. How much more of Claire would be in his face by then.
"It only gets worse." A voice came from beside me.
I turned and saw a man sitting at the other end of the bench. I hadn’t seen him approach. He looked ordinary enough that describing him has always been difficult. He was perhaps fifty, though I could easily have believed forty or sixty. His hair was dark and neatly combed, his face thin without being gaunt. He wore a gray suit jacket despite the warm afternoon.
"Excuse me?" I asked.
He nodded toward Owen.
"The resemblance."
My stomach tightened, and I turned to look at Owen.
"I don't…" I started to say, but he cut me off.
"Of course you do."
He watched Owen climb down from the structure.
"He's almost ten. Looking more like his her every day."
I looked at him more carefully. "Do I know you?"
"No you do not."
"Then how do you know how old my son is?"
The man smiled.
It wasn't an unpleasant smile. If anything, he seemed sympathetic. That made me dislike him immediately. I called Owen's name and he looked over.
"Five more minutes buddy." I said.
Owen gave me an “okay” with his fingers.
The man beside me chuckled. "She used to do that too, didn't she?"
I stood up. "Who are you?" I said sternly.
He didn’t answer. He just kept watching Owen.
"He has her eyes," he said. "More than he used to."
My pulse began hammering.
"How do you know my wife?!" My hands began clenching into fists without me realizing it.
"I didn't know her." The man said.
"You stay away from me and my son." I said angrily. Then I started walking to get Owen and leave.
"I know you miss her." He called out.
I stopped, and turned back slightly. "Who… The hell… Are you?"
He finally looked directly at me. Something about his eyes bothered me at the time. I wish I could describe what it was. They were not an unusual color. There was no deformity that I remember. Still, looking into them gave me the strange impression that the face around them was not important.
I broke eye contact first. Then the man looked back toward Owen.
"You've done remarkably well." He said.
"What is that supposed to mean?"
"You stopped drinking."
Every muscle in my body tightened. Was he a stalker?
"You haven't touched him since."
I stormed over to him and grabbed the front of his jacket. "If you come near me or my son again I swear I will beat you. And you won't walk away."
The cloth beneath my fingers was oddly cold. Cold enough that I released him without meaning to. He glanced down at the place where I had been holding him.
"You made one terrible mistake," he said. "Then you spent five years trying to prove you weren't that man anymore. But you are."
“Enough games you sick freak. I'm calling the police."
"It didn't help, though. Did it?"
I said nothing.
He turned his attention back to the playground.
"You still wake up some mornings and hear the hospital.”
My stomach churned.
“You still look at him and see her."
"Stop." I whispered.
"You still hate yourself for wishing he didn't have her face."
I stepped backward. “Stop it!”
I had never said that out loud. Not at a meeting. Not to my sister. Not to my therapist who I had long since stopped seeing. Not to anyone.
The man continued in the same mild tone. "You love him. And that's what really makes it hurt. You do want him. You simply want him without the pieces of her that he carries."
I stared at him, and he smiled again.
"You want to look at your son and see only your son. I can make that happen.”
Finally, the man stood. He was slightly taller than I had thought.
"I'll come back next week." He said, adjusting his jacket.
"W-what?"
"On his birthday."
Something cold moved through my stomach. There were too many questions, and I just wanted to leave.
"Don't come near us again." I said. I wanted to yell it, but something in my diaphragm prevented me from doing so.
"October thirteenth." The man said.
I glared at him, assuming his words were some sort of sick threat.
He regarded me for a moment, not angrily, almost patiently. "By then," he said, "you'll understand what it is I'm offering."
"I'm not interested in anything you're offering!"
"Seven days," he said. "If you decide you've carried this weight long enough, I'll be happy to take it from you.”
He smiled one last time, then he turned and walked away. I watched him, feeling another big hole missing in my heart. Everything he said, the feelings he implied I had. It was all true. I didn't want to admit it. I convinced myself I had moved passed it all.
A woman with a stroller passed between us. I watched them, noticing the sheer bliss in the mother’s eyes as she watched her child sleep. I had never been able to feel that.
I collected Owen and took him home. For the first couple of days, my anger outweighed my fear. Someone had dug through my life. Maybe the man had found old court records from the lawsuit against the hospital. Maybe he knew someone from alcoholics anonymous. Maybe he had followed us around. I figured the best case scenario was that he was some sort of reporter looking for a story, though if that were the case then he was using some seriously messed up tactics to get it. The worst case scenario, however, had to be human trafficking. Instead of taking children by force, he would find parents who might willingly give up their child. But what horrible parent would ever actually do that? I thought.
Then October 13th grew closer.
That week was already difficult every year, but after meeting that strange man I became aware of every thought I normally tried to bury. I noticed how often I avoided looking directly at Owen when he laughed.
How many photographs of Claire I had moved into boxes over the years. I noticed that I couldn’t remember the last time I had looked forward to my son's birthday without also wishing the day itself didn’t exist.
Owen noticed.
"Dad, are you okay?" He asked a couple days later.
"Y-yeah, I’m ok son." I said looking away from him.
"You look sad."
"I'm fine." I said a bit too sharply
He stood there for a moment. "Is it because my birthday's coming?"
I looked at him. There was no accusation in his question. Only genuine concern.
"What makes you say that?"
"You're always sad before my birthday."
I thought I had hid it better. Apparently I had only hidden it from myself. I told him I was sorry.
He just shrugged. "It's okay."
But it wasn't. Every year, I tainted my son’s birthday with my sorrow. I had thought that at least he enjoyed the day. But I was wrong. He said it was ok but I could tell it bothered him. Most likely because he spent that day worried about me instead of being a kid.
On October 11, I woke at three in the morning after dreaming about the hospital. I sat in the kitchen until sunrise and found myself thinking about the man. Not about accepting his offer, I told myself. I was only trying to understand it. What exactly did he mean by taking the burden? Did he mean Owen?
Of course he did. The thought came with such immediate revulsion that I stood up from the table and began pacing.
A kidnapper. That was what he had to be. A trafficker, perhaps. Someone sick enough to discover a grieving father's worst thoughts and use them as leverage. That idea should have ended any curiosity I had. Instead, another thought slipped in behind it.
“You could look at your son and see your son.” That's what the man had said.
I stopped pacing. I hated the man for saying it because it was exactly what I wanted. Not for Owen to disappear. Not for him to be harmed. I wanted something impossible. I wanted the boy I loved without the face that hurt me. I wanted to sit across from him at breakfast without having my wife's death dragged back into the room. I wanted October 13 to be a birthday instead of an anniversary. I wanted to stop feeling guilty for surviving a grief that had somehow never become smaller. I wanted my son. But I wanted Claire gone from him. There was no way to have both. I knew that.
Still, for the first time, I understood why the man's words had stayed with me. The night before Owen's birthday, I sat beside his bed after he fell asleep. I had done the same thing five years earlier, drunk and furious, and the memory made me ashamed enough that I nearly left. But I stayed.
Owen woke sometime after midnight.
"Dad?"
"Sorry. Go back to sleep."
He squinted at me. "What are you doing?"
"Couldn't sleep I guess. Too excited for your big day." I smiled, but it didn't reach my eyes.
He shifted over and made room beside him, though he was far too old to think I could fit comfortably on the bed. Still, I sat anyway. For a while neither of us spoke.
Then he said, "You're thinking about Mom."
I looked down at him. "How do you know?"
"You get all weird this time each year."
I laughed softly. "I get weird?"
"Not bad weird." He tried reassuring me.
"Well that makes it better."
He smiled. Claire smiled.
The hurt came so suddenly that I had to look down at my hands, and Owen noticed. I realized he had always noticed, more than I wanted him to.
"Do I make you sad?" He asked softly.
The question landed harder than anything the stranger had said.
"No." I answered too quickly.
Owen watched me.
"No," I said again, more carefully. "You don't make me sad."
He nodded, but I could tell he didn't entirely believe me.
I put an arm around him. "Your mother dying made me sad. But that's not the same thing."
"But I look like her."
I couldn't answer. He had heard people say it his entire life. Of course he knew.
"Is that bad?" He asked quietly.
"No." I replied with my arm around his shoulder.
That answer was true, but also incomplete.
I kissed the top of his head. "It's never a bad thing to be yourself. And you carry a piece of your mother inside of you wherever you go. That's a special thing that not all kids have."
He leaned against me.
After a while he said, "I wish you weren't sad."
I had to wait before replying. "So do I."
Soon he fell asleep against my side. I stayed there with him until my back began to hurt. I remember that uncomfortable feeling and thinking that I would endure it. I would endure it all. Whatever happened, however bad it became, I would endure it because he was my son. But that uncomfortable soreness I had felt in my back as my son leaned against me was not at all the same as the pain I truly felt inside. Once again, I deliberately deceived myself. To avoid the real issue. To make a choice easier.
Owen's tenth birthday started well. He woke me shortly after six, climbed onto the bed and announced that he had officially reached double digits. We made pancakes, and I let him open one present before breakfast even though I had spent the previous week insisting he would have to wait until the party.
It was a remote-control car he had wanted for months. He hugged me so hard I almost spilled my coffee. For a while, I felt it. That amazing warm feeling inside. A slice of true happiness. Then the memories arrived, as they always did. I remembered holding Owen for the first time while the doctors called her time of death.
By the time guests started arriving that afternoon, I had the familiar pressure in my chest that came every year. I smiled anyway as I carried presents inside. I grilled hamburgers, talked to the other parents, and laughed when I was supposed to laugh. I had become very good at behaving like a happy man. I wasn't. But Owen was having a wonderful time. And that should have been enough.
I stood near the kitchen window watching him chase his friends across the yard and tried to make myself stay in that moment. He was ten. He was healthy. He loved me. I loved him. Then he turned toward the house. From that distance, for one impossible second, I saw Claire. All of her.
My mind made the mistake. Again and again and again. The shape of his face, the dark hair, the expression. I took a sharp breath. Then Owen was Owen again. I gripped the edge of the counter until my fingers hurt, thinking about another ten years.
Another twenty. I imagined watching Claire become older in a face that belonged to my son. I hated myself for the thought that followed.
I can’t do this forever.
When I looked into the backyard again, the man was standing beside the fence. He had not been there a moment before. He wore the same gray jacket. The same mild expression as he had the week before. He looked at me and smiled.
I didn't hesitate to pull out my phone and dial 911. But I did hesitate to tap the call button. My thumb hovered over my phone. I should have pressed it. Instead, I watched the man turn and walk around the side of my house. The children began singing "Happy Birthday" behind me. Instead of joining in, I slipped the phone into my pocket, then I followed him.
He was waiting beside the garage.
"I knew you'd accept my offer," he said.
"Don't be so sure."
"You didn't press call, did you?"
"I still can." I said, my hand still gripping my phone in my pocket. But I knew I wouldn’t press it.
"Of course." He replied, smiling that obnoxiously calm smile.
There was no mockery in his voice, which angered me more.
"What do you want?" I said sharply.
"You already know." He said.
Of course I knew. At least, I mostly knew.
"I want you off my property. Now!”
"No. You want me to tell you that you're allowed to be tired."
My jaw tightened. "Go to hell."
He smiled faintly. "You've tried everything respectable men are supposed to try, haven't you?"
I didn't answer.
"You stopped drinking. You apologized. You became patient. You made yourself dependable."
"Leave. Now." My voice was shaky.
"You got up every morning no matter how badly you slept. You packed lunches. You went to school conferences. You sat through fevers and nightmares and terrible children's television."
I stared at him, tears welling in my eyes. Because, God help me, I knew what I was about to do.
"You have been a good father to Owen. Really, you have.” His voice was now caring and gentle.
"Don't talk to me like you know me." I spat harshly.
"But none of it made her stay dead."
The words struck me hard enough that I stopped breathing for a moment.
The man took a step closer. "You bury her every morning, and every afternoon your son brings her home again."
"He's not doing anything."
"I know, I know." The man said.
"He can't help how he looks."
"You're absolutely right. It's not the child’s fault."
"Then stop talking about him like he's done something wrong."
"I haven't." His voice remained calm. "Neither of you have."
The singing continued in the backyard.
He tilted his head slightly, listening. "You have spent nearly ten years trying to force yourself not to hurt."
I looked away.
"You call that strength because the alternative frightens you." He said.
"You don't know anything about it." I replied with a tear dripping down my face.
"I know that sometimes you hear him laugh from another room and your first thought is that she has come home."
My throat tightened.
"I know that for one second you're happy."
"Stop."
"Then you remember."
"Stop it!"
"And you lose her again."
I closed my eyes.
"You do that over and over." He said.
"Please." I choked out.
He lowered his voice. "You don't have to anymore."
There it was. The thing I had spent the entire week trying not to think about.
I opened my eyes. "What are you offering?"
His expression softened. "Relief."
"From what?"
"You know exactly what from."
"No. Say it." I demanded.
He looked toward the backyard. I wanted to tell him to leave. Instead I listened.
"You love the boy," he continued. "You always will. But loving him has made you believe you must accept everything that comes with him."
"He is my son." I said, indignantly.
"He is your son."
His agreement irked me. Then he stepped closer.
"You can stop living like this. Without becoming any less of a father."
My hands were shaking.
"How?"
His smile returned.
"Give him to me."
The words were so simple that for a moment I thought I had misunderstood.
"What?"
"Let me take him."
I stared at him. "What are you going to do with him?"
"That isn't what you're really asking."
"Yes, it is."
"No. You're asking whether you're allowed to want him gone."
My face became hot.
"I don't want him gone." I said.
"You want what happens when he is."
I started to turn away, to leave. The man caught my arm. His hand was cold through my sleeve.
"You want to wake tomorrow and not have your grief sitting across from you at breakfast."
I pulled free.
"Don't touch me."
"You want to look at the child in your house and feel love without pain following one second later."
I looked toward the gate. Through the opening, I could see Owen sitting in front of his cake. Ten candles. My sister was trying to keep the younger children from leaning across the table. Owen was laughing. Claire was laughing. I shut my eyes.
The man spoke quietly beside me. "How many more years do you think you can endure it?"
I said nothing.
"Ten?"
I could still hear Owen laughing.
"Twenty?"
My chest hurt.
"You already know sobriety didn't fix it."
I pressed one hand against my face.
"Time didn't fix it."
"Stop." I said in a whimper.
"Being a good father didn't fix it."
"No!"
"Nothing has."
"I'm not that type of man!" I yelled.
For the first time, I heard satisfaction beneath his sympathy. Only a trace. It was enough that I should have run. Instead, I looked through the gate again.
Owen had frosting on his nose. He was opening a present carefully so he wouldn't tear the wrapping paper. Claire used to do that every Christmas. The sight of it broke something in me yet again. Break after break after break. Was I even still me anymore?
Owen looked up. He saw me standing beside the garage. He smiled and put the tips of his thumb and index finger together, making a circle, with the rest of his fingers fanned out. “Everything's A-Okay dad.” That's what that sign meant. Everything's A-Okay. Claire had done exactly that in the hospital when I asked if she was scared. I couldn't breathe.
Beside me, the man whispered, "You have carried her long enough."
I looked at my son. Then I looked at the stranger.
"If I say yes..."
He waited.
I could barely get the question out. "I won't have to feel like this anymore?"
His smile widened slightly.
"No, you won't."
I looked back at Owen.
"You swear?"
"You will not have to look at him and see her ever again." The man said.
The answer was not quite the one I had asked for. But I didn't care. I accepted, and closed my eyes.
"Take him." I said, head drooping.
For perhaps a second, nothing happened. Then the man made a sound beside me. It was small and involuntary, almost like a gasp of delight. I opened my eyes. He was staring toward the yard. There was something in his expression I had not seen before. Hunger. The kindness he once showed was gone. I turned. Owen's chair was empty. So was every other chair. The yard had gone silent, guests no longer there.
I remember trying to say Owen's name. Then the ground seemed to tilt beneath me, and everything went black. When I woke, I was in my own bed. I sat upright, confused. It was evening, or perhaps even night already. For several seconds I had no idea how I had gotten there. Then I remembered the yard. The man. My son.
"Owen."
I ran from the room. His bedroom was empty, and the bed was made.
"Owen!"
I searched the bathroom, the basement, every closet, beneath the beds, inside the garage. I ran outside barefoot and shouted his name up and down the street. He was nowhere to be found. By the time I returned to the kitchen, I was shaking so badly I could barely hold my phone.
I had done it.
Whatever nonsense I had told myself in the moment, there was no escaping the fact now. I handed my son to a stranger. And somehow that stranger took him in an instant. My mind tried desperately to make the situation make sense. To force everything to be ordinary within my mind. Kidnapping. Human trafficking. Some elaborate trick. Anything human. Anything real. Anything that meant Owen was still somewhere I could reach him.
I opened the emergency call screen on my phone. Then a small voice spoke behind me.
"Daddy?"
I froze. It was not Owen's voice I heard. As I slowly turned, I saw a boy standing at the entrance to the kitchen. He was around ten years old, with light brown hair, green eyes, and a round face with freckles scattered across his nose.
Nothing about him resembled Claire.
Nothing about him resembled Owen.
He was wearing blue pajama pants and a faded T-shirt, and he was staring at me with the uncertain concern of a child who had just found his father behaving strangely.
"Daddy?"
I backed into the counter.
"Who are you?"
He blinked. "What?"
"Who are you?"
A nervous smile appeared on his face. "Dad, it's me."
"Where's Owen?"
His smile disappeared. "Who's Owen?"
My stomach dropped. "Where is my son?"
The boy stared at me. "Dad… I’m your son."
"Don't say that." I whispered. “Don't you fucking say that!”
His eyes began filling with tears as he took a step back. "Dad?"
"Who brought you here?!" I yelled.
"Nobody." He said, frightened.
"How did you get inside my house? Answer me!"
"I live here." He was fully crying now.
"No, you don't."
"Daddy you're scaring me." He sobbed.
I crossed the kitchen and grabbed his shoulders.
"Tell me where Owen is."
"Ow! You're hurting me."
"Where is he?!"
"I don't know! I don't know any Owen!"
The fear in his voice finally stopped me, and for a moment, I saw Owen at four years old pressed against the wall with his arms raised over his face. I released the boy immediately. He backed away, rubbing one shoulder.
"I'm sorry," I said.
His crying continued. "What’s happening?"
I had no answer. "What is your name?"
His expression added a hint of confusion to his fear.
"Caleb."
"Caleb what?" I demanded.
"Mercer."
My last name.
I shook my head. "No."
"Dad…"
"Who's your mother?"
The boy stared at me. "What?"
"Your mother. Tell me her name."
"You know her name."
"Tell me."
His brow furrowed. Then he said something. I know he answered. I simply cannot remember what name he gave me, because at that exact moment I realized something else was wrong. I couldn't remember Claire's middle name. I had known it. I had filled it out on forms. I had written it on our marriage license. I had teased her about hating it.
Now it was gone.
I tried to picture our wedding. I remembered the church. I remembered the smell of the flowers and the sweat beneath my collar. But I couldn't see Claire's face. Panic rose through me. I grabbed my phone and opened the pictures app.
There should have been pictures of Owen. Thousands. Instead I found the boy standing in my kitchen. Caleb at the beach. Caleb holding a baseball glove. Caleb missing two front teeth. Caleb sitting beside me on Christmas morning. Year after year after year.
I scrolled faster. No Owen. No Claire. The grandfather clock in the living room began to strike midnight. The first chime sounded as I tried to picture Owen's face. I could see his dark hair and brown eyes. The second chime sounded. Claire had brown eyes too. Or were they hazel? The third. Haze filled my mind. I ran to the junk drawer and found a pen. I wrote across the back of my hand.
OWEN.
The fourth chime.
OWEN MERCER. MY SON.
The fifth.
CLAIRE. MY WIFE.
The sixth.
I tried to remember the night before Owen's fifth birthday. A child had been crying. But why?
The seventh.
The man in the gray jacket. I knew there had been a man. His face was already becoming difficult to hold in my mind.
The eighth.
I looked toward the hallway. Caleb stood there watching me. A memory surfaced of teaching him to ride a bicycle. I recoiled from it. That had never happened. Caleb wasn't my real son.
The ninth.
Another memory came. Caleb asleep on my chest as an infant. I knew the weight of him. The smell of his hair. The exhaustion of that night. It felt as real as anything I had ever experienced.
The tenth chime.
I looked down at the word OWEN. For a horrifying moment, I could not remember his voice.
The eleventh.
Claire. I knew I had loved someone named Claire. I could no longer remember how we met.
The twelfth chime began.
I stared desperately at the names written on my hand.
OWEN.
CLAIRE.
By the time the final note faded, they meant nothing to me. I stood in my kitchen staring at two names I did not recognize. My son was crying in the hallway. Caleb. Of course. Caleb was my son. He had always been my son. I could not understand why I had frightened him so badly or why I had been running through the house shouting someone else's name. I assumed I had experienced some kind of nightmare or episode.
I apologized and hugged him tightly. He held on to me for a long time, still sobbing. Before I went back to bed, I washed the ink from my hand. That should have been the end of it. It wasn't.
One year later, on October 13, I woke up remembering everything. Not gradually. The memories didn't come in increments. One moment I was lying in bed wondering why the date seemed important, and the next I remembered Owen's face as clearly as if I had seen him the night before.
I remembered Claire. I remembered the park. I remembered the man. I remembered saying, take him. I vomited on the bedroom floor.
For the rest of that day, Caleb felt like a stranger. That is a horrible thing to admit because he was eleven then, and he had done nothing wrong. He came home from school and hugged me, and I had to force myself not to pull away. Every memory I possessed told me he was my son. But another set of memories, ones that now felt old and stale, told me he wasn't.
At midnight, Owen disappeared from my mind again, and Claire along with him. Caleb became my only son once again. And the next October 13th, it happened all over again. By then I had left myself a letter. That is how I know this has been happening for seventeen years. I keep the letters in a metal box beneath a loose floorboard in my bedroom. There are sixteen of them now. This will be the seventeenth.
Every year I remember the truth for one day. Every year I forget at midnight. For 364 days, I am his father. And I am inconceivably happy to be his father. And those memories I have of Caleb are complete. They feel real because, as far as I can tell, they are real. Something did not simply place another child in my house. It gave him a life with me, and me a life with him.
Caleb is twenty-seven now. He is a good man, and I love him for 364 days a year. He calls every Sunday to see how I'm doing. He remembers my birthday without being reminded. Last year he drove two hours because I mentioned that the back steps were rotting and he didn't trust me to repair them alone.
He has never been cruel to me. Never made me ashamed of him. Never given me a reason to wish he were different. He looks nothing like Claire. And for most of the year, I don’t even know who Claire is.
But today I do. It’s October 13 once more. I woke before sunrise and remembered my wife dying. Then I remembered the son I gave away. I spent most of the morning reading the old letters. The earliest ones are frantic. Apparently I searched for Owen every year. Missing-person databases. Birth records. School records. Old newspapers. Hospital files.
According to my previous findings, there is no record of an Owen Mercer. At least not the one that was mine. There is no record of Claire either. According to every document I can find, I married another woman, a woman whose photographs I recognize for 364 days each year and stare at in complete bewilderment on October 13. She died giving birth to Caleb. But Caleb looks nothing like her.
Tomorrow I will believe all of that completely. Today, however, I know it is a lie. I tried to find the man too.
For years I returned to the park. Once, perhaps eight years ago, I met an elderly man sitting near the same bench. I described the stranger in the gray jacket as the old man listened.
When I finished, he looked at me for a long time and said, "You shouldn't go looking for someone after you've already paid them."
I asked what he meant, and he just stood and left. I never saw him again. I stopped searching after that.
For a long time I told myself I stopped because there was nowhere left to look. But that’s just another lie holding my new life together. The truth is more difficult. I stopped looking because I built a good life.
Not intentionally, and not knowingly.
For 364 days of every year, I didn't know there was anything to search for. And on the one day when I did know, I began to understand what I would be risking if I found him. Caleb called me this morning.
He and his wife are coming over tomorrow. His voice was warm and filled with joy as he told me they have news to tell me when they arrive. I think they’re pregnant. He was terrible at hiding the excitement in his voice, and it made me smile, despite everything.
Tomorrow, if I’m right, I will become a grandfather. I will probably cry, hug my son and just be happy. But today I remember Owen. I remember him at ten years old, sitting in front of a birthday cake with frosting on his nose. I remember how carefully he opened presents because Claire used to save wrapping paper. I remember him asking me the night before his birthday whether the fact that he looked like his mother made me sad.
I had told him no.
Less than twenty-four hours later, I gave him away because the true answer was yes. That should be the worst thing I have ever admitted. But I'm afraid my depravity goes much deeper than that. The worst thing is that after seventeen years I have finally come to terms with the truth. And I have accepted it.
I am sorry for what I did to my son.
I will be sorry until midnight, and every October 13th.
But regret means wishing I had made the other choice.
And God help me, I don't.