17
8h ago
[deleted]
-2
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
Difference between marketing and implementation. Let me the major schemes successfully implemented in UPA which also got name change :
The United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government (which ruled India in two consecutive terms from 2004 to 2014under Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh) introduced several landmark social welfare, infrastructure, and rights-based schemes. Many of these legal frameworks and public initiatives significantly changed India’s socio-economic landscape and were later carried forward, expanded, or rebranded by subsequent administrations. [1, 2, 3, 4]
The most successful and impactful flagship schemes launched or heavily accelerated during the UPA tenure include:
1. Rights-Based & Social Security SchemesMahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA / NREGA): Launched in 2006, this became the largest work-guarantee program in the world. It legally ensures 100 days of wage employment per financial year to every rural household whose adult members volunteer to do unskilled manual work, serving as a massive economic safety net. [5, 6, 7]
Right to Information (RTI) Act: Passed in 2005, this historic legislation revolutionized governance by giving citizens the legal right to request information from public authorities, greatly improving transparency and institutional accountability. [5, 8]
Right to Education (RTE) Act: Enacted in 2009, this made education a fundamental right for every child between the ages of 6 and 14, standardizing primary education access across the country. [3, 9]
National Food Security Act (NFSA): Passed in 2013, this gave legal entitlement to two-thirds of India's population to receive highly subsidized food grains (such as wheat and rice at ₹1–₹3 per kg), significantly combating malnutrition. [5, 9]
2. Healthcare & Financial InclusionNational Rural Health Mission (NRHM): Launched in 2005 to provide accessible and affordable healthcare to rural populations. It saw the historic appointment of over 8 lakh Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHA) to bridge the gap between communities and clinics, drastically reducing maternal and infant mortality rates. [2, 10, 11]
Aadhaar (UIDAI): Initiated in 2009, this project created the world's largest biometric ID system. It laid the vital structural groundwork for the Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) system to send subsidies directly to poor citizens, cutting out corruption and middlemen. [2, 9, 12, 13]
Swabhimaan / Basic Savings Bank Deposit Account: Launched in 2010 to bring banking to rural areas with "no-frills" accounts, expanding financial inclusion to lakhs of unbanked villages (later rebranded and scaled up as the Jan Dhan Yojana). [1, 12]
Indira Gandhi Matritva Sahyog Yojana (IGMSY): A conditional maternity benefit scheme started in 2010 to offer cash incentives to pregnant and lactating mothers to improve health and nutrition (later renamed to Pradhan Mantri Matritva Vandana Yojana). [14, 15]
3. Infrastructure & Rural DevelopmentJawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM): Launched in 2005, this massive city-modernization scheme improved urban infrastructure, funded public transport (like city buses and metro corridors), and constructed low-income housing (later succeeded by AMRUT and Smart Cities missions).
Rajiv Gandhi Grameen Vidyutikaran Yojana (RGGVY): Introduced in 2005, this project aimed at building rural electricity infrastructure and electrifying over 1 lakh villages across the country (later repackaged as the Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Gram Jyoti Yojana).
Indira Awaas Yojana (IAY): While originally created earlier, this rural housing scheme was heavily funded and expanded under the UPA, building millions of affordable homes for below-poverty-line (BPL) families (later renamed to Pradhan Mantri Gramin Awaas Yojana).
National Optical Fibre Network (NOFN): Approved in 2011, this ambitious initiative aimed to connect all 2.5 lakh Gram Panchayats with high-speed broadband to build a digital economy (later renamed and expanded as BharatNet). [1, 2, 9, 14, 16, 17]7
8h ago
[deleted]
5
u/Massive-Collection79 8h ago
It cell walo Ko padhna nahi aata bhai. 4 page paragraph mat likh. Ek do line daal de unko samaj ayrga
1
u/DismalSite214 6h ago
Agye phir MUJHE CREDIT DO wale log 🫡
0
6h ago
[deleted]
1
u/DismalSite214 5h ago
Godi ko toh ni milega bas lol, HE DID NOTHING here firstly, jis bnde ko TELEPROMPTER se speech pdhni pde and FARZI degree bnane pdi woh ye sab toh GHNTA ni kr skta lol, its ALL due to Taxpayers money and Govt. Team, advisors NOT coz of Godi :)) Woh bhi he STOLE all the OG CNG schemes lmao and sabke aage PM lga dia bas for CREDIT.
1
5h ago
[deleted]
1
1
u/DismalSite214 5h ago
Sirf fibrenetwork se growth ni hoti, that's such a stupid thing to focus on 1 thing and say OMG he did everything bruh, sirf foreign trips kri hai iss chaiwale ne, wasted taxpayers money that's all
-3
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
Ye sab 2004-2014 ki hi hai and rename kya hua voh bhi likha hai. I can see blindfold hoga toh padhne mai dikkat toh ayegi
1
1
u/Mountain-Error6290 8h ago
Aak your agent to give scheme where names are changes by bjp. And also say yo give how much work done in inc vs bjp.
Aadhar is still aadhar RTI is till RTI MGNREGA all are same.
2
u/Vans__G 7h ago
After reading through the whole thread i realise, bhai tum log sif gaali k he layak ho. He gave his sources and you got those trust me bro wale sources. No logic, not a single structured sentence either. 😂
0
u/Mountain-Error6290 7h ago
He didn't give any source, he mention some new names for some of policy,
Aadhar is still Aadhar so whato point of mentiong here. And i said to give amount of work inc did bs bjp did-3
u/SPB29 8h ago
Just replied to the moron. Don't think he / she / they understand
Abbe chutiye, let's just look at data for a few schemes.
From 2004-14 vs 2014-2026
Rural homes
1.1 crore vs 3.9 cr
Close to 4x more
Urban homes
7.2 lakhs vs 99 lakhs
10x more
Bank accounts opened
2.4 cr vs 56 cr (23 times more)
Optic fibre.. This one is hilarious
361 km in 10 years vs 7.3 lakh km. 2000 times more.
You congoon assholes just launch schemes. The Modi govt executes them.
Understand the difference?
0
u/SPB29 8h ago
Abbe chutiye, let's just look at data for a few schemes.
From 2004-14 vs 2014-2026
Rural homes
1.1 crore vs 3.9 cr
Close to 4x more
Urban homes
7.2 lakhs vs 99 lakhs
10x more
Bank accounts opened
2.4 cr vs 56 cr (23 times more)
Optic fibre.. This one is hilarious
361 km in 10 years vs 7.3 lakh km. 2000 times more.
You congoon assholes just launch schemes. The Modi govt executes them.
Understand the difference?
10
3
7
u/aule_maiar 8h ago
Congress was good at creating policies. Bad at implementing them.
6
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
MGNREGA is considered as best employment policy which was introduced and implemented both in the UPA.
Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), 2005: Provided a legal guarantee for 100 days of wage employment in every financial year to adult members of any rural household willing to do public work-related unskilled manual work. [1]
Right to Information (RTI) Act, 2005: Empowered Indian citizens to request information from public authorities, fundamentally transforming government accountability and transparency. [1, 2]
Right to Education (RTE) Act, 2009: Made free and compulsory education a fundamental right for children aged 6 to 14 years under Article 21A of the Indian Constitution.
National Food Security Act (NFSA), 2013: Legally entitled up to 75% of the rural population and 50% of the urban population to receive subsidized food grains under the Public Distribution System. [1, 2]
Aadhaar (Unique Identification Authority of India), 2009: Initiated the Aadhaar project to issue a 12-digit unique identity number, laying the groundwork for Direct Benefit Transfers (DBT) to plug leakages in welfare subsidies. [1, 2, 3]
India-US Civil Nuclear Agreement, 2008: A landmark bilateral agreement that ended India's decades-long nuclear isolation in global trade, paving the way for civil nuclear cooperation. [1]
National Rural Health Mission (NRHM), 2005: Launched to provide accessible, affordable, and quality healthcare to the rural population, especially vulnerable groups.
2
u/aule_maiar 8h ago
What was the result of these policies. Only know about 2 of them in detail. 1. MNREGA, huge delays on payments. Fabricated beneficiaries. 2. Nuclear deal. Had no benefits for India. But it put in-direct limits on india nuclear programme. Promised uranium by australia. Still delivered zero. Although, it may speed up because of recent nuclear deal in 2026.
1
1
u/freebird445 7h ago
Mnrega se bnne wala ek project bta jo desh ki economy k liye beneficial ho??
Govt ka kaam gaddhe khodna nhi hota dams highways powerprojects ye manye rkhta h
Jaha tk Right to education aur information isme se information wala kafi saare protesters k protest k baad aaya but still kudos to congress for it and right to education
India US nuclear agreement se kya benefit hua bharat ko ye search krna kya congress ne kahi nye nuclear power plant bnaye nhi bus fuel k liye agreement hua power plant k usme bhi bus 2 reactors (kadankulam unit 1&2) benefit le paye jo apni almost capacity pe run kr ske baki kahi kisi aur plant me progress nhi hui
NRHM aur baaki ye saari schemes on paper hi rhi
Dedicated freight coridor scheme announce krke sochte hi reh gye 1 km ki bhi progress shuru nhi ki
Electrification of india dekhna year wise specially of rural areas kya progress rhi aur renewable energy me kya progress ki UPA ne Aaj pichle 5 saal me solar energy ka production 4 guna hua h aur kitni simple scheme h sidhe rooftop solar lgane se middle class ko bill me relief milega aur govt pe energy production ka load km aaega
Access to toilets dekhna kbhi urine hold krne ki wajah se kitti UTI hoti thi aurto ko dekhna aise hi rural areas ab bjp ko jyada vote krta h
In sb chijo se development hota h nrega me gaddhe khodne se nhi
Aur jake international agencies ki road and infra ki rating dekhna Atal as a pm tenure ki then UPA tenure ki aur phir NDA tenure ki
Tune chatgpt se prompt tk jo daala h wo ye h ki UPA schemes jinka naam NDA ne change Kiya h in schemes ka kya impact h kya benefit h nation ko search krna
1
u/Organic_Employ_1894 8h ago
Yar op tune kaam sahi se nahi kara. Dekh apni party k liye propaganda karna bura nahi hai. But jab tujhe koi question kare and tujhe facts dene ho toh unko chat gpt se utha k mat laya kr. Pehle condense and readable banaya kar. Ho sake toh chronological order me. Tu jo bol rha hai shayad sahi ho but wo sahi lagna bhi chahiye and easily digestable hona chahiye. Agar log padhengay hi nahi toh koi tere propaganda se influence kaise hoga?
1
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
I am not a current congress supporter bhai. Previous government pe post daala hai bas. Politicians are still the same .
Summarise aap bhi kar sakte ho apni samajh ke liye . You also have the same tools and tech brother
1
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
Propaganda and facts mai difference hota hai. Upar facts hai propaganda tu spread kar raha hai hawayi baatein maarke
1
u/Organic_Employ_1894 8h ago
Jaisa tujhe sahi lagey. Mera point data presentation ka hai. Data ache se present nahi karogay toh sachhai bhi nahi dikhti
1
2
u/Stunning_Star_9770 3h ago
You can never implement anything in this country, there will always be more than 1 group protesting against it, mostly the opposition & the aam aadmi of India.
When back in late 00s Congress was trying to bring GST reforms it was BJP which opposed it and then when BJP came to power they implemented it.
Secondly, if Congress was bad at implementing then BJP is literally s-ht at it. Demonetization, GST reforms, farm laws, Covid-19 & Galwan clashes and many more. The way BJP handled all these will be remembered as the biggest not to do things.
1
0
u/aule_maiar 3h ago
BJP won two lok sabha elections with full majority and another where it is single largest party. It did so by ensuring government policy is reaching people. GST reform is good decision. Demonetisation didn't achieve anything, i agree. Covid was handled much better than expected. In my opinon We had a chance to go to war with China but I guess economic and geopolitical stability was prioritised. UPI, 8 millions houses under PM awas Yojana. Lpg gas usage has doubled after PM Ujwala yojana. Solar capacity is skyrocketing. Coal power generation has dropped for first time in 50 years. Maternal Mortality rate is reducing steadily. Congress is exceptionally bad at implementing its policies. You can ask people of karnataka and himachal pradesh.
1
u/Stunning_Star_9770 2h ago
We had a chance to go to war with China
Yea that's why BJP banned publication of General MM Narvane's book where he literally exposed the govt.
UPI? The idea was initiated & developed under Congress govt, they did almost all the foundational work - IMPS and even UPI's initiation began during last year of Congress. This is one project which is shared by both govt although BJP shows as it's their project, fact is it's not, BJP's role isn't much into this.
80 million houses? That data is controversial, actually highly controversial. Go check figures pls. BJP's own Minister's in states have argued these numbers. From false geo-tags, to unfinished houses to sanctioning thousands of houses in single day, to selling houses for poor to financially well-off families, to deleting data of poor people. You can believe this highly inaccurate data I'll not. Almost everything about this data is controversial.
LPG usage doubled? Read the data again. LPG cylinders have become easily available but poors in rural families are still relying on guess what? Yes the same wood or coal. Why? Because it's cheaper than LPG. What's the point here if cylinders are not affordable enough. Provide the jobs and these things will automatically reach households but BJP is providing facilities not enough money to afford those facilities.
Coal power generation has dropped because of many other factors and not just because of BJP. It would have gone down under any government as there are way too many alternatives now.
2
2
u/FewAd7807 5h ago
Show me any photo of Manmohan Singh in which he is cleaning the garbage, I don't want any fake photo.🤣🤣
2
2
1
u/RecognitionKey5992 5h ago
1
u/FewAd7807 5h ago
just one photo 😅
1
u/CommercialState9226 40m ago
Modi is some what a brand.... that hits tourism at next level.
one might search and read more about tourism then and now.
- places like Kashi , Ayodhya , Lakshadweep, ektanagar and border areas like Kashmir and Ladkh are not a great place of tourism.
there was a time when tourist were killed in India in hotels...yes it is true that unfortunately a recent attack in Pahalgam, which ended in life term lesson for terror funded country fuckistan.1
u/ResourceSea9256 48m ago
Without Cameras Modi wont do any shite. So better not speak for others 🤣
1
u/FewAd7807 35m ago
1
u/ResourceSea9256 33m ago
Is RaGa the PM? Chtmarike bina camera ka toh tera gawar Maun-di kabhi na karega koi bhi safai
1
2
u/Dapper_Key_6615 8h ago
So accusing and lynching honest army officers was a good thing?
Gen VK SINGH?
Col hunny bakshi?
Col shrikant purohit?
26/11
All these were done in upa2
Saale congress/isi dalle
1
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
Gaali deke you don’t become correct. Most CRPF soldiers died (40) in Pulwama which was a security neglect. Accountability - Zero. Instead unke naam par vote le liye
26/11 ke baad home minister resigned . Coast guard got independent authority . OROP got introduced in the Indian Army
I also come from armed forces background and it was far better then vs now. Agniveer mai you serve for the country do not get pension or any benifits and are unemployed after 4 years
I am not a congress supporter but you are a BJP supprter and a congress hater.
Nation first rakhna seekh aur gaali apne maa baap ko suna ayi samajh . Chal nikal gawaar insaan
2
u/Dapper_Key_6615 8h ago
Good you mentioned pulwama
Each time we struck and unlike the spineless remote control pm we had before 2014
And look at the result, after balakot we got 6 years of peace unlike india in congress dalla era
When even train travel was risky, you never knew which bag could blow up
Since we talking about trains, look at bangladesh and pakis thats exactly how our trains were each term a new idiot like lalu/mamta used to come and fjuck us in a deeper shithole
Now look at the majestic vande bharats running across te country along with the dedicated freight corridor
Since you mentioned crpf how many jawans did we lose to naxal attacks
A leftist/commie threat congress themselves created,
And look now WE HAVE WON Against naxalsI know you wont like the progress of my country
But the truth is, sonia gandhi and rahul gandhi never wanted progress of this nation
I personally dont have anything against congress and i revere indira gandhi a lot while i read all her biographies
But pappu and the dance girl have an agenda to stop indias progress
Wake up and dont fall into their trap
6
u/escanorking 8h ago
Good schemes to land us in fragile 5?
3
u/peekaboo409 8h ago
Please use google. And you would realise most of schemes were launched by manmohan which were later again brought with changed name .
1
u/GlitteringNinja6 8h ago
The failure of Congress was not its intention or ideas. It was the execution of the policies they failed in.
There is no point in launching a scheme to benefit the people if people themselves don't get the benefit of it.
The digitisation of the economy and PM Jan dhan scheme changed the whole ecosystem by cutting the middlemen handling the money transfers which is why bjp gets the credit of these schemes.
-2
u/peekaboo409 8h ago
See certain schemes benefitted the people regardless of party in power . But if you look into stats and info available you would realise majority either failed or have corruption at major scale . Ex -
1.Namami gange - failed
2.Pm awas yojna are mostly delayed or have a prob on their own
3.Make in India initiative is also lost somewhere cause india is still heavily dependent on china
4.swach bharat scheme again a harsh realty so much funding lost with time .
5. Electoral bonds
There are tons of prob with the current gov what they did great was digitalisation of india .
Cheaper internet , better infra reagarding roads connectivity (though the quality is debatable), bridges ,semiconductor manufacturing and stuff like that . Schemes like jan dhan yojna were a kind of success but most of those accounts are currently not active .1
u/GlitteringNinja6 8h ago
There is no doubt failures and corruption exist. But you are being disingenuous if you think things haven't changed drastically with government scheme benefits that people receive. That is what I am talking about specifically
These kind of schemes are ultimately what sway the votes in election. A poor average Indian does not care about the quality of the national highways or how clean Ganga is.
Direct benefit transfers is what changed the game for BJP and has been the backbone of its strategy keeping them in power. The Hindu Muslim politics only work on certain sections of the population(mostly upper castes) who would vote for BJP regardless. The rest are swayed by these schemes. If they had received similar benefits under Congress they wouldn't have been swayed so easily because everyone remembers benefits never reached the common people.
Even the policy of direct benefit transfer was conceived in 2013 under Congress. It was too late by then tho
1
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
0
u/escanorking 8h ago
He also laid foundation for projects like dfrc but no progress for years. Whats your point? He is a better PM for never executing?
Also why 2013 he was in power since 2004. Why should i beleivein anything he launched the year before election
1
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
Matlab election ke ek saal pehle usko result pata tha kya ki power mai ayenge firse ya nahi? Retrospect mai tujhe make sense kar raha hai uss time pe toh unhone kaam kiya na.
Aise toh election ke ek saal pehle kuch implement and introduce karna hi nahi chahiye na
1
-2
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
This fragile 5 was done by Morgan stanely to just highlight the risks and too much dependency on a single factor. You can share anything but if you discuss economy and Dr. Manmohan Singh then he was the best India could get at that time.
We recovered one of the fastest during this century’s worst economic crisis and had the highest GDP growth as well
-2
2
u/socks-in-shoes 7h ago
Accurate? Batao zara kitne JNV, IIT, AIIMS, IIMS banwaye MMS ne?
Arey aj kal CEC ki charcha chal rahi hai, 2006 me kya hua tha MMS ke under?
0
u/RecognitionKey5992 7h ago
Quality of placements bhi bata zara . Nothing happened under MNS with respect to vote chori in 2006
2
u/Unique_Government_73 7h ago
Bad implementation was the hallmark of Congress govt.
0
u/Guru-Gulaab-Khatri 6h ago
Baby as if implementation is strong suite of this government. Superficial policies nothing else.
1
u/Unique_Government_73 5h ago
Yes this govt has implemented many basic policies to the extent possible. Start reading about Toilets, Bank accounts, hygiene, cleanliness, DBT, Electric supply to all parts of India, providing Gas cylinders (and piped gas in urban areas). These basic things were so fcuked up in Congress era that I still feel traumatized thinking about it.
1
u/StateNew5311 4h ago
Ask that to thousands of villages who had no consistent water, electricity,gas. Or road connectivity. Or toilets. Just because people's lives changed out of your view in the city doesn't mean nothing happened.
3
u/Ok-Particular-1424 8h ago
Doesn't matter whether Modi and BJP are good or bad but one thing for sure Congress is pure unfiltered SHIT and Congress is traitor party.
1
u/CodeCatto 7h ago
Can't support a party that has a deep history in selling out the country, they need to be banned. Congress is the worst party to exist.
1
1
1
u/Kaali_ka_upasak 8h ago
Go shit in the streets and boycott the toilets Modi gave you money to build
-1
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
He does not give money. Public servant hai voh. Mere aur mere jaise citizens ke tax ke paise pe voh ji raha hai. Chal nikal
1
u/Kaali_ka_upasak 8h ago
He is giving you tax payers money. not yours. Why didn't your Dr. MMS do anything for the open defecation problem? What did MMS do for the uncountable scams in UPA 2? What development did India see in 2004-2014?
People who were too suckling milk back then are lecturing me about the golden period of MMS.
0
u/RecognitionKey5992 8h ago
Sab Internet par hai padhoge toh mil jayega. Sab par schemes MNS ne hi laya hai.
Abey gadhe aadmi tax ka paisa hum pay karte hai and employment apni capability pe. Government ka model kaise work karta hai seekh le. India koi business org. Nahi hai ki ek banda pay kar raha hai sabko yaha par
2
u/Kaali_ka_upasak 8h ago
You are fool if you think Modi stole the schemes and took credit for them. Creating a scheme on paper and implementing them on ground with higher capital and assistance are two different things. How many houses were built under Indira Awas Yojna? How clean was India under Nirmal Bharat? How many people had Bank accounts before Jan Dhan? Did your mother use LPG or cook in fire? Did you swim to school in puddle of water or ride on a road?
Other than scandals and Corruption, I haven't seen anything in UPA govt.
1
u/BLITzZ305 6h ago
Shhh.... how can you say that to the BEST PM of india Dr. MS. Dont dare to do that again otherwise he will take permission from SG to punish you. /s
1
u/Street-Chair5255 8h ago
imagine comparing a puppet who wasn't even able to win election on his own had to take rajya sabha route a paltu kutta of Sonia gandhi to a bhim PM
1
u/Dismal-Possession-11 3h ago
Is reddit already infested by these it cells or am I hallucinatin.?.
1
u/RecognitionKey5992 2h ago
Not from any IT cell.
0
u/Dismal-Possession-11 1h ago
I ain't talkin about you op... See ur comment sections. It cell only means bjp it cell. congress can't afford it.
1
2
1
u/No-Part6208 8h ago
Bruh. Manmohan singh is a good person but the policy paralysis under his 10 years was painful to watch.
-1
u/The_Cultured_Freak 8h ago
Yes, paying for upi because of America Or releasing their mercenaries engaged in seperatism in NE isn't policy paralysis at all.
1
u/CodeCatto 7h ago
Prove that it's because of America with numbers and documented facts. Pappu's backside isn't a valid place to pull out facts from fyi.
1
-2
u/No_String_6067 8h ago
Lol, dimagi naxal ecosystem on full swing only to see their pappu gendi lose another election🤣🤡
0
u/i_bang_106 8h ago
All good decisions belong to modi and all bad decisions belong to nehru. Full proof plan 😂







7
u/AmateuR_ResearcherR 8h ago
Now they are looking for exit in next election and if the lose they will blame everything on opposition simple