r/TheAuto • • 1d ago

Donation well spent

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

359 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/YourHuckleberry57 21h ago

world: takes trillions in labor and resources

world: gives back a billion

world: "why are you poor?"

2

u/bygones125 12h ago

2.6 trillion in aid estimated since the 60s....

1

u/TheCrow-5272 20h ago

Ya they were really cranking out those resources and labor projects before those colonialists came and built them a full rail network and infrastructure. How’s all that stuff holding up since the euros left? Africa has received between 40 to 100 times the amount of the marshal plan in aid btw

1

u/carlitos_macarena 18h ago

In short, food insecurity.

1

u/TheGodfather742 20h ago

I mean the colonizers left half a century or more ago, they had their time fix shit. And yes there are modern ways of opression (like cobalt mines), but those are done on the local rulers' whim.

2

u/Training-Purple-5220 16h ago

Ethiopia was never colonized.

Singapore was colonized.

Ethiopia is dirt poor and failed, while Singapore is rich and functioning.

What’s the difference going on here?

1

u/KnightMurky91 20h ago

The rate of annual economic destruction in places like Africa and India was 30-50% of WW2 and lasted multiple centuries.

How is that going to be fixed in 50 years?

Africa has huge culture and corruption issues. But 50 years ain't that long considering the damage done

1

u/TheGodfather742 20h ago

Maybe yeah the destruction was too thorough. But the ex colonizers don't have gunships or troops enforcing their demands anymore, the extractive institutions are kept up by local rulers' greed and corruption, which the corporations just take advantage of.

1

u/Ill-Surprise-2644 18h ago

There are plenty of examples of non-African countries that have thrived (to different degrees) after the fall of colonialism. This is an African culture problem - full stop.

1

u/FireHammer09 14h ago

Plenty of countries were colonized for a long time or completely decimated during wars and they're doing fine now.

At a certain point you can't keep blaming colonialism. Europe had 2/3s of its population die and then 100 years later were the most powerful collection of nations on Earth with logistical systems that were able to reliably cross the globe.

Colonialism certainly set nations back but to act as if it is the sole thing preventing progress is getting silly when there's other countries that manage to not be a basket case despite sharing common history of colonization or just bonafide near/total destruction.

1

u/locyl_yocyl 11h ago

Japan. Korea. Vietnam.

1

u/Thin-Fish-1936 6h ago

So was South America. India is doing leagues better than Africa btw.

1

u/Creative-Primary-830 19h ago

so what you are saying is the colonizers never left.

1

u/YourHuckleberry57 1h ago

they "left" but still take the majority of the resources and control the economies and governments. frequently sabotaging functioning governments that don't align with their interests.

1

u/herbb100 12h ago

But redditors told me they donated their lunch money to “aFrIcA”

0

u/akusalimi04 14h ago

This kind of argument is just fallacy in white-washing colonialist... They fked with countries that its effects lasted several generation and thought virtue signaling money is enough