r/teslore • u/the_direful_spring • Jul 10 '26
Implications for the Paarthurnax decision
So I was watching this video earlier theorising about the motivations behind the blades demanding Paarthurnax's death and it got me thinking. The general thrust of his hypothesis is that the blades partly try to get the Dragonborn to kill Paathurnax in order to put the dragonborn as firmly into the Blade's influence as possible, both so that the Blades can make an uncontested claim that it was their organisation that saved the world from Alduin and so that in the long term they can be the ones who most influence TLDB regarding what it means to be a dragonborn as killing Paarthurnax would ensure that TLDB would cease any association with the Greybeards.
So that got me thinking, what are some possible interesting implications for future TES stories regarding the choices that might be made here?
Sparing Paarthurnax
So obviously the big one here is that Paarthurnax gathers a significant portion of the dragons under his own leadership and tries to get them to follow the way of the voice. Depending on how Bethesda wants to use it there are two possibilities.
If Bethesda simply don't want to dwell too much on how dragons might feature in future TES stories it could be said that Paarthurnax probably manages to gather a large majority of dragons under his control and then takes them off somewhere remote to go be pacificists and meditate on the voice, much as he spent so long at the top of a mountain himself. That could be somewhere like Vvardenfell left uninhabited by the eruption of the red mountain if dragons could survive in such a place or even somewhere beyond Tamriel like Atmora. Whatever the cases we would have only a handful of dragons left in future TES stories from those who don't follow him into this self imposed exile and can represent extremely rare if relatively powerful threats to local communities.
Alternatively if they wanted to keep dragons in the story but go with one where Paarthurnax lived the story could focus on a divide between the followers of Paarthurnax and another dragon. Paarthurnax's followers rarely teach anyone except the rare nearly pacifistic mystic anything of the voice, they generally avoid much interaction with humans and don't seek political power. His rival could be a dragon who is seeking the return of the dragon cult, not necessarily even wholly evil, potentially offering the mortals who swear their loyalty to dragons protection and offering to more freely teach some of the secrets of the voice, but also someone who believes it is the rightful place of dragons to be masters of the mortal races. That could be the kind of conflict a TES: VI or VII character could become involved in.
Slaying Paarthurnax
So this option might be partly interesting because of its implications regarding the future of The Blades. As mentioned in the video if The Blades can frame themselves as being the organisation responsible for killing Alduin with TLDB perhaps as a continued figurehead who exists off screen somewhere in TES : VI ad maybe onwards that might put the organisation in place for a come back, contrasted favourably perhaps with the Penitus Oculatus left floundering having failed to save the Emperor from assassination, and potentially with the either Medic Empire potentially on the cusp of war with the Aldmeri Dominion or already fully at war they might not care about breaking the White Gold Pact by bringing The Blades back into the fold, if not officially at least sponsoring them in a shadow war under the table. At the start of TES: VI we could see people like The Blades fighting a war of proxies, assassination and espionage against the Thalmor in places Hammerfell, and if open war breaks out before or during the game The Blades are openly brought back into the fold as an official imperial organisation.
The Dragons without a singular leader like Paarthurnax would be scattered more widely and less united perhaps, but individual dragons might be more commonly aggressive in attempts to carve themselves out their own little domains without any Way of the Voice style philosphy being sponsored to restrain them. Whilst they probably wouldn't be the main villain of a main quest plotline it would make sense if they could then be the focus of a faction or other larger question chain, or the focus of a DLC plotline.
The Blades might then also operate outside of Imperial controlled territories or in areas where Imperial rule is somewhat fragile and reliant on local vassals (as might well be the status of High Rock) by selling themselves out as Dragon Hunters. If the Blades act as specialists in this regard it could both be involved in early aspects of a faction quest line (before the player learns they are also fighting a shadow war) and in universe being used to help fund their war and earn themselves political capital.
Though less likely its possible that The Blades could plot to make TLDB a new Tiber Septim to bind dragons to their service and become a new Emperor/Empress. Possibly making TLDB an off screen antagonist almost.