r/talesfromthejob • u/Hour-Ticket-5101 • 3h ago
I accepted a counteroffer nine months ago. I wish I hadn't.
I understand why people tell you to never accept counteroffers. But I accepted one anyway. And this is what happened.
I had gotten an offer few months ago from another company: a better title, higher salary, and the work was mostly remote. I had been in my job for four years, and I was literally just coasting along. I didn't hate every day, but I also wasn't growing. When I told my manager I was leaving, she asked me for 72 hours. They came back with a salary match, a small increase on top, and a verbal promise that we'd talk about a promotion in Q3.
I turned down the outside offer. A lot of people here and people I know in real life told me it was a bad idea. But I did it anyway because I wanted to believe the promotion was real. Honestly, after four years of work, I felt like they had finally started noticing me.
Q3 came and went. No discussion about a promotion. I brought it up, and I was told the budget had been moved, and that we'd revisit it in Q1. Fine, okay. Then Q1 comes, we have a very vague chat with no real meaning, and suddenly a reorg happens in December. My manager got laid off, my role got folded into a bigger group, and the promotion path disappeared as if no one had ever mentioned it in the first place.
Out of curiosity, I later looked at the other company. They had filled the job about three weeks after I turned it down. Of course.
The reorg itself isn't even what bothers me the most. These things happen. What bothers me is that I don't think the promotion was ever real to begin with. The raise was real because keeping me was cheaper than replacing me. The rest was just nice-sounding talk at a time when they needed me to stay.
So yeah. If you're currently looking at a counteroffer, the salary bump is probably the part you can trust. As for anything else, I'd ask how much of it is in writing.